Ben Rapelessburger

Flynn had a few good games, but he does not consistently put up better than Rodgers.

Rodgers has the highest passer rating of all-time, and Peyton is a distant second.

Do you honestly think that the guy who holds the record for most interceptions is the 2nd best QB ever? He would make my list of top 20, but not top ten (actually top 9, since I left a spot for "other").

This. Graham, Starr, and Johnny U not getting enough credit here.

Stabauch & Bradshaw were awesome, especially playing against each other.

Joe Montana.

Fourth quarter....less than two minutes left...losing by 6....who do you want at QB?

We are sorry that you weren't good enough to make the team in high school, and that all the other kids laughed at you in gym class. Get over it.

When did Favre ever have a winning team around him and you have your answer what he was able to do with such scrubs was nothing short of amazing, he begged them to draft him weapons, if they would have listened to him and drafted Randy Moss and not wasted a pick on Vinnie Holiday, we'd of seen another dynasty.

Rodgers will never be in the same conversation with anyone on this list, he's not even from the same era, it's not even the same game.

Awww

I have to go with this.

exactly Joe Montana won big games like the super bowl when it was up to good decision making and skill.

 

Young and Montana.

No Favre? Pole fail.

ETA: I'm a Vikings guy so... yeah.

I think you are forgetting that when Favre's team won that single Superbowl, he also had a dominant defense, led by the great Reggie White. Combining that with a great punter and a great return guy, they almost always had a short field to work with. He didn't carry the whole team.

Edit: and Vonnie Holiday wasn't nearly as much of a wasted pick as Tony Mandarich, who they chose over Barry friggin Sanders. Can you imagine those 90s Packers with Barry carrying the ball?

+1

Peyton.

And I love Montana. I just think Peyton would have equaled or surpassed his numbers. He's clearly a superior NFL quarterback.

Peyton Manning.

That John Elway sunofagun sure wrecked my Chiefs a lot of times too.  

Joe Montana was up there too.

Dude, you're nuts. When he was an old man and went to KC, he was still fucking magic.

Joe Montana

Roger Staubach, grew up watching him, solid guy.

Tony Romo

One of the greatest MNF games ever.






 






















 

Definitely going with Peyton.

Ryan Leaf, hands down.

Where is Sammy, Sid, and Otto?

Poll fale!!

Poll limits you to ten choices. I picked the top 9 based primarily on their records, championships, and career passer ratings. You could NEVER make everyone agree on a top ten list.

Passer rating. Lol

Joe Montanas o line and Jerry Rice?

Where is Jamarcus Russell? This is the thread for worst qb of all time right

Because completion percentage, passing yards, touchdowns, and interceptions are meaningless when we are discussing the greatest quarterback, right?    What statistic would you prefer to use?

Dandy Don.

Yep...Automatic Otto far eclipses Montanilow and these other pretty boys. I'd also roger up for Bobby Lane and Y.A. Tittle, just because they were tough bastards who could take a hit.

TERRY FUCK ING BRADSHAW

Aaron Rodgers /thread.

Montana

You're wrong:










 
 

Kurt Warner.  Only QB to take two different teams to the Superbowl.  Rams were 4-12 the year before he became the starter, 14-2 and Superbowl champs the next season with him.  The Cardinals were mediocre without him, and would have been Superbowl champs had their defense been able to hold that last drive, after he brought the Cardinals back in the 4th quarter.

The fastest release I've ever seen combined with the best ability to hit receivers perfectly in stride.

Oops. Forgot that Manning has now done it as well and Craig Morton did it first.

Montana was good, but I honestly think Young was better; his total numbers just never got there because of the concussion thing - and his wisdom at getting out.

But best EVER? Manning. Aaron Rodgers has a chance to be close, some day, as does Andrew Luck. Both are ahead of Manning where Manning was at their Age/Experience. The thing is, though... Manning keeps getting BETTER.

Nobody - NOBODY - has been as good as Manning at his age. And he's at the peak. He's better than ever. It's scary. He's 38... and the best. Montana retired at 38... and he was a shadow of himself with KC.

I really think the test of a QB is his brains. Arm, legs, size... all that is purely secondary. Drew Brees is small. Manning is slow with a weak arm. Tom Brady is slower, with a weak arm. And those three are GREAT QB's... because of their brains. They know EXACTLY what to do in any given situation, and they'll just plain outthink you.

Manning is the best, the most intelligent of the current bunch. Young was incredibly smart; his career was just too short. Rodgers and Luck are very smart, have physical skills that nobody else in this post has, and are still growing as players.

There were great QB's in previous generations... but the current generation has learned, grown from them. They're standing on the shoulders of Giants; that's why they're taller.

My top 5:

1) Manning
2) Young
3) Montana
4) Rodgers
5) Brees

Caveat: Rodgers and especially Luck are nowhere near their peak. The PEAK for Elway and Farve was impressive... but their brains and their bodies both meshed for too short a time to make a greatest-all-time list. They both made incredibly stupid mistakes for long periods of time, trusting their physical skills over their brains... and it didn't always work. And there are others, like Russell Wilson, who look like they have the brains to make something amazing happen.

Caveat #2: I don't put as much credence as some in Super Bowls. That's a TEAM, not a personal, achievement, and the best teams often can get there, and win it, with a mediocre QB, or at least one that isn't the best in the league. I think you can look at teams like Peyton in Indy, Brees always, Rodgers until recently... those teams were dependant on their QB. But take the Tom Brady Pats... when they were dependant on Brady - they lost. When they were a good team even without him - they won. The GM has as much to do with that as the QB.

ETA: Marino. Could have been great. Maybe the best ever. Was never surrounded with even half as much talent as it would take to convince me of that. Huge numbers... But never when it counts. The Super Bowl statement above stands... for multiples. But to even be in this conversation, you've gotta have one.

Asu...Manning and Brady have weak arms?  Wtf are you smoking?

Christian Ponder

Posted Via AR15.Com Mobile

lol .... you have no idea what you are talking about



 

Well, look what we have here, a comedian!

 

No Favre in the poll? Fail.

Yep
Nailed it

The question was not "who threw the most picks of all time, then went to his former team's arch rivals just to spite them?".

WHERE THE FUCK IS TROY AIKMAN?!!!!

POLL FAIL!!!

Only room for ten choices, and whiny bitches were automatically excluded.