User Panel
OK, this is a 100% hypothetical question. Do not mistake my asking it for my desire to actually TRY it.
What would happen if someone were to take a bit of black powder and put it in the tube before inserting the can for fire? Kaboom? I only ask because I was watching BP cannon videos and my mind wandered. |
|
Quoted:
OK, this is a 100% hypothetical question. Do not mistake my asking it for my desire to actually TRY it. What would happen if someone were to take a bit of black powder and put it in the tube before inserting the can for fire? Kaboom? I only ask because I was watching BP cannon videos and my mind wandered. View Quote The pressure created would shred the thin walled can to pieces, there is not enough pressure building up behind a 12oz can to blow up the aluminum tube... pressure is like electricity it will always take the path of least resistance if you were to take and press fit a chunk of aluminum in 1 of 2 things would happen A. get your "Kaboom" B. the bolt would be shot back into the receiver and the pressure would escape via the ejection port/destroyed receiver |
|
It may work in the longer tube but in the OEM launcher it would just blow up the can and stink to hell when you do. Anything more powerful than an M200 will blow up the cans.
They did a good job of safety testing the tube. |
|
Quoted:
It may work in the longer tube but in the OEM launcher it would just blow up the can and stink to hell when you do. Anything more powerful than an M200 will blow up the cans. They did a good job of safety testing the tube. View Quote And besides the stink, it'd be corrosive as all heck and make a big mess. I shoot black, but I'll never put it in an AR. I'd only dip into higher pressures via smokeless inside the blanks. If seeking longer range without popping cans, I'd try softening the blow to the can by using cardboard wadding when using more powerful blanks. I also think a powder that is ever so slightly slower in burn rate (than the blank powder in the M200) might get you farther in conjunction with a longer barrel. Just guessing on my part though. |
|
|
Quoted: The pressure created would shred the thin walled can to pieces, there is not enough pressure building up behind a 12oz can to blow up the aluminum tube... pressure is like electricity it will always take the path of least resistance if you were to take and press fit a chunk of aluminum in 1 of 2 things would happen A. get your "Kaboom" B. the bolt would be shot back into the receiver and the pressure would escape via the ejection port/destroyed receiver View Quote Bolt thrust says the bolt will be just fine where it is. Black powder would have a hard time generating enough pressure to compromise the barrel extension lugs or the bolt lugs. BP pressures are in the 10k-15k psi range. Smokeless 5.56 is in the 62,000 range on the high end. The shortest path out is through that tiny wall of aluminum. Either through the can or through the wall of the tube. |
|
Quoted:
Bolt thrust says the bolt will be just fine where it is. Black powder would have a hard time generating enough pressure to compromise the barrel extension lugs or the bolt lugs. BP pressures are in the 10k-15k psi range. Smokeless 5.56 is in the 62,000 range on the high end. The shortest path out is through that tiny wall of aluminum. Either through the can or through the wall of the tube. View Quote View All Quotes View All Quotes Quoted:
Quoted:
The pressure created would shred the thin walled can to pieces, there is not enough pressure building up behind a 12oz can to blow up the aluminum tube... pressure is like electricity it will always take the path of least resistance if you were to take and press fit a chunk of aluminum in 1 of 2 things would happen A. get your "Kaboom" B. the bolt would be shot back into the receiver and the pressure would escape via the ejection port/destroyed receiver Bolt thrust says the bolt will be just fine where it is. Black powder would have a hard time generating enough pressure to compromise the barrel extension lugs or the bolt lugs. BP pressures are in the 10k-15k psi range. Smokeless 5.56 is in the 62,000 range on the high end. The shortest path out is through that tiny wall of aluminum. Either through the can or through the wall of the tube. The tube is almost a 1/4 in the pressure chamber area. Probably through the can... Anyway, the point is sort of moot. The loud report of mine vs pool_shark's bloop sound tells me that there is still fuel left when the can leaves the tube. |
|
|
I suppose this is the de facto dedicated thread, so I will ask a can cannon related question here.
How would I set up a bold catch to engage every time the bolt is pulled to the rear? I feel like, by asking other places, that people would jump to the conclusion that I am trying something jankey with an open bolt gun. But the can cannon has no gas system, plus I will still have the SA trigger setup. The reason I ask here is because ended up cycling though a good 6-7 rounds unnecessarily with the can cannon on my halfback edition. I know training could be enough, But I also like the idea of an open bolt for loading the can. The air behind the can doesn't need to escape forward. |
|
|
|
Quoted:
If you use the same tube I used a 2-3/4" (70mm) hole saw works perfectly for making wads... higher pressure blanks should be here by next weekend http://i.imgur.com/ILSlrXY.jpg?1 http://i.imgur.com/vE0DDbC.jpg?2 View Quote I was thinking of doing something similar with great stuff foam, and then cutting them into discs with my chop saw. |
|
Quoted:
I suppose this is the de facto dedicated thread, so I will ask a can cannon related question here. How would I set up a bold catch to engage every time the bolt is pulled to the rear? I feel like, by asking other places, that people would jump to the conclusion that I am trying something jankey with an open bolt gun. But the can cannon has no gas system, plus I will still have the SA trigger setup. The reason I ask here is because ended up cycling though a good 6-7 rounds unnecessarily with the can cannon on my halfback edition. I know training could be enough, But I also like the idea of an open bolt for loading the can. The air behind the can doesn't need to escape forward. View Quote Modify the mag to ride up higher? |
|
Quoted:
Quoted:
I suppose this is the de facto dedicated thread, so I will ask a can cannon related question here. How would I set up a bold catch to engage every time the bolt is pulled to the rear? I feel like, by asking other places, that people would jump to the conclusion that I am trying something jankey with an open bolt gun. But the can cannon has no gas system, plus I will still have the SA trigger setup. The reason I ask here is because ended up cycling though a good 6-7 rounds unnecessarily with the can cannon on my halfback edition. I know training could be enough, But I also like the idea of an open bolt for loading the can. The air behind the can doesn't need to escape forward. Modify the mag to ride up higher? Wouldn't do anything but cause feeding issues. Like I posted above, you just need to move the spring for the bolt catch so that it pushes the bolt catch up instead of down. |
|
Quoted:
If you use the same tube I used a 2-3/4" (70mm) hole saw works perfectly for making wads... higher pressure blanks should be here by next weekend http://i.imgur.com/ILSlrXY.jpg?1 http://i.imgur.com/vE0DDbC.jpg?2 View Quote Mwuuahahahahaaa! This could get interesting...... I'll be anxiously awaiting your results. |
|
Quoted:
Thought up a weird way to stabilize cans. Basically it works like a badminton birdie. http://i72.photobucket.com/albums/i172/schkoot/Shasta%20Blasta/F2E53DD7-F205-436F-BCA1-EF4FEF360F8D_zpsqcfcb1ek.jpg View Quote On the little can, try using the "can opener around the rim" trick. Might also provide you a decent gas seal. Plus, you could experiment with a streamer type stabilizer like someone else suggested. Possibly with a magnet on the tail to ensure correct deployment. ETA: took another look at your diagram, same thing, but reverse the cans so the little can (payload) is mouth to muzzle and the big can (stabilizer) is same. It'll be easier to open with a can opener that way. Also, the concave can base should handle the pressure better than the can mouth. ETA2: I wonder if you tried with the long can as the stabilizer, mouth to breech, opened up so it extends over the barrel extension. Like this... ETA3: Maybe add an aerodynamic cover to the above pic like they do with HEAT rounds? And fill in the can junction with foam, at least on the outside. |
|
Quoted:
If you use the same tube I used a 2-3/4" (70mm) hole saw works perfectly for making wads... higher pressure blanks should be here by next weekend http://i.imgur.com/ILSlrXY.jpg?1 http://i.imgur.com/vE0DDbC.jpg?2 View Quote Try running the hole saw backwards with soft stuff like corrugated cardboard. You'll get cleaner cuts. ETA: I figured that out with a soda can solar heater experiment. |
|
Quoted:
On the little can, try using the "can opener around the rim" trick. Might also provide you a decent gas seal. Plus, you could experiment with a streamer type stabilizer like someone else suggested. Possibly with a magnet on the tail to ensure correct deployment. ETA: took another look at your diagram, same thing, but reverse the cans so the little can (payload) is mouth to muzzle and the big can (stabilizer) is same. It'll be easier to open with a can opener that way. Also, the concave can base should handle the pressure better than the can mouth. ETA2: I wonder if you tried with the long can as the stabilizer, mouth to breech, opened up so it extends over the barrel extension. Like this... http://i.imgur.com/cLUdtXn.jpg ETA3: Maybe add an aerodynamic cover to the above pic like they do with HEAT rounds? And fill in the can junction with foam, at least on the outside. View Quote View All Quotes View All Quotes Quoted:
Quoted:
Thought up a weird way to stabilize cans. Basically it works like a badminton birdie. http://i72.photobucket.com/albums/i172/schkoot/Shasta%20Blasta/F2E53DD7-F205-436F-BCA1-EF4FEF360F8D_zpsqcfcb1ek.jpg On the little can, try using the "can opener around the rim" trick. Might also provide you a decent gas seal. Plus, you could experiment with a streamer type stabilizer like someone else suggested. Possibly with a magnet on the tail to ensure correct deployment. ETA: took another look at your diagram, same thing, but reverse the cans so the little can (payload) is mouth to muzzle and the big can (stabilizer) is same. It'll be easier to open with a can opener that way. Also, the concave can base should handle the pressure better than the can mouth. ETA2: I wonder if you tried with the long can as the stabilizer, mouth to breech, opened up so it extends over the barrel extension. Like this... http://i.imgur.com/cLUdtXn.jpg ETA3: Maybe add an aerodynamic cover to the above pic like they do with HEAT rounds? And fill in the can junction with foam, at least on the outside. That would work, except that in the last 5" or so of the X products can, it tapers down to below soda can diameter. |
|
Quoted:
That would work, except that in the last 5" or so of the X products can, it tapers down to below soda can diameter. View Quote View All Quotes View All Quotes Quoted:
Quoted:
Quoted:
Thought up a weird way to stabilize cans. Basically it works like a badminton birdie. http://i72.photobucket.com/albums/i172/schkoot/Shasta%20Blasta/F2E53DD7-F205-436F-BCA1-EF4FEF360F8D_zpsqcfcb1ek.jpg On the little can, try using the "can opener around the rim" trick. Might also provide you a decent gas seal. Plus, you could experiment with a streamer type stabilizer like someone else suggested. Possibly with a magnet on the tail to ensure correct deployment. ETA: took another look at your diagram, same thing, but reverse the cans so the little can (payload) is mouth to muzzle and the big can (stabilizer) is same. It'll be easier to open with a can opener that way. Also, the concave can base should handle the pressure better than the can mouth. ETA2: I wonder if you tried with the long can as the stabilizer, mouth to breech, opened up so it extends over the barrel extension. Like this... http://i.imgur.com/cLUdtXn.jpg ETA3: Maybe add an aerodynamic cover to the above pic like they do with HEAT rounds? And fill in the can junction with foam, at least on the outside. That would work, except that in the last 5" or so of the X products can, it tapers down to below soda can diameter. Would there be any value in slitting the stabilizer can up the side with a razor blade just far enough so it would fit as pictured? |
|
Quoted:
Would there be any value in slitting the stabilizer can up the side with a razor blade just far enough so it would fit as pictured? View Quote View All Quotes View All Quotes Quoted:
Quoted:
Quoted:
Quoted:
Thought up a weird way to stabilize cans. Basically it works like a badminton birdie. http://i72.photobucket.com/albums/i172/schkoot/Shasta%20Blasta/F2E53DD7-F205-436F-BCA1-EF4FEF360F8D_zpsqcfcb1ek.jpg On the little can, try using the "can opener around the rim" trick. Might also provide you a decent gas seal. Plus, you could experiment with a streamer type stabilizer like someone else suggested. Possibly with a magnet on the tail to ensure correct deployment. ETA: took another look at your diagram, same thing, but reverse the cans so the little can (payload) is mouth to muzzle and the big can (stabilizer) is same. It'll be easier to open with a can opener that way. Also, the concave can base should handle the pressure better than the can mouth. ETA2: I wonder if you tried with the long can as the stabilizer, mouth to breech, opened up so it extends over the barrel extension. Like this... http://i.imgur.com/cLUdtXn.jpg ETA3: Maybe add an aerodynamic cover to the above pic like they do with HEAT rounds? And fill in the can junction with foam, at least on the outside. That would work, except that in the last 5" or so of the X products can, it tapers down to below soda can diameter. Would there be any value in slitting the stabilizer can up the side with a razor blade just far enough so it would fit as pictured? Yeah, I think that would work. Unless you bent a pitch into them to induce a spiral, I'm not sure it would matter though. It's sort of strange to me how the cans will come out of the tube completely stationary outside of their ballistic path. If you shot a Dr. Pepper and you saw the logo as it left, you could read it all the way to the top of its arc where it starts to move around a bit. That's what I have noticed anyway. Other people here can chime in and either confirm or correct me. |
|
The problem with the can stabilization ideas is the pressure doesn't just go forward. It tries to expand in all directions, and likely would end up locking the empty can to the barrel during the pressure spike.
|
|
|
|
Quoted:
This maybe getting a little out of hand http://i.imgur.com/qr3jL07.jpg?1 New VFG should be here this week also http://i.imgur.com/WRD9A32.png ETA: you can maintain a cheek weld with this sight setup if you use your left eye... also only at about $300 so still under budget View Quote LULZ... That's awesome. |
|
Quoted:
That's why I have mine pointed backwards. View Quote View All Quotes View All Quotes Quoted:
Quoted:
The problem with the can stabilization ideas is the pressure doesn't just go forward. It tries to expand in all directions, and likely would end up locking the empty can to the barrel during the pressure spike. That's why I have mine pointed backwards. Smart. |
|
Quoted:
The problem with the can stabilization ideas is the pressure doesn't just go forward. It tries to expand in all directions, and likely would end up locking the empty can to the barrel during the pressure spike. View Quote You're braver than me. I'd treat that the same way I do a flare launcher and keep my hands back at the magwell. |
|
|
Quoted:
Quoted:
If you look down the tube do you see the barrel? Yes, you can see the plugged end. So, basic design is a short barrel cut, plugged, and ported with a tube welded to a barrel nut? |
|
Quoted:
So, basic design is a short barrel cut, plugged, and ported with a tube welded to a barrel nut? View Quote View All Quotes View All Quotes Quoted:
Quoted:
Quoted:
If you look down the tube do you see the barrel? Yes, you can see the plugged end. So, basic design is a short barrel cut, plugged, and ported with a tube welded to a barrel nut? That pretty much sums it up. The tube looks to be pinned to what appears to be a 1" thick base/nut. There is also a dramatic taper to thicken the walls of the pressure chamber area, and to prevent the can from getting too deep. |
|
Quoted:
So, basic design is a short barrel cut, plugged, and ported with a tube welded to a barrel nut? View Quote View All Quotes View All Quotes Quoted:
Quoted:
Quoted:
If you look down the tube do you see the barrel? Yes, you can see the plugged end. So, basic design is a short barrel cut, plugged, and ported with a tube welded to a barrel nut? you just described how I built mine (page 17) |
|
Quoted:
you just described how I built mine (page 17) View Quote View All Quotes View All Quotes Quoted:
Quoted:
Quoted:
Quoted:
If you look down the tube do you see the barrel? Yes, you can see the plugged end. So, basic design is a short barrel cut, plugged, and ported with a tube welded to a barrel nut? you just described how I built mine (page 17) What tubing did you use? I think you said 2-3/4" aluminum, what schedule pipe? |
|
Quoted:
What tubing did you use? I think you said 2-3/4" aluminum, what schedule pipe? View Quote View All Quotes View All Quotes Quoted:
Quoted:
Quoted:
Quoted:
Quoted:
If you look down the tube do you see the barrel? Yes, you can see the plugged end. So, basic design is a short barrel cut, plugged, and ported with a tube welded to a barrel nut? you just described how I built mine (page 17) What tubing did you use? I think you said 2-3/4" aluminum, what schedule pipe? https://www.onlinemetals.com/merchant.cfm?pid=7140&step=4&showunits=inches&id=71&top_cat=0 My entire build and material list is a little over halfway down page 17 of this thread.. I have no idea what the tube would convert to in schedule size |
|
On the actual x can cannon, does the barrel nut unscrew from the tube?
|
|
|
Still telling myself I don't want one.
Probably be another safe occupant. Grand Kids would like it. $-CHA-CHING-$ |
|
X Products has M200 for sale on their website now. Looks like it's ~$0.45 a round. That's a little steep for me, but I like the idea of ordering them in intervals of 100.
LINK |
|
Quoted:
X Products has M200 for sale on their website now. Looks like it's ~$0.45 a round. That's a little steep for me, but I like the idea of ordering them in intervals of 100. LINK View Quote That' a bit high. I get mine here. http://www.atlanticwallblanks.com/PRVI-556-M200A1-BLANK_p_183.html http://www.atlanticwallblanks.com/PRVI-556-M200-BLANK_p_177.html http://www.atlanticwallblanks.com/556-M200-DUPLICATE_p_247.html |
|
|
View Quote LOL... that thing is so awesome. How does the sight picture look with the quadrant and the conventionally placed stock? When I was a grenadier, I hated the quadrant and preferred the leaf sight for my 203. I was able to give up having to carry the SAW as a boot because I had the highest hit percentage of any of the Marines in the Platoon. As soon as I got into country, I kinda started missing the SAW. |
|
Quoted:
LOL... that thing is so awesome. How does the sight picture look with the quadrant and the conventionally placed stock? When I was a grenadier, I hated the quadrant and preferred the leaf sight for my 203. I was able to give up having to carry the SAW as a boot because I had the highest hit percentage of any of the Marines in the Platoon. As soon as I got into country, I kinda started missing the SAW. View Quote View All Quotes View All Quotes Quoted:
LOL... that thing is so awesome. How does the sight picture look with the quadrant and the conventionally placed stock? When I was a grenadier, I hated the quadrant and preferred the leaf sight for my 203. I was able to give up having to carry the SAW as a boot because I had the highest hit percentage of any of the Marines in the Platoon. As soon as I got into country, I kinda started missing the SAW. I can keep a full cheek weld if i use my left eye to aim.. haven't been to the range since my last video but hoping to go on Sunday and set up a 12oz range card as well as testing some higher pressure blanks |
|
Quoted:
I can keep a full cheek weld if i use my left eye to aim.. haven't been to the range since my last video but hoping to go on Sunday and set up a 12oz range card as well as testing some higher pressure blanks View Quote View All Quotes View All Quotes Quoted:
Quoted:
LOL... that thing is so awesome. How does the sight picture look with the quadrant and the conventionally placed stock? When I was a grenadier, I hated the quadrant and preferred the leaf sight for my 203. I was able to give up having to carry the SAW as a boot because I had the highest hit percentage of any of the Marines in the Platoon. As soon as I got into country, I kinda started missing the SAW. I can keep a full cheek weld if i use my left eye to aim.. haven't been to the range since my last video but hoping to go on Sunday and set up a 12oz range card as well as testing some higher pressure blanks Cool. When I finally get some free time I am going to modify my sight. I think I might put an M203 leaf where the plastic one is, and run a new removable "through-bolt" for it to rotate on. I will probably find a spring similar to the one that keeps the ejection port open to keep this leaf site up, and then make a way to clip it shut. I am not the best at explaining stuff, but I can take OK pictures, so when I am done, I will make a DIY thread. |
|
Quoted:
X Products has M200 for sale on their website now. Looks like it's ~$0.45 a round. That's a little steep for me, but I like the idea of ordering them in intervals of 100. LINK View Quote That's nice and all...but they still don't have the cannon in stock, and the 6-8 week lead time hasn't changed. It would be good to get an updated ETA. I would rather order one when they're in stock. |
|
DSG has them on their site. I already have one so I didn't check to see if they were in stock though,
|
|
Quoted:
This may be more of an inspiring solid image: http://i39.photobucket.com/albums/e192/shadyirishmen/Grappling%20Hook_zpsg8o0n0zw.png View Quote That is awesome! when are we going to get some test footage |
|
Sign up for the ARFCOM weekly newsletter and be entered to win a free ARFCOM membership. One new winner* is announced every week!
You will receive an email every Friday morning featuring the latest chatter from the hottest topics, breaking news surrounding legislation, as well as exclusive deals only available to ARFCOM email subscribers.
AR15.COM is the world's largest firearm community and is a gathering place for firearm enthusiasts of all types.
From hunters and military members, to competition shooters and general firearm enthusiasts, we welcome anyone who values and respects the way of the firearm.
Subscribe to our monthly Newsletter to receive firearm news, product discounts from your favorite Industry Partners, and more.
Copyright © 1996-2024 AR15.COM LLC. All Rights Reserved.
Any use of this content without express written consent is prohibited.
AR15.Com reserves the right to overwrite or replace any affiliate, commercial, or monetizable links, posted by users, with our own.