User Panel
Posted: 4/13/2007 2:58:01 AM EDT
"Please take your hands out of your pockets"
I noticed this with casual encounters with the police a few times. I also noticed this when I went to traffic court for a speeding ticket recently, I was told by the court deputy that I was not allowed to put my hands in my pockets. What right does law enforcement have, or what right does a court deputy have to tell you that you are not allowed to put your hands in your pockets while in their presence? Anyone ever heard of this behavior from law enforcement? And anyone ever hear of anyone non complying with these orders? And at what point do you think it justifies a citizens arrest against law enforcement for using color of law to infringe against rights? |
|
He has the tazer, you don't. Sorry. |
|
|
Wonderful first post. I think I'll just stand over here, out of the line of fire. |
|
Out on the street it is simply an issue of the LE officer thinking that the person might have a weapon in the pocket.
|
|
|
Potentially yes there could be a sniper in every bush, but does that give law enforcement the power to force the citizenry to walk around with their hands out of their pockets? There is no Federal or State Law that allows them to do this. There is however a Federal Law giving me the power of citizens arrest against people that infringe on civil rights. |
|
|
Maybe they just want to make sure you're not diddling yourself.
|
|
Pockets can be a pretty handy place for a weapon dont you think? If it wasn't for that, noone would care.
|
|
Noone always cares! He is one of the most caring individuals you will ever meet! |
|
|
Were you in the courtroom? If so, he was most likely he was complying with the judge's standard orders. The judge can pretty much tell you to do anything in his court room. If you fail to comply, its contempt of court.
|
|
If you feel that they're violating your rights next time by telling you not to place you hands in your pockets, feel free to tell the nice officer to "fuck off" and tell him you'll put your hands anywhere you want. report back and let us know how it goes.
Try it like this! |
|
Ive noticed it in and OUT of a courtroom. Everyone seems to get the same treatment. I even noticed it on the TV show COPS. |
|
|
I don't think you are allowed to wear a hat in a courtrom, either.
|
|
|
|
See the above post. What right are they violating? Let me answer that... None. |
|
|
|
Everytime I encounter an authority figure (with a weapon at least) I make it a habit to show my hands... unless I went to make them uncomfortable
|
|
Right to peacefully assemble. the right where it says "nor be deprived of life, liberty, or property, without due process of law;" From my State Constitution: "Presumption of innocence -- Securing accused persons. -- Every person being presumed innocent, until pronounced guilty by the law, " |
|
|
At what point are they adjudicating you guilty of anything? |
|
|
We should ban pockets. Worry more about the hand under my shirt. Eddie |
|
|
There is a gun store in Austin, Texas that has a large sign posted as you enter that says "keep your hands out of your pockets". I understand the reason, but I really have to wonder (based on the odds of being robbed/shot &), how much would this really help to give the gun store employees an advantage. What are they gonna do? Draw down and search everyone that puts their hands in their pockets? Unless they are prepared to do that, having a no hands in pockets rule really doesn't help.
|
|
With enough advance notice, I'm sure I can get there in time with a video camera for the ensuing takedown. Youtube lives for that shit. Just joking around ........ to the OP, it really must be as simple as LE and the courts have probably seen too many people with their hands in their pockets pull out a weapon of some sort. Don't you think? What do you say when they ask you to walk through a metal detector before you enter the court? |
|||
|
I am sure Johnny Cochran knows the answer to your question....oh, wait....he's dead.
Well, in that case, noone knows..... |
|
Weak stretch.... |
|
|
That guy's a smart fucker, too. He knows everything! |
|
|
Actually I didnt have to walk through the metal detector. It was there but not being used. Last time I went to the State House, again no metal detectors. They were there but not being used. Maybe they were down for maintenance. Maybe they only use them at certain times. But to me, a metal detector is a "search" and unconstitutional, in my opinion. Also in the YouTube video, it appeared the guy was under arrest for something else enitrely. If not then that behavior is disturbing coming from a police officer. |
|
|
I do it on just about every encounter.
When you and I are talking while I'm on duty, I am in control. I don't know you and I don't know what you have in your mind. Hands kill. Thus I want to see your hands. That is just the way it is. |
|
You are the Poster Boy for the Book titled"The Death of Common Sense" Please,if you plan on living a full life,Use Common Sense,it will make you a better person.I'm assuming you are in the 18-34 demographic ETA:I'm not even a LEO,just a person that uses good judgement. |
||
|
Simple: Officer saefty is more important to them than your rights to put your hands in your pockets.
|
|
Officer Safety is too. |
|
|
This is correct. I saw it on the 3 stooges. Take off you hat. Raise your right hand. Take off your hat. |
|
|
So because officers care more for their safety then common decency to liberties, they have granted themself the privelage of deciding wether or not I am allowed to use my pockets?
Where in the law does it give police officers this privelage? And for the person who questioned my common sense. I know the police officers rationale in asking citizens to keep their hands out of their pockets. I was asking what gives them the right to think they have the privelage of disallowing citizens from exercising their liberty. |
|
YEAH! Today its keeping my hands out of my pockets and tomorrow its shooting your dog! ... oh... wait.... nevermind |
|
|
this thread is a waste of bandwidth.
you are sounding too trollish for me or anyone else to waste time with. I'd love for you to be in LE shoes for a day. I'd also love to see how you act when you call 911 for assistance from those bad JBT boys. Oops, started to fall in the trap of responding to your silly ass questions. How about your common decency to the officers. Treatthem with some respect. YOU seem to already know that we are a bit nervous about seeing your hands. HOw about spreading the sunshine and doing us a decent favor and show us your hands - make us feelk a bitmore comfortable about engaging the public. LEO engage potential threats with every interaction with a human when they wear the badge. How many interactions do you have with LE? How about you not worrying about the 4 occassions in your LIFETIME that an officer interacts with you andYOU show some decency. Now go start another troll acct and stir up more silliness. |
|
FWIW, I'd tell you one time. If you did it again, you'd be wearing handcuffs.
|
|
+1 |
|
|
You just don't get it,do you? If you are in a situation with a LEO,and he tells you to take your hands out of your pocket,do so,if not suffer the consequences. If you are in a courtroom,and the Judge or LEO tells you to take your hand out of your pockets,do it. If you are walking down the street,with no engagement with a LEO,then do whatever you want with your hands. Time to get off the fucking soapbox and grow up. Don't do stupid shit,and you won't be involved with Judges or LEO's. Then you can do whatever the fuck you want to with your hans. Enjoy your Life,it is too short to worry about stupid shit like this |
|
|
What is so dangerous about being a police officer?
Around 150 officers are killed every year in the line of duty. There are around 700,000 detectives and police officers employed in the United States last year according to the Department of Labor. The murder rate in the United States per 700,000 people is nearly 300. YOU ARE TWICE AS LIKELY TO FACE MURDER BEING A NORMAL CITIZEN. And this statistic doesnt count victims of crimes other then murder such as rape or assault. As a citizen I deal with the same scum of the Earth as Law Enforcement does. I dont go around telling people they cant use their pockets because I feel threatened. It would be pure paranoia. |
|
I give up. MODS Please Help |
|
|
This response truly shows youre a moron. It is a dangerous job and they have to confront dangerous situations everyday, which you most likely dont. As a librarian I was forced to "deal with the same scum of the Earth as Law Enforcement", but I wasnt putting them into a fight or flight situation. So, if the officers are less likely to die, dont you think thats because they are doing somethings RIGHT in their jobs? There is no winning with you. You being allowed to have your hands in your pockets is some what less consequential then the safety of someone else's life. |
|
|
Disobey the direct order of an officer and report back to us.
|
|
Because I can. Good enough. |
|
|
This is as dumb as the Brady Law. If you feel a person might have a weapon, screw telling him to keep his hands out of his pockets, Terry Search him. Jeez. |
|
|
How many times a year does an officer get into a deadly situation and lives? How many times a year does an officer have to fight because someone doesn't want to keep his hands out of his pockets and decides to resist? People do not like to go to jail, therefore some will fight. You have no Idea what you are talking about. I would suggest that you join a reserve program at a local department. It will be an eye opener for ya.
|
|
Are you fucking kidding me? It's called officer safety. Those same scum of the earth that you and I deal with are not out to harm you because of the uniform you wear, the gun you carry, and the authority you excercise. If I dont feel comfortable with something you are doing (like putting your hands in your pockets) I'm going to tell you to stop. If you don't comply, you are gonna end up in some shiny bracelets. (disclaimer: some people do this out of habit especially when nervous. If I get the "right vibe" from you, I'll give you another warning, with a consequence. If you can't do something as simple as keeping your hands out of your pockets, tough luck. If you give the the "wrong vibe", good luck.) Simple as that. I want to go home each night. Hands kill. Keep 'em where I can see 'em. |
|
|
Sign up for the ARFCOM weekly newsletter and be entered to win a free ARFCOM membership. One new winner* is announced every week!
You will receive an email every Friday morning featuring the latest chatter from the hottest topics, breaking news surrounding legislation, as well as exclusive deals only available to ARFCOM email subscribers.
AR15.COM is the world's largest firearm community and is a gathering place for firearm enthusiasts of all types.
From hunters and military members, to competition shooters and general firearm enthusiasts, we welcome anyone who values and respects the way of the firearm.
Subscribe to our monthly Newsletter to receive firearm news, product discounts from your favorite Industry Partners, and more.
Copyright © 1996-2024 AR15.COM LLC. All Rights Reserved.
Any use of this content without express written consent is prohibited.
AR15.Com reserves the right to overwrite or replace any affiliate, commercial, or monetizable links, posted by users, with our own.