User Panel
More retro options is never a bad thing
|
|
|
It's good to see expansion in the retro market.
|
|
|
|
Originally Posted By GenYRevolverGuy: A couple years ago, nobody was making A2 stuff. A bunch of companies were making A4s, and some of those companies were calling those A4s A2s, but you couldn't really get an A2 without digging up an old upper somewhere and building around it yourself. Then one day, a holding group bought the rights to an old gun company's branding and IP, and they hired a retro rifle nerd to run it, and now there's a shift. H&R released A1s first, then A2s started shipping a year or so ago, and they've been a hit. https://files.springfield-armory.com/wp-content/uploads/model-hero-sa16-rifle-2200x1257-3.jpg https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SwuKAESTsYo It's going to see how far this goes. Personally, I didn't love the A2 when I was in the Army. The examples I was issued were mostly older than I was and it showed, and every USGI magazine I was ever issued before I deployed should have been smashed and trashed. Also, GI triggers are what they are, and the training wasn't very good. The marksmanship training was so poor, many (most?) of us couldn't hit the 300M targets with confidence, and bad maintenance practices caused reliability issues. I learned a hell of a lot more about shooting techniques and firearms maintenance towards the end of my career and after I got out than I ever did when I was in. I recently acquired my first civilian A2: https://www.ar15.com/media/mediaFiles/257918/IMG_9632-3183526.jpg I dropped a trigger in it, lubed it up, and took it out, and it actually kind of rips. I was pinging the 300 yard target casually, I had a good hit rate at 400 with some effort, and 550 was a bit tough, but it was hard to see the target. The 0-2 aperture was also way more useful than I remember it being. I could get the A2 on targets from 50-200 with that aperture about as fast as I could my TA-31 ACOG. I bought this A2 as a range toy, training rifle, and Memberberries item, but my confidence in it is high. I'm going to put a loaded mag in that force pro pouch and keep it handy. Anyways, I don't have much love for Springfield, but I'm glad they're doing this, and I hope this trend grows a bit more. View Quote The biggest reason that soldiers struggled with the more distant targets is that the rifles were never fully zeroed in many units. As a civilian would you consider your rifle properly zeroed with out confirmation at range? |
|
Asa Phelps has died.
|
That's weird, I had a dream about M16A2s last night.
|
|
|
I like it
|
|
"If you cant do something smart, do something right"
|
My least favorite AR variant, but I should pick one up just to have it.
|
|
|
I don't need one but I'm glad they are keeping the retro stuff alive
|
|
"Don't want to be that guy with 100K primers who can't pay the electric bill."
|
Originally Posted By SSeric02: That's weird, I had a dream about M16A2s last night. View Quote What will their next model in this series be, prophet? (As someone still waiting for a Detective model SA-35 I'm kidding). I think this market is going to eventually saturate somewhat, and those like H&R who make weird stuff will be the ones with longevity. These days pretty much everyone has (a) rifle(s) for "serious use," and are now looking at nostalgic stuff so they can sit and watch Platoon while holding their A1 clone. And there's absolutely nothing wrong with that. If I can ever find an M5 RAS I'll pick up a Colt Ar15A4 to clone the M16A4 I was first issued. Day late and a dollar short again. |
|
|
Originally Posted By FightingHellfish: The biggest reason that soldiers struggled with the more distant targets is that the rifles were never fully zeroed in many units. As a civilian would you consider your rifle properly zeroed with out confirmation at range? View Quote View All Quotes View All Quotes Originally Posted By FightingHellfish: Originally Posted By GenYRevolverGuy: A couple years ago, nobody was making A2 stuff. A bunch of companies were making A4s, and some of those companies were calling those A4s A2s, but you couldn't really get an A2 without digging up an old upper somewhere and building around it yourself. Then one day, a holding group bought the rights to an old gun company's branding and IP, and they hired a retro rifle nerd to run it, and now there's a shift. H&R released A1s first, then A2s started shipping a year or so ago, and they've been a hit. https://files.springfield-armory.com/wp-content/uploads/model-hero-sa16-rifle-2200x1257-3.jpg https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SwuKAESTsYo It's going to see how far this goes. Personally, I didn't love the A2 when I was in the Army. The examples I was issued were mostly older than I was and it showed, and every USGI magazine I was ever issued before I deployed should have been smashed and trashed. Also, GI triggers are what they are, and the training wasn't very good. The marksmanship training was so poor, many (most?) of us couldn't hit the 300M targets with confidence, and bad maintenance practices caused reliability issues. I learned a hell of a lot more about shooting techniques and firearms maintenance towards the end of my career and after I got out than I ever did when I was in. I recently acquired my first civilian A2: https://www.ar15.com/media/mediaFiles/257918/IMG_9632-3183526.jpg I dropped a trigger in it, lubed it up, and took it out, and it actually kind of rips. I was pinging the 300 yard target casually, I had a good hit rate at 400 with some effort, and 550 was a bit tough, but it was hard to see the target. The 0-2 aperture was also way more useful than I remember it being. I could get the A2 on targets from 50-200 with that aperture about as fast as I could my TA-31 ACOG. I bought this A2 as a range toy, training rifle, and Memberberries item, but my confidence in it is high. I'm going to put a loaded mag in that force pro pouch and keep it handy. Anyways, I don't have much love for Springfield, but I'm glad they're doing this, and I hope this trend grows a bit more. The biggest reason that soldiers struggled with the more distant targets is that the rifles were never fully zeroed in many units. As a civilian would you consider your rifle properly zeroed with out confirmation at range? We almost always did confirmation zeros before scored quals. I remain convinced the marksmanship struggles were 80% training and 20% the GI trigger. But, it is funny you ask that... Mike says all the H&R uppers are zeroed from the factory. Trust but verify? I printed two A2 zeroing targets, and went to a guy's range where I had never shot before only to find there was nowhere to hang paper short of 100 yards. So I started popping steel. 100? ding ding ding. 200? ding ding ding. 300? ding ding ding. Dial to 400? ding bang ding ding. Dial to 500 and aim for 550? bang bang ding bang ding ding bang ding. I'd never shot that far with a rifle before, this was my first time shooting this particular rifle, I didn't make a single adjustment to the sights outside of dialing, and... there I was. |
|
"I haven't met one burnt end or rib that I haven't liked." -Andy Reid
"Sporterizing: The art of spending $700 on a $300 gun to make it worth $200." -GTwannabe |
I like the A2, I like all things AR's
|
|
This world would be a better place to live if it weren't for people!
|
glad to see it.
i just love 20" and rifle length gas, so smooth. having fixed irons is great too. noob owners who may have trouble maintaining zero with optics and/or backup irons have one less thing to worry about. |
|
|
M16 is a full automatic weapon. Do they mean AR15?
|
|
It matters not how strait the gate, or how charged with punishments the scroll,
I am the master of my fate. I am the captain of my soul. |
"The villainy you teach me, I will execute, and it shall go hard but I will better the instruction"
|
|
"I haven't met one burnt end or rib that I haven't liked." -Andy Reid
"Sporterizing: The art of spending $700 on a $300 gun to make it worth $200." -GTwannabe |
|
Modern A1 with either fixed irons, or a flat top and lightweight 1-6, makes for a damned nice rifle.
Folks have forgotten how nicely a 20” pencil barrel balances when you don’t have a shitload of widgets hanging off the rifle. |
|
|
Not MD legal
|
|
|
I love my 1997 vintage Colt MT6700 ("A4" version). Granted, I've had the original 1-9 twist HBAR turned down to government profile and the threads put on the end but still... No, it isn't the same thing as the A2 but close. The rear sight is a breath of fresh air after looking through all these optics everywhere I turn.
I'm still a believer in the 55gr bullet moving at near 3300 fps being the way to go. My M4'gery Frankenstein with the can is the "go to" gun...but I always take a long look at that 20in Colt that sits next to it and think twice... :) Long Live the A2!!! |
|
|
I am surprised SA put a bayonet lug on it.
It looks great. |
|
|
Originally Posted By GenYRevolverGuy: A couple years ago, nobody was making A2 stuff. A bunch of companies were making A4s, and some of those companies were calling those A4s A2s, but you couldn't really get an A2 without digging up an old upper somewhere and building around it yourself. Then one day, a holding group bought the rights to an old gun company's branding and IP, and they hired a retro rifle nerd to run it, and now there's a shift. H&R released A1s first, then A2s started shipping a year or so ago, and they've been a hit. https://files.springfield-armory.com/wp-content/uploads/model-hero-sa16-rifle-2200x1257-3.jpg https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SwuKAESTsYo It's going to be fun to see how far this goes. Personally, I didn't love the A2 when I was in the Army. The examples I was issued were mostly older than I was and it showed, and every USGI magazine I was ever issued before I deployed should have been smashed and trashed. Also, GI triggers are what they are, and the training wasn't very good. The marksmanship training was so poor, many (most?) of us couldn't hit the 300M targets with confidence, and bad maintenance practices caused reliability issues. I learned a hell of a lot more about shooting techniques and firearms maintenance towards the end of my career and after I got out than I ever did when I was in. I recently acquired my first civilian A2: https://www.ar15.com/media/mediaFiles/257918/IMG_9632-3183526.jpg I dropped a trigger in it, lubed it up, and took it out, and it actually kind of rips. I was pinging the 300 yard target casually, I had a good hit rate at 400 with some effort, and 550 was a bit tough, but it was hard to see the target. The 0-2 aperture was also way more useful than I remember it being. I could get the A2 on targets from 50-200 with that aperture about as fast as I could my TA-31 ACOG. I bought this A2 as a range toy, training rifle, and Memberberries item, but my confidence in it is high. I'm going to put a loaded mag in that force pro pouch and keep it handy. Anyways, I don't have much love for Springfield, but I'm glad they're doing this, and I hope this trend grows a bit more. View Quote Your pic hit with with a wave of nostalgia. When I was in I had an FN A-2 and I kinda miss it. I was thinking there are only 2 upgrades I'd want to do on it. 1) Upgraded single-stage trigger - Geisselle maybe? 2) Swap a Tubb spring into it. I think it would be a good rifle to have overall and it never failed me. Question for those who know: An M-16 purchased in the mid-late 1990s, what would the roll-mark be? I can't remember where it was made back then. |
|
Proud millennial.
|
Originally Posted By GenYRevolverGuy: We almost always did confirmation zeros before scored quals. I remain convinced the marksmanship struggles were 80% training and 20% the GI trigger. But, it is funny you ask that... Mike says all the H&R uppers are zeroed from the factory. Trust but verify? I printed two A2 zeroing targets, and went to a guy's range where I had never shot before only to find there was nowhere to hang paper short of 100 yards. So I started popping steel. 100? ding ding ding. 200? ding ding ding. 300? ding ding ding. Dial to 400? ding bang ding ding. Dial to 500 and aim for 550? bang bang ding bang ding ding bang ding. I'd never shot that far with a rifle before, this was my first time shooting this particular rifle, I didn't make a single adjustment to the sights outside of dialing, and... there I was. View Quote Confirmation at what distance? |
|
Asa Phelps has died.
|
My a2 is probably my favorite bench gun.
|
|
“I was always willing to be reasonable until I had to be unreasonable. Sometimes reasonable men must do unreasonable things.”
|
One of my very first AR's was a Colt 6600. Still have it and will never sell it, and to this day one of my favorites to shoot.
|
|
RIP Ronald Silavent, 1985-2015, OIF, 101st Airborne, No Slack
|
Proud millennial.
|
Originally Posted By SGT_Tentpeg: M16 is a full automatic weapon. Do they mean AR15? View Quote Attached File |
|
“I was always willing to be reasonable until I had to be unreasonable. Sometimes reasonable men must do unreasonable things.”
|
I don't understand the retro fascination. It's going backwards on purpose. Things have been updated and modernized for a reason.
|
|
|
The M16A3 was better than the M16A2. I'm right. You know I am. If you disagree your bad and you should feel bad.
|
|
I killed a bacon puppy. :(
This post is brought to you by The Pogues, the official punk band of the .mil forums. |
Originally Posted By djkest: Your pic hit with with a wave of nostalgia. When I was in I had an FN A-2 and I kinda miss it. I was thinking there are only 2 upgrades I'd want to do on it. 1) Upgraded single-stage trigger - Geisselle maybe? 2) Swap a Tubb spring into it. I think it would be a good rifle to have overall and it never failed me. View Quote View All Quotes View All Quotes Originally Posted By djkest: Originally Posted By GenYRevolverGuy: A couple years ago, nobody was making A2 stuff. A bunch of companies were making A4s, and some of those companies were calling those A4s A2s, but you couldn't really get an A2 without digging up an old upper somewhere and building around it yourself. Then one day, a holding group bought the rights to an old gun company's branding and IP, and they hired a retro rifle nerd to run it, and now there's a shift. H&R released A1s first, then A2s started shipping a year or so ago, and they've been a hit. https://files.springfield-armory.com/wp-content/uploads/model-hero-sa16-rifle-2200x1257-3.jpg https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SwuKAESTsYo It's going to be fun to see how far this goes. Personally, I didn't love the A2 when I was in the Army. The examples I was issued were mostly older than I was and it showed, and every USGI magazine I was ever issued before I deployed should have been smashed and trashed. Also, GI triggers are what they are, and the training wasn't very good. The marksmanship training was so poor, many (most?) of us couldn't hit the 300M targets with confidence, and bad maintenance practices caused reliability issues. I learned a hell of a lot more about shooting techniques and firearms maintenance towards the end of my career and after I got out than I ever did when I was in. I recently acquired my first civilian A2: https://www.ar15.com/media/mediaFiles/257918/IMG_9632-3183526.jpg I dropped a trigger in it, lubed it up, and took it out, and it actually kind of rips. I was pinging the 300 yard target casually, I had a good hit rate at 400 with some effort, and 550 was a bit tough, but it was hard to see the target. The 0-2 aperture was also way more useful than I remember it being. I could get the A2 on targets from 50-200 with that aperture about as fast as I could my TA-31 ACOG. I bought this A2 as a range toy, training rifle, and Memberberries item, but my confidence in it is high. I'm going to put a loaded mag in that force pro pouch and keep it handy. Anyways, I don't have much love for Springfield, but I'm glad they're doing this, and I hope this trend grows a bit more. Your pic hit with with a wave of nostalgia. When I was in I had an FN A-2 and I kinda miss it. I was thinking there are only 2 upgrades I'd want to do on it. 1) Upgraded single-stage trigger - Geisselle maybe? 2) Swap a Tubb spring into it. I think it would be a good rifle to have overall and it never failed me. There are three small but important differences between the way I have my A2 set up now vs the ones I was issued in the '00s. 1) CMMG 2-stage trigger. I don't think they make these anymore, but I already had it, it's good enough, and it doesn't change the look of the rifle. 2) Lubrication. In most places in the Army, we kept our rifles way too dry. It was supposed to attract less dust or some BS. I grease my buffer tube and charging handle, and I generously oil the BCG, and it's much better. 3) Magazines. I know it's a debate here, but PMAGs are a huge upgrade over USGI aluminum, and you'll never convince me otherwise. |
|
"I haven't met one burnt end or rib that I haven't liked." -Andy Reid
"Sporterizing: The art of spending $700 on a $300 gun to make it worth $200." -GTwannabe |
I killed a bacon puppy. :(
This post is brought to you by The Pogues, the official punk band of the .mil forums. |
|
|
Let me get my coffee first...
|
ARF loves to gobble SA cock while shunning every other company who as much as farted near the 2nd amendment. This place never fails to surprise me.
FUCK SPRINGFIELD ARMORY from the gun owners of Illinois. |
|
Nissans are for poor people
|
“I was always willing to be reasonable until I had to be unreasonable. Sometimes reasonable men must do unreasonable things.”
|
Originally Posted By djkest: We always did 25-meter paper targets and then moved the rear sight aperture two clicks. View Quote View All Quotes View All Quotes Originally Posted By djkest: Originally Posted By FightingHellfish: Confirmation at what distance? We always did 25-meter paper targets and then moved the rear sight aperture two clicks. Same. |
|
"I haven't met one burnt end or rib that I haven't liked." -Andy Reid
"Sporterizing: The art of spending $700 on a $300 gun to make it worth $200." -GTwannabe |
Originally Posted By GenYRevolverGuy: There are three small but important differences between the way I have my A2 set up now vs the ones I was issued in the '00s. 1) CMMG 2-stage trigger. I don't think they make these anymore, but I already had it, it's good enough, and it doesn't change the look of the rifle. 2) Lubrication. In most places in the Army, we kept our rifles way too dry. It was supposed to attract less dust or some BS. I grease my buffer tube and charging handle, and I generously oil the BCG, and it's much better. 3) Magazines. I know it's a debate here, but PMAGs are a huge upgrade over USGI aluminum, and you'll never convince me otherwise. View Quote For point 3, get some milspec aluminum mags and install the Magpul followers in them. :) |
|
Proud millennial.
|
Originally Posted By UndrGrndPrdcts: I don't understand the retro fascination. It's going backwards on purpose. Things have been updated and modernized for a reason. View Quote A lot of early GWOT guys deployed with A2 (mostly support) and carried it everywhere for a year or more. In a support unit we deployed with them in 2010. I'm in a TDA unit and still have A2s I'm trying to get swapped for M4A1s. Plus the Desert Storm and cold War guys. |
|
Let me get my coffee first...
|
Love it.
|
|
|
Musket thread
@beamy |
|
|
Originally Posted By FightingHellfish: The biggest reason that soldiers struggled with the more distant targets is that the rifles were never fully zeroed in many units. As a civilian would you consider your rifle properly zeroed with out confirmation at range? View Quote View All Quotes View All Quotes Originally Posted By FightingHellfish: Originally Posted By GenYRevolverGuy: A couple years ago, nobody was making A2 stuff. A bunch of companies were making A4s, and some of those companies were calling those A4s A2s, but you couldn't really get an A2 without digging up an old upper somewhere and building around it yourself. Then one day, a holding group bought the rights to an old gun company's branding and IP, and they hired a retro rifle nerd to run it, and now there's a shift. H&R released A1s first, then A2s started shipping a year or so ago, and they've been a hit. https://files.springfield-armory.com/wp-content/uploads/model-hero-sa16-rifle-2200x1257-3.jpg https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SwuKAESTsYo It's going to see how far this goes. Personally, I didn't love the A2 when I was in the Army. The examples I was issued were mostly older than I was and it showed, and every USGI magazine I was ever issued before I deployed should have been smashed and trashed. Also, GI triggers are what they are, and the training wasn't very good. The marksmanship training was so poor, many (most?) of us couldn't hit the 300M targets with confidence, and bad maintenance practices caused reliability issues. I learned a hell of a lot more about shooting techniques and firearms maintenance towards the end of my career and after I got out than I ever did when I was in. I recently acquired my first civilian A2: https://www.ar15.com/media/mediaFiles/257918/IMG_9632-3183526.jpg I dropped a trigger in it, lubed it up, and took it out, and it actually kind of rips. I was pinging the 300 yard target casually, I had a good hit rate at 400 with some effort, and 550 was a bit tough, but it was hard to see the target. The 0-2 aperture was also way more useful than I remember it being. I could get the A2 on targets from 50-200 with that aperture about as fast as I could my TA-31 ACOG. I bought this A2 as a range toy, training rifle, and Memberberries item, but my confidence in it is high. I'm going to put a loaded mag in that force pro pouch and keep it handy. Anyways, I don't have much love for Springfield, but I'm glad they're doing this, and I hope this trend grows a bit more. The biggest reason that soldiers struggled with the more distant targets is that the rifles were never fully zeroed in many units. As a civilian would you consider your rifle properly zeroed with out confirmation at range? Never fully zeroed is a nice way to say improperly zeroed. The amount of bad information that spreads in the Army, which simply paper targets at range would dispel or correct, is sad. The pop up range is great validation, but a poor training tool on its own. |
|
Here’s an example from a butterfly, an example that it can be happy on a hard rock. An example that it can lie on this unsweetened stone, friendlessly and all alone. Now let my bed. I do not care.
|
|
Originally Posted By UndrGrndPrdcts: I don't understand the retro fascination. It's going backwards on purpose. Things have been updated and modernized for a reason. View Quote Counterpoints: 1) Modern ARs and polymer pistols might be the most practical options, but they get boring quick. I'd guess 87% of guys here have recreational firearms. 2) 30+ years worth of American veterans were issued A2 rifles, and they'll never get the real deal from the CMP. This is the next best thing. 3) The 20" M16s are actually great rifles for a variety of reasons including superior external and terminal ballistics, the rifle length gas system, and some of the best iron sights fielded on any rifle ever. 4) 20" guns just plain shoot better than 16" guns, M4s, or SBRs. 5) Basic rifles like these might not be the best option for defensive use, but they're still more than good enough. After the last range day I just had, I could use my A2 with a high level of confidence just about anywhere outside of dark or close quarters situations. |
|
"I haven't met one burnt end or rib that I haven't liked." -Andy Reid
"Sporterizing: The art of spending $700 on a $300 gun to make it worth $200." -GTwannabe |
“How dare we whine at our inevitable return to that prior state from which the vast majority have never stirred?”
|
"I haven't met one burnt end or rib that I haven't liked." -Andy Reid
"Sporterizing: The art of spending $700 on a $300 gun to make it worth $200." -GTwannabe |
Originally Posted By GenYRevolverGuy: Personally, I didn't love the A2 when I was in the Army. The examples I was issued were mostly older than I was and it showed, and every USGI magazine I was ever issued before I deployed should have been smashed and trashed. View Quote LOL, you should have tried going thru boot camp with an old A1 that rattled like a box of screws and always felt like it was going to fall apart. I didn't get an A2 until about year into my first duty assignment and right after qualifying with it, it was taken away and I was assigned an M3 Grease gun I am pretty sure I was more accurate throwing a rock at the target. Anyways, glad to see more choices being offered. |
|
Traveled the world, currently living in Indian Territory
|
Originally Posted By GenYRevolverGuy: Does the M16A3 actually exist in the real world? I've never seen one nor have I ever met anyone who was issued one. View Quote ETA: Finding a 1/7 government profile barrel with a rifle extension is not easy. Attached File |
|
I killed a bacon puppy. :(
This post is brought to you by The Pogues, the official punk band of the .mil forums. |
Originally Posted By UndrGrndPrdcts: I don't understand the retro fascination. It's going backwards on purpose. Things have been updated and modernized for a reason. View Quote Some of us more retro guys were issued these rifles and remember how they felt in the hand, and the memories assiciated with that. |
|
|
This world would be a better place to live if it weren't for people!
|
Eitek1: ANTIFA just destroys, hurts, silences and harms. The people they hate are better than they will ever be.
|
Sign up for the ARFCOM weekly newsletter and be entered to win a free ARFCOM membership. One new winner* is announced every week!
You will receive an email every Friday morning featuring the latest chatter from the hottest topics, breaking news surrounding legislation, as well as exclusive deals only available to ARFCOM email subscribers.
AR15.COM is the world's largest firearm community and is a gathering place for firearm enthusiasts of all types.
From hunters and military members, to competition shooters and general firearm enthusiasts, we welcome anyone who values and respects the way of the firearm.
Subscribe to our monthly Newsletter to receive firearm news, product discounts from your favorite Industry Partners, and more.
Copyright © 1996-2024 AR15.COM LLC. All Rights Reserved.
Any use of this content without express written consent is prohibited.
AR15.Com reserves the right to overwrite or replace any affiliate, commercial, or monetizable links, posted by users, with our own.