While living here, I have purchased all of two guns. One was over the counter at Omni Arms, and I got good service. They will do transfers as well, and several friends have used them for that.
When I purchased another gun online, I went with an individual who does some interesting stuff for the film industry. He was quick and responsive, I can pass on his info if you are comfortable with a kitchen table FFL.
I also just found out that feed store in Edgewood on the south side of 40 right next to 344 just started doing transfers and sales. I will be stopping by tonight on the way home to check them out, however my boss used them once, and was happy with them.
::EDIT::
Seem like nice people at the Old Mill, think they said $30 for a transfer. They had a small selection of guns behind the counter, less than 20. Shotguns, rifles, pistols. Will probably use them the next time I need an FFL.