Quote History Quoted:
Personally I wouldn't touch one with a 10 foot pole, but I have seen some reports of good ones slipping out once in a while.
Educate yourself on problem areas and inspect any potential purchase very carefully. Off the top of my head here are some things I've seen.
* canted sights, very common
* loose sights, I once saw a rack full of Marlin 45-70s are Cabelas, half were missing the front sight, the other half you could push the front sight out of it's dovetail with finger pressure only.
* horrible wood to metal fit and/or wood finish
* extremely rough action
* feeding issues
I have heard of issues with the barrel, rifling and constrictions, but have not seen this myself.
There are plenty of older, authentic Marlins out there. I'd find one of these and call it good.
View Quote
They have certainly improved in the past year or two, but they are not up to the 'golden era of Marlin' standard.... then again, Marlin toward the end of the JM stamp wasn't up to the 'Golden Era of Marlin' standard either.
Do check the things listed in the quote above. I lucked(?) into an 1895 .45-70 Remlin built that is just a hair shy of my pre-safety Marlins. I did go through the entire stock the store had of .45-70 Marlins (about a dozen of various models) and cherry picked the best of the supply...
Of that dozen, at least four should never have left the factory. Four had issues that while obvious, weren't safety / function issues... two or three were merely o.k. with some visual flaws... and 1 was just shy of perfect. It's in my safe currently alongside several of it's older cousins.
I picked that gun up during the height of the "Man, WTF did Remington do to Marlin?"... it's been flawless since I purchased it. I stripped it down and cleaned it good. Polished off a burr or two and have been shooting it happily for the past few years now.
I looked at some current production Marlins recently... they were better then when I bought that 1895 a few years ago, but some flaws in fit / finish were still visible.
TL:DR.... I wouldn't buy one you could not hand inspect prior to laying cash out. I would say these days that 35-40% of the Marlins on the rack are 'nice'... 35-40% are OK with some QC issues... and about 20% have serious flaws that shouldn't have left the factory.