Thanks, guys. In the end, I didn't even get one.
A little after I posted this thread, I cruised by the local Dick's Sporting Goods on a whim. They had the Remington 870 HD (model 25077). Normally it was $379.99, but it was on sale for $269.99... and Remington had a $50.00 mail in rebate going on, so in practical terms it was $219.99 (which is the same price as a Mossberg Maverick 88 and only ten bucks more than a 981R
). Yes, it's an Express. Yes, the one piece six-shot magazine tube precludes using any other barrel. BUT the one piece extended magazine tube eliminates a potential catch point for the follower/shells and I would never use any other barrel anyway.
I reached so fast for my wallet it was unseemly.
So far I've been pretty impressed. It operates smoothly and surely. The machining is smooth and straight, with no sharp edges. My only ding on it is that firing pin strikes are not centered, but the firing pin hits just fine and reliability has been 100%. It's cylinder bore (not improved cylinder) and buckshot tends to open up pretty fast. For shooting past 50 feet I pretty much have to use Federal's LE13300 load (8-pellet 00 Buck at 1145 fps with the Flight Control Wad) to keep all the pellets in the chest area. At about 36 feet (the only other distance I've tried it and, let's face it, is still long for a typical HD scenario), everything will shoot inside the chest area pretty comfortably. It's actually smoother and more reliable than the several new-production 870 Police Magnums I handled and shot several years ago. Maybe (hopefully) Remington is finally getting a clue.
http://www.dickssportinggoods.com/p/remington-model-870-express-hd-tactical-pump-action-shotgun-6-round-15rema870hdxprss1spg/15rema870hdxprss1spg?&color=
As long as you're OK with not being able to use other 870 barrels, I have no problem recommending this shotgun at Cabela's sale price. I think at about $300.00 or less it's a good deal.