User Panel
Posted: 8/26/2016 9:12:51 PM EDT
So I've been stocking up on my .45 ACP as two of my favorite handguns (FNX-45 Tactical and a Kimber Stainless Pro TLE II) are chambered in the round. I've been getting the itch to purchase another pistol in .45 but I'm just not sure what I want. I've thought about another USP (have one in .40) but it's more of the same.
I prefer hammer fired DA/SA or SAO handguns, is there something I should really take a look at that the members of arfcom recommend? Upfront, I like Sig rifles, not as big on the handguns. |
|
Quoted: So I've been stocking up on my .45 ACP as two of my favorite handguns (FNX-45 Tactical and a Kimber Stainless Pro TLE II) are chambered in the round. I've been getting the itch to purchase another pistol in .45 but I'm just not sure what I want. I've thought about another USP (have one in .40) but it's more of the same. I prefer hammer fired DA/SA or SAO handguns, is there something I should really take a look at that the members of arfcom recommend? Upfront, I like Sig rifles, not as big on the handguns. View Quote (not my pic) S&W 1917. If you're looking strictly for semi autos tracking down a EAA Witness match elite is always a good investment. Affordable pistols but give the accuracy of match guns that cost much, much more. |
|
Quoted: There is only one DA/SA handgun in .45 ACP worth owning. (not my pic) http://i163.photobucket.com/albums/t307/dexternikki/Smiths/MusicEvents110.jpg S&W 1917. View Quote View All Quotes View All Quotes Quoted: Quoted: So I've been stocking up on my .45 ACP as two of my favorite handguns (FNX-45 Tactical and a Kimber Stainless Pro TLE II) are chambered in the round. I've been getting the itch to purchase another pistol in .45 but I'm just not sure what I want. I've thought about another USP (have one in .40) but it's more of the same. I prefer hammer fired DA/SA or SAO handguns, is there something I should really take a look at that the members of arfcom recommend? Upfront, I like Sig rifles, not as big on the handguns. (not my pic) http://i163.photobucket.com/albums/t307/dexternikki/Smiths/MusicEvents110.jpg S&W 1917. He's not wrong yano...I'd love a 1917. The only other wheelgun in 45 I'd want is a S&W 652JM or S&W 352 As for semi autos....do you have an interest in a CCO type 1911? |
|
Quoted: He's not wrong yano...I'd love a 1917. The only other wheelgun in 45 I'd want is a S&W 652JM or S&W 352 As for semi autos....do you have an interest in a CCO type 1911? View Quote View All Quotes View All Quotes Quoted: Quoted: As for semi autos....do you have an interest in a CCO type 1911? |
|
Cz 97
Or this: https://www.cdnnsports.com/eaa-sar-k2-45acp.html?___SID=U |
|
Now that looks pretty awesome, I'm pretty on board with this idea plus a new semi auto. [
quote]Quoted: Quoted:
So I've been stocking up on my .45 ACP as two of my favorite handguns (FNX-45 Tactical and a Kimber Stainless Pro TLE II) are chambered in the round. I've been getting the itch to purchase another pistol in .45 but I'm just not sure what I want. I've thought about another USP (have one in .40) but it's more of the same. I prefer hammer fired DA/SA or SAO handguns, is there something I should really take a look at that the members of arfcom recommend? Upfront, I like Sig rifles, not as big on the handguns. There is only one DA/SA handgun in .45 ACP worth owning. (not my pic) http://i163.photobucket.com/albums/t307/dexternikki/Smiths/MusicEvents110.jpg S&W 1917. If you're looking strictly for semi autos tracking down a EAA Witness match elite is always a good investment. Affordable pistols but give the accuracy of match guns that cost much, much more. View Quote |
|
Sar K2 45. Big, heavy, accurate,14+1 and only $369 to boot. I like mine a lot.
|
|
Quoted:
So I've been stocking up on my .45 ACP as two of my favorite handguns (FNX-45 Tactical and a Kimber Stainless Pro TLE II) are chambered in the round. I've been getting the itch to purchase another pistol in .45 but I'm just not sure what I want. I've thought about another USP (have one in .40) but it's more of the same. I prefer hammer fired DA/SA or SAO handguns, is there something I should really take a look at that the members of arfcom recommend? Upfront, I like Sig rifles, not as big on the handguns. View Quote |
|
I'll have to reconsider the USP 45 then, I do love the one I already have. The TRP looks awesome too.
|
|
I'm gonna tell you to take a look at the Springfield XD (original mod). I've got the 5" tactical (13 + 1) and the 4" compact (10 + 1). Both have been 100% and are excellent guns.
|
|
Quoted:
I'm gonna tell you to take a look at the Springfield XD (original mod). I've got the 5" tactical (13 + 1) and the 4" compact (10 + 1). Both have been 100% and are excellent guns. View Quote Strikers are awesome, but it isn't for everyone nor should it be force fed. Let;s help him find something he wants |
|
Quoted:
The OP strictly stated he's a SAO and DA/SA kind of pistol guy. Strikers are awesome, but it isn't for everyone nor should it be force fed. Let;s help him find something he wants View Quote View All Quotes View All Quotes Quoted:
Quoted:
I'm gonna tell you to take a look at the Springfield XD (original mod). I've got the 5" tactical (13 + 1) and the 4" compact (10 + 1). Both have been 100% and are excellent guns. Strikers are awesome, but it isn't for everyone nor should it be force fed. Let;s help him find something he wants I'm sure glad GSL is here to keep us all in line. If we're going to nitpick, the OP also said he's not in to Sigs...come on GSL, let's not force feed the poor fellow. |
|
The S&W model 25 or 625 are excellent in 45 ACP. They have long history of fine accuracy and an excellent action.
|
|
I bought a Ruger P90 years ago and sold it but was able to find another. They are big and overly built but they are amazingly accurate and soft shooting. The HK pistols are a great platform.
|
|
You already have two of my favorite 45's, the FN Tactical and 1911. The HK USP Tactical is nice also, or the newer HK45. The Sig P220 is also nice, the 227 for extra capacity is decent too. Actually I'd probably go with a STI Tactical pistol if I was you, love those guns and extra capacity of the standard 1911. I was looking at the Wilson Combat Texas BBQ Special pistol the other day, and damn if that wasn't a nice ass gun. I just don't have the $5K it's worth, ha. The S&W M&P 45 is also nice, put an APEX trigger kit in and it's sweet.
|
|
G30
Yes I know it is striker fired and it fits the hand with all the grace of a brick . I am a long time 1911 lover and as much as I tried to hate the G30 I just shoot it so well I have to give it lots of respect. Reasonable price ,great resale , great factory support and great aftermarket support and it sort of defines reliable ,plain and boring but it's a shooter |
|
|
|
Quoted:
There is only one DA/SA handgun in .45 ACP worth owning. (not my pic) http://i163.photobucket.com/albums/t307/dexternikki/Smiths/MusicEvents110.jpg S&W 1917. If you're looking strictly for semi autos tracking down a EAA Witness match elite is always a good investment. Affordable pistols but give the accuracy of match guns that cost much, much more. View Quote View All Quotes View All Quotes Quoted:
Quoted:
So I've been stocking up on my .45 ACP as two of my favorite handguns (FNX-45 Tactical and a Kimber Stainless Pro TLE II) are chambered in the round. I've been getting the itch to purchase another pistol in .45 but I'm just not sure what I want. I've thought about another USP (have one in .40) but it's more of the same. I prefer hammer fired DA/SA or SAO handguns, is there something I should really take a look at that the members of arfcom recommend? Upfront, I like Sig rifles, not as big on the handguns. (not my pic) http://i163.photobucket.com/albums/t307/dexternikki/Smiths/MusicEvents110.jpg S&W 1917. If you're looking strictly for semi autos tracking down a EAA Witness match elite is always a good investment. Affordable pistols but give the accuracy of match guns that cost much, much more. I would love to own a S&W 1917. |
|
Haha thanks GSL for keeping the group on target.
Honestly didn't even think of a fun gun like a Kriss. This opens up some possibilities. Thanks all for the suggestions thus far! |
|
Quoted:
The OP strictly stated he's a SAO and DA/SA kind of pistol guy. Strikers are awesome, but it isn't for everyone nor should it be force fed. Let;s help him find something he wants View Quote View All Quotes View All Quotes Quoted:
Quoted:
I'm gonna tell you to take a look at the Springfield XD (original mod). I've got the 5" tactical (13 + 1) and the 4" compact (10 + 1). Both have been 100% and are excellent guns. Strikers are awesome, but it isn't for everyone nor should it be force fed. Let;s help him find something he wants A) the OP used the word "prefer" SA/DA. No where did I read the he has absolutely ruled out striker fired guns. B) the original XD line of pistols tend to be very popular with folks who like the 1911 platform, and he seems to like the 1911 platform. C) I'm not "force feeding" anyone, anything. It's the internet. He can choose to take or ignore any advice he gets. D) how is you being a d-bag to me, helping the OP more than me suggesting he look at two great .45s? E) I'll stop at D |
|
Quoted:
A) the OP used the word "prefer" SA/DA. No where did I read the he has absolutely ruled out striker fired guns. B) the original XD line of pistols tend to be very popular with folks who like the 1911 platform, and he seems to like the 1911 platform. C) I'm not "force feeding" anyone, anything. It's the internet. He can choose to take or ignore any advice he gets. D) how is you being a d-bag to me, helping the OP more than me suggesting he look at two great .45s? E) I'll stop at D View Quote View All Quotes View All Quotes Quoted:
Quoted:
Quoted:
I'm gonna tell you to take a look at the Springfield XD (original mod). I've got the 5" tactical (13 + 1) and the 4" compact (10 + 1). Both have been 100% and are excellent guns. Strikers are awesome, but it isn't for everyone nor should it be force fed. Let;s help him find something he wants A) the OP used the word "prefer" SA/DA. No where did I read the he has absolutely ruled out striker fired guns. B) the original XD line of pistols tend to be very popular with folks who like the 1911 platform, and he seems to like the 1911 platform. C) I'm not "force feeding" anyone, anything. It's the internet. He can choose to take or ignore any advice he gets. D) how is you being a d-bag to me, helping the OP more than me suggesting he look at two great .45s? E) I'll stop at D I stopped after A. because it was pointless by then. |
|
Quoted:
A) the OP used the word "prefer" SA/DA. No where did I read the he has absolutely ruled out striker fired guns. B) the original XD line of pistols tend to be very popular with folks who like the 1911 platform, and he seems to like the 1911 platform. C) I'm not "force feeding" anyone, anything. It's the internet. He can choose to take or ignore any advice he gets. D) how is you being a d-bag to me, helping the OP more than me suggesting he look at two great .45s? E) I'll stop at D View Quote View All Quotes View All Quotes Quoted:
Quoted:
Quoted:
I'm gonna tell you to take a look at the Springfield XD (original mod). I've got the 5" tactical (13 + 1) and the 4" compact (10 + 1). Both have been 100% and are excellent guns. Strikers are awesome, but it isn't for everyone nor should it be force fed. Let;s help him find something he wants A) the OP used the word "prefer" SA/DA. No where did I read the he has absolutely ruled out striker fired guns. B) the original XD line of pistols tend to be very popular with folks who like the 1911 platform, and he seems to like the 1911 platform. C) I'm not "force feeding" anyone, anything. It's the internet. He can choose to take or ignore any advice he gets. D) how is you being a d-bag to me, helping the OP more than me suggesting he look at two great .45s? E) I'll stop at D You'd better be careful...you're going to make GSL's hissy fit / "ignore list"...then where will you be without his telling you what you can / can't say? He's kind of like that little girl we all remember from grade school...you know, the one who runs around trying to mother all the other kids and who likes to stay in at recess to grade papers for the teacher. I also remember that girl was always far from the best or brightest...she just had to be up everbody's butt desperately trying to be what she's not. That's GSL. Of course, I'm on his little hissy fit "ignore list," so he'll miss my asessment of his continued d-baggery. Oh, if you make his ignore list, he'll make a big production out of it...he needs you to know that he's exercised his authority...it's priceless. |
|
I'd recommend either a Sig P220 as a single stack option or an HK USP45 for hicap. My Sig has a really sweet factory trigger, but my HK USP 9mm is 16 years old and still runs like it's brand new. I recently replaced the recoil spring but after comparing them the old one looks as good as the replacement.
I also have an older CZ97B, it's big n heavy but has a great SA trigger. Has a long DA trigger pull which doesn't fit everyone's hand. Trigger feels a lot like a S&W N frame revolver. No bad choices here. I'd also looked at a used or new S&W .45acp revolver. They're nice, but more than I'd want to pay just to shoot cheap .45acp. If I'm spending that much I'll go with another mod.29 and start reloading .44mag again. I went with a Ruger Blackhawk convertible. Not really a big fan of single action cowboy guns, just liked the fact it didn't need mooncliips. |
|
Quoted: So I've been stocking up on my .45 ACP as two of my favorite handguns (FNX-45 Tactical and a Kimber Stainless Pro TLE II) are chambered in the round. I've been getting the itch to purchase another pistol in .45 but I'm just not sure what I want. I've thought about another USP (have one in .40) but it's more of the same. I prefer hammer fired DA/SA or SAO handguns, is there something I should really take a look at that the members of arfcom recommend? Upfront, I like Sig rifles, not as big on the handguns. View Quote S&W 625 |
|
Quoted:
Quoted:
So I've been stocking up on my .45 ACP as two of my favorite handguns (FNX-45 Tactical and a Kimber Stainless Pro TLE II) are chambered in the round. I've been getting the itch to purchase another pistol in .45 but I'm just not sure what I want. I've thought about another USP (have one in .40) but it's more of the same. I prefer hammer fired DA/SA or SAO handguns, is there something I should really take a look at that the members of arfcom recommend? Upfront, I like Sig rifles, not as big on the handguns. S&W 625 I've got the 625-8 PC Model, it's a fun gun to own and shoot; very accurate. For range use, you can shoot them without moon clips and just flick out the fired cases if you choose. |
|
This is the second thread where I've seen posters decide to take the thread from a technical slant to a personal one.
I'd rather not sanction posters personally but if that's what it takes... Stop fucking with each other, in here, and talk guns, please. |
|
Thanks everyone for all of the replies, I've been thinking about this and the winner is a Kriss Vector SDP in 45. It has no practical purpose but to become an SBR (it'll be form 1'd for sure) but I know I'll get a shit eating grin every time I shoot it.
When the bonus check comes in December it'll be time for a USP in 45. |
|
|
HK USP 45, unless you need a picitinany light rail to saw down trees.
|
|
For a reasonably priced gun look at the Ruger SR1911 full size or Commander size. I have the LW 9mm Commander and it's a wonderful gun. I'm a 1911 45ACP guy at heart but the 9mm LW Commander is great for carry. I also have a STI Ranger II 45ACP all steel Commander and a Colt 45ACP LW Commander. After an adjustment to their extractors they are now 100% reliable with JHPs. If you want a less expensive 1911 look at the RIA line, very good guns at great prices.
|
|
Quoted:
You already have a 1911 and an fnx, it sounds like your practical needs are fulfilled . I submit a purely fun gun, just for smiles. http://files.harrispublications.com/wp-content/uploads/sites/6/2014/12/Kriss-Vector-SDP-13.jpg The vector pistol, because you only live once. Or maybe a converted webly https://s3.amazonaws.com/mgm-content/sites/armslist/uploads/posts/2015/09/27/4729494_02_british_webley_mk_vi_455_45_ac_640.jpg Lots of fun and a little bit of neat factor. Or forget acp, tear the space time continuum and go for a single action army. .45 lc is a blast to shoot and a little class never hurt anybody. BBQ example http://www.engravingtransfers.com/usaf3_right_side.jpg View Quote OMFG! |
|
Okay, I saw about the hammer/striker, but really, if you want a work-a-day .45 auto that can 'take a lickin' and keep on tickin', how about the new Ruger American? Its a good-looking polymer/striker that addresses many of the shortcomings in similar pistols and was designed and built to be a service pistol. It has a milled steel chassis instead of the usual stamped steel or milled aluminum. There are a number of other features that are good, such as the grip adjusting backstraps.
|
|
Quoted:
He's not wrong yano...I'd love a 1917. The only other wheelgun in 45 I'd want is a S&W 652JM or S&W 352 As for semi autos....do you have an interest in a CCO type 1911? View Quote View All Quotes View All Quotes Quoted:
Quoted:
Quoted:
So I've been stocking up on my .45 ACP as two of my favorite handguns (FNX-45 Tactical and a Kimber Stainless Pro TLE II) are chambered in the round. I've been getting the itch to purchase another pistol in .45 but I'm just not sure what I want. I've thought about another USP (have one in .40) but it's more of the same. I prefer hammer fired DA/SA or SAO handguns, is there something I should really take a look at that the members of arfcom recommend? Upfront, I like Sig rifles, not as big on the handguns. (not my pic) http://i163.photobucket.com/albums/t307/dexternikki/Smiths/MusicEvents110.jpg S&W 1917. He's not wrong yano...I'd love a 1917. The only other wheelgun in 45 I'd want is a S&W 652JM or S&W 352 As for semi autos....do you have an interest in a CCO type 1911? The original Model 25 is pretty nice. |
|
I'd say get a USP45 Tactical, but you'd wind up never shooting your FNX
CZ97 is the other obvious answer, but you'll be in danger of ditching your 1911 if you go that route. SAR K2 45 if you're willing to risk NEVER needing service from EAA, who are dickbags. The gun is freaking sweet. If the all stainless version makes it stateside for similar money to the black one ($400-$500ish) I'd be hard pressed to pass it up, and I HATE EAA after the debacle that was my SAR B6Pc. But really OP, if you don't have a USP Tactical, and love the .45ACP round, you're missing out on what is very possibly the best gun ever made for it. Barrel threads are the same as the Kriss you're getting also, FYI. Get a 45 suppressor regardless of anything else. Sooner you start the paperwork, the sooner it will get done. |
|
Quoted:
I'd say get a USP45 Tactical, but you'd wind up never shooting your FNX CZ97 is the other obvious answer, but you'll be in danger of ditching your 1911 if you go that route. SAR K2 45 if you're willing to risk NEVER needing service from EAA, who are dickbags. The gun is freaking sweet. If the all stainless version makes it stateside for similar money to the black one ($400-$500ish) I'd be hard pressed to pass it up, and I HATE EAA after the debacle that was my SAR B6Pc. But really OP, if you don't have a USP Tactical, and love the .45ACP round, you're missing out on what is very possibly the best gun ever made for it. Barrel threads are the same as the Kriss you're getting also, FYI. Get a 45 suppressor regardless of anything else. Sooner you start the paperwork, the sooner it will get done. View Quote Your Hate for EAA just made me buy a K2 Didn't even know I wanted one |
|
Quoted: Your Hate for EAA just made me buy a K2 Didn't even know I wanted one View Quote View All Quotes View All Quotes Quoted: Quoted: I'd say get a USP45 Tactical, but you'd wind up never shooting your FNX CZ97 is the other obvious answer, but you'll be in danger of ditching your 1911 if you go that route. SAR K2 45 if you're willing to risk NEVER needing service from EAA, who are dickbags. The gun is freaking sweet. If the all stainless version makes it stateside for similar money to the black one ($400-$500ish) I'd be hard pressed to pass it up, and I HATE EAA after the debacle that was my SAR B6Pc. But really OP, if you don't have a USP Tactical, and love the .45ACP round, you're missing out on what is very possibly the best gun ever made for it. Barrel threads are the same as the Kriss you're getting also, FYI. Get a 45 suppressor regardless of anything else. Sooner you start the paperwork, the sooner it will get done. Didn't even know I wanted one |
|
Quoted:
I didn't know EAA had bad customer service? I dealt with them a few times awhile back and they were chill as hell and handled business. Only place better is RIA. View Quote View All Quotes View All Quotes Quoted:
Quoted:
Quoted:
I'd say get a USP45 Tactical, but you'd wind up never shooting your FNX CZ97 is the other obvious answer, but you'll be in danger of ditching your 1911 if you go that route. SAR K2 45 if you're willing to risk NEVER needing service from EAA, who are dickbags. The gun is freaking sweet. If the all stainless version makes it stateside for similar money to the black one ($400-$500ish) I'd be hard pressed to pass it up, and I HATE EAA after the debacle that was my SAR B6Pc. But really OP, if you don't have a USP Tactical, and love the .45ACP round, you're missing out on what is very possibly the best gun ever made for it. Barrel threads are the same as the Kriss you're getting also, FYI. Get a 45 suppressor regardless of anything else. Sooner you start the paperwork, the sooner it will get done. Didn't even know I wanted one Not to get too off topic, but I got a SAR B6Pc from CDNN. The front frame insert broke in less than 200rds. They would fix it if I shipped it to them on my dime. I asked if they would just send me the $20 part, I'm an FFL, I have a full time gunsmith, who has done this exact repair before on your shitty gun. Nope. OK, fine, I'll just buy it. Can I buy another 13rd mag for it? No, we only sell 10rd mags in CO. We know its not the law, we just do it that way anyway. I fixed, and sold the gun, for a very small loss. The K2 is sooooo nice though... I still want one. Grip the size of an M9 but holds all that 45, the one we had in the store had an amazing trigger, and was crazy accurate. And I think its a damn fine looking pistol. But EAA's seeming lack of any interest in fixing or replacing a defective gun left a very sour taste in my mouth. |
|
I really like my Sig P227. I ended up selling my Glock 41 because I shot the Sig so much better. The Glock 41/21 frame is just a little too big for my Carny hands.
|
|
Quoted:
Now that looks pretty awesome, I'm pretty on board with this idea plus a new semi auto. [ quote]Quoted: View Quote View All Quotes View All Quotes Quoted:
Now that looks pretty awesome, I'm pretty on board with this idea plus a new semi auto. [ quote]Quoted: Quoted:
So I've been stocking up on my .45 ACP as two of my favorite handguns (FNX-45 Tactical and a Kimber Stainless Pro TLE II) are chambered in the round. I've been getting the itch to purchase another pistol in .45 but I'm just not sure what I want. I've thought about another USP (have one in .40) but it's more of the same. I prefer hammer fired DA/SA or SAO handguns, is there something I should really take a look at that the members of arfcom recommend? Upfront, I like Sig rifles, not as big on the handguns. There is only one DA/SA handgun in .45 ACP worth owning. (not my pic) http://i163.photobucket.com/albums/t307/dexternikki/Smiths/MusicEvents110.jpg S&W 1917. If you're looking strictly for semi autos tracking down a EAA Witness match elite is always a good investment. Affordable pistols but give the accuracy of match guns that cost much, much more. The 1917 is pretty awesome... Check out S&W's model 626 "Mountain Gun" as well. It's a really sweet .45acp revolver... |
|
Quoted:
Your Hate for EAA just made me buy a K2 Didn't even know I wanted one View Quote View All Quotes View All Quotes Quoted:
Quoted:
I'd say get a USP45 Tactical, but you'd wind up never shooting your FNX CZ97 is the other obvious answer, but you'll be in danger of ditching your 1911 if you go that route. SAR K2 45 if you're willing to risk NEVER needing service from EAA, who are dickbags. The gun is freaking sweet. If the all stainless version makes it stateside for similar money to the black one ($400-$500ish) I'd be hard pressed to pass it up, and I HATE EAA after the debacle that was my SAR B6Pc. But really OP, if you don't have a USP Tactical, and love the .45ACP round, you're missing out on what is very possibly the best gun ever made for it. Barrel threads are the same as the Kriss you're getting also, FYI. Get a 45 suppressor regardless of anything else. Sooner you start the paperwork, the sooner it will get done. Your Hate for EAA just made me buy a K2 Didn't even know I wanted one EAA warranty service is notoriously horrible. If you think you've heard bad stories about shitty companies such as Taurus... then double the worthlessness for EAA. You better hope your new K2 doesn't need warranty service. If it does, just pay to have it fixed. Good luck! |
|
|
Sign up for the ARFCOM weekly newsletter and be entered to win a free ARFCOM membership. One new winner* is announced every week!
You will receive an email every Friday morning featuring the latest chatter from the hottest topics, breaking news surrounding legislation, as well as exclusive deals only available to ARFCOM email subscribers.
AR15.COM is the world's largest firearm community and is a gathering place for firearm enthusiasts of all types.
From hunters and military members, to competition shooters and general firearm enthusiasts, we welcome anyone who values and respects the way of the firearm.
Subscribe to our monthly Newsletter to receive firearm news, product discounts from your favorite Industry Partners, and more.
Copyright © 1996-2024 AR15.COM LLC. All Rights Reserved.
Any use of this content without express written consent is prohibited.
AR15.Com reserves the right to overwrite or replace any affiliate, commercial, or monetizable links, posted by users, with our own.