I don't see anyone really posting about this lube and I also don't see much negativity. Has anyone used this?  If so how does it compare to the other "green" products such as Froblube (Extreme) and Fireclean as well as regular lubricants/cleaners/protectors?

Fireclean is the best organic I have used, however, I don't recommend it for storage.

I used Seal1 for a few years and it works fine.  Just switched to Weapon Shield and so far I like it better.  Seal1 smells better but I dont like that the liquid separates in the bottle and as a cleaner it worked well except for the barrel that I still needed Hoppe's 9 for.  WS just seems to do a better job cleaning and lubricating.

have used seal1 on my ar and 1911, worked real good.

FROGLUBE, TRACKLUBE, AND SEAL1 LABORATORY ANALYSIS

All those "organic" lubes are dildos.

Get Weapon Shield.

Watch this guy's videos and make your decision.

I don't think I ever said I was considering using it. I was just wondering what people thought.

However I would never trust a company who conducts their own tests instead of hiring an independent unbiased party. This happened with Aspartame. The Aspartame "cancer" causing myth started from a doctor who was paid to say it was bad. Even after years and him admitting it, the general public still thinks aspartame is bad because of this lie. Dozens of independent tests including tests from the FDA have determined that aspartame, even in large doses (larger than a huge would ever consume) didn't cause cancer in rats.

My point is, never trust the person doing a test if they are a related party.

I get that, but the ingredients are well known regarding Weapon Shield, and they work. There is no pixie dust involved. Also, the inventor's track record is superb, having first invented FP-10, for which 3rd party tests exist in abundance.