User Panel
Quoted:
The issues with 18650 batteries is from using the cheap ass fakes. As has been pointed out, if you stick to known Brands from REPUTABLE suppliers you can trust, you won't have any issues. I don't remember if it's from this thread or a different one, but a member stated "Don't trust any rechargeable brand that their name ends in fire" There are quite a few crap cells that their name ends in "fire" that sell batteries that are unsafe and make outrageous claims as to capacity. I only use AW brand IMR cells from Oveready. I was purchasing Panasonic cells, but they are slightly larger in diameter than AW cells and were too tight a fit in my Zebralight SC600. If you want to have an explosion, in your hand....cut corners on your batteries. Funny thing, the members of candlepowerforums.com have been using 18650's for years with ZERO issues but then again they know better than to purchase CRAP! View Quote |
|
You DO realize that ALL LED's are manufactured in China including the units Surefire uses?
|
|
Quoted:
No one in CID at my department uses a handheld light that is not at least 1000 lumens for a daily carry light. Olight, Thrunite, Fenix, etc. I have a 600 lumen E2B on a active shooter/felony warrant belt kit in the trunk, but carry a Fenix daily right now. Virtually all of them use 18650. Every single member of CID has a lithium ion charger with batteries in their office. Patrol is also shifting away from big Streamlights to smaller lights that use 18650. The only reason the weapon lights are not 18650 is because Surefire is behind the curve and trying to sell its own brand 123 cells. Now that Streamlight has an 18650 weaponlight for under $150 I can tell you 90% of the new weapon lights on long guns at my department are going to be Streamlight until Surefire catches up. Handgun lights, its Surefire and Streamlight 50/50 and all 123 cells, but for rifle lights it is all over the place due to the price of the Surefire rifle lights. Id love a Scout format 18650 that did 900-1000 lumens and Id pay twice the cost of a Streamlight to get it. The 600 lumens Scout is fine indoors but outside it just dies past 100 yards. Never heard of some one complain a light was too bright in law enforcement except when writing a ticket. If you are using the light correctly, you should not even be looking at the light directly most of the time, when searching. Do a quick strobe while panning the light up, down, left, right etc. get a flash image of the area and move in the dark, then pop it again, etc. The reflected light will illuminate the room effectively. Introduce light to a room before you enter it to blind anyone inside. By keeping the light intermittent anyone in another room cannot tell when you are near or how far you are. By introducing light to a room before entering you rob anyone inside of their night vision. After that you can pop a blip of light as you get in position and clear on your terms. The more light for this the better. If you meet someone with their own light you better have significantly more lumens than they do because the person with the least lumens is going to be blinded while the other person can still see. Low light is only needed for administrative tasks that require continuous light, very close range observations, etc. which is a small portion of what is needed and a weapon light is NOT what you want to use for those tasks. These ideas of 60-75 lumens is all you need and under 300 is what you want is beyond ridiculous. You guys must have old weapon lights on the EE or something. View Quote |
|
I just ordered the 800 lumen TLR1 HL for <$100. I can't wait to compare it to my 600lumen x300ub.
So far it seems like Streamlight (with the TLR-1 Hl and ProTac Railmounts) might be a legitimate quality alternative to SF at "human prices". I love SF but they're being given a real run for the money. Now Streamlight just needs a 1k lumen dual output series for IR. |
|
Quoted:
You DO realize that ALL LED's are manufactured in China including the units Surefire uses? View Quote |
|
Quoted:
I just ordered the 800 lumen TLR1 HL for <$100. I can't wait to compare it to my 600lumen x300ub. So far it seems like Streamlight (with the TLR-1 Hl and ProTac Railmounts) might be a legitimate quality alternative to SF at "human prices". I love SF but they're being given a real run for the money. Now Streamlight just needs a 1k lumen dual output series for IR. View Quote |
|
Quoted:
If police/swat, military and firefighters can trust streamlight products, I'm sure they will be just fine View Quote |
|
Well...when I was in the Ukraine...
that 600 lumens was a god send....and lots of fun as it blinded people severely. The Ultra defender was the same also. |
|
Quoted:
If police/swat, military and firefighters can trust streamlight products, I'm sure they will be just fine View Quote |
|
I am also annoyed that Surefire sticks you with their BS push for momentary/turn for constant on switch.
|
|
|
|
|
|
Quoted:
Agreed. View Quote Attached File Attached File |
|
Quoted:
This is sadly so, in most cases. That said, I just can't get on board with the cheapie alternatives like streamlight. Lack of quality is too tangible, from poor architecture design, to cheap anodizing etc. View Quote try to put on a X300 then put on a tlr-1 then come back and spout your bull shit about poor design. I don't know what you want a flash light to dobut the TLR-1 will do it better the only drawback is the switches. sure fire's remote tape switch options are far better. I am over all unimpressed with the Surfire product line when compared to stream light. |
|
Quoted:
They can't even begin to compare to a light like the Fenix TK75 which outputs 4,000 lumens at a price of UNDER $200.00 Oh, wait a minute, they DO have the Hellfighter 5 at 4,500 lumens that retails for $4,300.00 I drank the Surefire KoolAid for YEARS, I have several thousand dollars in Surefire lights. That was before I wandered into Candlepowerforums.com Fenix TK75 2015 Turbo - 4000 Lumens - 1 hr. 40 min. High - 1600 Lumens - 3 hr. 40 min. Mid - 600 Lumens - 11 hr. 20 min. Low - 35 Lumens - 270 hr. http://i135.photobucket.com/albums/q125/PursuitSS/Bolt%20Carriers/3483558A-AE22-4345-BEFB-93F4B257F620.jpg One place I will give it to Surefire is dedicated weapons lights, I'm running a Surefire M600 on my duty rifle with an aftermarket LED head. If the M600 body was thick enough I'd bore it to 18mm and use a 18650 battery. But it's too damn thin. I've yet to find a tape switch comparable to Surefire. View Quote |
|
Quoted:
Quoted:
They can't even begin to compare to a light like the Fenix TK75 which outputs 4,000 lumens at a price of UNDER $200.00 Oh, wait a minute, they DO have the Hellfighter 5 at 4,500 lumens that retails for $4,300.00 I drank the Surefire KoolAid for YEARS, I have several thousand dollars in Surefire lights. That was before I wandered into Candlepowerforums.com Fenix TK75 2015 Turbo - 4000 Lumens - 1 hr. 40 min. High - 1600 Lumens - 3 hr. 40 min. Mid - 600 Lumens - 11 hr. 20 min. Low - 35 Lumens - 270 hr. http://i135.photobucket.com/albums/q125/PursuitSS/Bolt%20Carriers/3483558A-AE22-4345-BEFB-93F4B257F620.jpg One place I will give it to Surefire is dedicated weapons lights, I'm running a Surefire M600 on my duty rifle with an aftermarket LED head. If the M600 body was thick enough I'd bore it to 18mm and use a 18650 battery. But it's too damn thin. I've yet to find a tape switch comparable to Surefire. |
|
My offer is still open.
If anyone is unhappy with how bright their X300U is, I'll trade my x300 for it and pay for shipping. |
|
Per Surfire's site some are completely made with US parts and some use parts from outside the US.
Quoted:
Fenix lights are fantastic for their cost and durability. |
|
|
For me 300 Lumens is enough for indoor/outdoor use. This depends alot on bezel design too imo. I find the 600 Lumen lights rediculous, then again I dont live on a bazilion acre farm, im in the city. So I agree with the op, but everyones needs are dif.
|
|
Quoted:
Anyone else annoyed with Surefire making lights brighter and brighter and with shorter and shorter battery life? I don't need 600 lumens on a handgun light (x300). That much light will blind me and ruin my night vision. I would rather have 100 lumens and 6-8 hours of battery life. View Quote I'm with you (not just Surefire, but all light makers). I recently received an Olight PL2 Valkyrie and it's completely useless indoors (1200 lumens! Yikes) which I believe is the leader for the most lumens for a pistol light. . As soon as you turn it off, your blind for about a minute. The lumen race is ridiculous. It's like the auto industry's horsepower wars. You get to the point that you cannot possibly use it (on the road) anyway, so it's just wasted (unless bragging rights is someone's idea of "useful"). What I would like to see is light manufacturers install a switch on the outside so we could quickly switch between an indoor/outdoor mode. Say... 300 lumen (max) as indoor mode, and whatever your heart desires for outdoor (ETA: not talking about tailcap, talking about a separate exterior switch, so the tailcap mode/operation can remain a 1 push deal). They seem to be ignoring there are two distinct uses for lights (indoor and outdoor) and one mode does not work well for both. A quickly accessed switch (such as the constant/momentary switch on Inforce WML) would be a godsend and make lights, truly, a one does all. Surefire, Olight, Inforce... are you listening? Feel free to call it the "Maverick model" |
|
I was annoyed when they made a 600V with 350 lumens of white light to replace the 150 lu. I still bought it, but it's almost as if they had been holding on to the technology for making $
|
|
Quoted:
i really want a decent battery life. View Quote Surefire's launches a new 300 lumen light, it has 1.5 hours run time. Light is upgraded to 500 lumens, still has 1.5 hours run time. Output is upgraded to 600 lumens, still 1.5 hours run time. Light just comes out with 800 lumens, you guessed it, 1.5 hours run time. They need to hire a run a run time engineering team and focus on that. |
|
I’m mostly annoyed that they don’t sell reasonable priced replacement heads. I’ve got a bunch of old scouts, some with the first gen leds which iirc were only 100 lumens.
Looking at their website and they have a 500 lumen replacement head for a whopping $10 less than a complete 600 lumen scout. I get why they do that, but it’s still shitty. |
|
|
|
Quoted: That's B.S. There are ZERO manufacturers of LED's in the U.S. View Quote |
|
Quoted:
This is sadly so, in most cases. That said, I just can't get on board with the cheapie alternatives like streamlight. Lack of quality is too tangible, from poor architecture design, to cheap anodizing etc. View Quote Like I said in the other thread and more and more people are getting wise to, SF’s days are numbered unless they make some real changes soon. And not finally offering a high lumen dual fuel light for triple the price of everyone else. |
|
Quoted:
Sign me up! If I can dim my truck's gauge cluster, I should be able to dial down my weaponlights too. View Quote View All Quotes View All Quotes Quoted:
Quoted:
First weapon light with a dimmer adjustment wins. Just needs to be a micro screw driver slot. I like the lower setting for clearing a house and the brighter setting for clearing outside. Having cleared many a building, I prefer no more than 250 lumens (and even 120 is fine for inside a house) inside a building and 250+ outside. I have used the brighter setting for clearing inside large warehouses. The Fenix light offers what you are looking for. |
|
Surefire really needs to understand output is only one piece of the puzzle. IDGAF about a 2k lumen pistol light that has a 1 minute run time.
|
|
Quoted:
I’m mostly annoyed that they don’t sell reasonable priced replacement heads. I’ve got a bunch of old scouts, some with the first gen leds which iirc were only 100 lumens. Looking at their website and they have a 500 lumen replacement head for a whopping $10 less than a complete 600 lumen scout. I get why they do that, but it’s still shitty. View Quote After using the 1000 lumen Streaight HLX rail mount and regular HLX hand held variants regularly at work, I can say they push the limit indoors for comfort to red line. They are perfect outdoors, but I could use a tiny bit more in the hot spot only for pure range, but not in the spill, which hits nearby objects like fences, tree limbs etc. to prevent you from seeing further. If I try to use 1000 lumens tp search under a car seat I get a painful reminder to use a lower level setting. I wish I could get that light output in a M600 size/weight or better yet an Arisaka 300/ Surefire M300 size/weight package. Run time not an issue with a rechargeable lithium ion battery IMO. Use lower mode on a hand held for more run time. Currently I am also not appreciative of Surefire going for more lumens at the expense of lux. I don't need less range and more spill to get a higher lumen rating on the box. Though the guys who hate high lumens indoors probably prefer the less blinding hotspot indoors. Tactical flashlights are SUPPOSED to blind anyone's night adapted vision that sees the output. They should also blind and overpower any light an adversary may shine at you. When you both light each other up, the guy with much higher lumens/lux can see and the guy with a lower powered light just sees a bright spot. |
|
I like the bright stuff, but I'm caught in a catch 22 right now. I'm not 100% trusting of Streamlight, but Surefire's prices are to the point that I just can't justify buying them anymore.
I bought an E2D-LED when I graduated college and it had around 200/15 lumens. It was great, but after a couple years, didn't seem as bright. I wanted to relegate it to backup duty and buy another one (higher output) for daily duty. The price had risen from the $116 I paid to $180. Even the single 123 was like $160-170ish. The equivalent streamlight was $53. I also love my x300UA, but $170 used was an amazing amount of money for a stupid used flashlight. I never understood the pricing of the scout lights either. Never seemed like you were getting much for the assload of cash you're laying down to get it. I'm pretty happy with current offerings for performance. Newer tech will make LEDs more efficient if/when they decide to stop trying to have the highest bragging rights. Until then, it'll just be a dick measuring contest. |
|
Quoted:
Anyone else annoyed with Surefire . View Quote |
|
I hate to say this.....
But with Surefire offering the Scout light that uses an 18650 battery I’m afraid I’m going in for the Kool Aid again. But I’ll probably use an aftermarket head from vinhnguyen54 or Oveready. |
|
|
So let me get this straight, you want a company to stop developing products because YOU yourself have poor low light techniques and end up blinding yourself?
Guys we need to tell barrel mfgs to stop making more accurate barrels because I cant shoot that accurately anyway. |
|
This thread long ago departed the rails of "productive for a tech forum."
|
|
Sign up for the ARFCOM weekly newsletter and be entered to win a free ARFCOM membership. One new winner* is announced every week!
You will receive an email every Friday morning featuring the latest chatter from the hottest topics, breaking news surrounding legislation, as well as exclusive deals only available to ARFCOM email subscribers.
AR15.COM is the world's largest firearm community and is a gathering place for firearm enthusiasts of all types.
From hunters and military members, to competition shooters and general firearm enthusiasts, we welcome anyone who values and respects the way of the firearm.
Subscribe to our monthly Newsletter to receive firearm news, product discounts from your favorite Industry Partners, and more.
Copyright © 1996-2024 AR15.COM LLC. All Rights Reserved.
Any use of this content without express written consent is prohibited.
AR15.Com reserves the right to overwrite or replace any affiliate, commercial, or monetizable links, posted by users, with our own.