Quote History Quoted:
Perhaps you should have asked a more specific question if you are looking for a specific answer. Your inquiry was vague at best. You inquired about differences and why pick one over the other. Battery choice may very well sway someone's decision if they are trying to keep all the same battery types around. You made no indication in your original post that you knew ALL of the specs of all 3 models. If you wanted to know the difference in usability, quality, brightness, durability, you should ask specifically. Not everyone is a mind reader.
Don't knock someone's reply that is trying to help you. The reply satisfied the question, but didn't meet your expectations.
View Quote
I understood what he meant, but your answer was fine until the part about "you could have read yourself." That's where your help derailed and became snobbish, at best, but really more like a first class arrogant jerk, which is all too common on this and most internet forums. I'm sure you didn't intend it that way, but that's the way it came across in writing.
Back to topic...I've got the original Sparc (two of them), had a Strikefire, and a Sparc AR. I put a Sparc on a Ruger 10/22, so the low mount option as described previously is gtg for that kind of deal. I've also got a Sparc mounted on an M4gery, at lower 1/3, and it works great and is very light weight. The Sparc AR is on a PSA build, also at lower 1/3, and it is GREAT. The Sparc AR feels more durable and solid because it has one less shim in the mount. It also has a rubber cover, which I think is nice. The AAA battery is the champ, though, as it is easy to find and easy to replace, especially in the field where you are trying not to get dust or dirt in there.
The Strikefire was fine, but didn't really gain anything over the Sparc except bulk and weight, so I sold it. It performed well, though.
As for durability, I've knocked my Sparcs around quite a bit and they've held zero and had no issues. They do use batteries up while stored, but I bought a large package of 12 or so of them from Amazon for very little money. I haven't had the Sparc AR long enough to say anything about durability, and I've not knocked it around at all. I also don't know if it will eat the battery while in storage, but if it does, I can look in a kitchen droor and probably find a AAA laying around. However, I've seen some videos that show some pretty compelling evidence of the durability of the Sparc AR, including some pretty nasty drops, freezing in an ice block, etc.
The field of view appears about the same, btw, between the Sparc AR and Sparc. The Sparc II might be worth a look, but I've not seen them for a price anywhere near the Sparc AR. I did the 199 deal at PSA with 10 Pmags. Can't beat it!