Update on the gas plug: the gas plug that came with the rifle had a manufacture date of 12/15 and spun freely in the gas block. I called POF, talked to a guy briefly and got an RMA. I shipped them the gas plug and within a couple business days they shipped a new plug with a manufacture date of 09/16. The new plug works as expected. Hope to get it to the range tomorrow.
Looking at some pictures I took of the original gas plug, I think the detent on the new one sits just a hair lower than the old one. The detent itself appears to be unchanged, but I wonder if they didn't relocate that detent hole that's in the plug by a few hundredths of an inch.
One last note: the tech I spoke with at POF said they went from s 3 position gas system to a 5 position gas system about a year ago. I still haven't found any marketing materials or descriptions that indicate a 5 position gas regulator.
Anyhow, I hope someday if somebody has the same problem they do an internet search and find this useful. Despite what some have reported, POF customer service does NOT suck if you're just a tiny bit patient. Took a little time to be resolved but resolved it was, no kicking and screaming and Internet tantrum required.