Quote History Quoted:
What would be your "best" then in your opinion?
Maybe a list of good to bad.
View Quote View All Quotes
View All Quotes
Quote History Quoted:
Quoted:
Model 1 Sales and "Quality" are mutually exclusive words in the same sentence in my experience, but they are an economy option if you want to say you have something that looks like an AR15.
You can get them to work well, and some are hit, while others are miss. If plinking is all that you might do a few times a year, they are an option.
What would be your "best" then in your opinion?
Maybe a list of good to bad.
Ive been in a place for a while where I have a hard time trusting many manufactures to get it right. Because of all the things I do when working on my own projects, the components I select, and the build procedures, I know what there is to be done for reliability and accuracy, so why would I leave that up to someone on an assembly line? That's just my perspective after working with AR15's/M16's/M4's since 1988.
There is too much variance in quality and assembly methods across almost all of the manufacturers, so a best-to-worst list would have to be by lot or even serial number, not the brand name Joe Blow sees engraved on a lower or barrel fore end.
If we're talking about parts kits in the price range of Model 1 Sales, I will steer you to J&T Distributing/Double Star. They actually have components and products that are priced lower than value, in my experience. The LPK's I've seen from them lately have all had proof marks and inspection codes on the MIM'd pieces like the hammer, trigger, bolt catch, and selector, and the fit and finish of those components is of a high quality.
I'm pretty picky about what kind of bolt, bolt carrier, carrier key, and barrel I will use. Same for receivers, but I'm looking more at upper-to-lower fit, 7000 series alloy, proper anodizing, dry film coating inside the BCG raceway, and a square face on the upper.
Name a component and I have a list of things I look for. Some of the most important things are materials sourcing on critical components like the barrel, barrel extension, and bolt, as well as the processes used to make them. Gas port diameter is a big one on barrels, combined with gas system length. Trouble-shooting the gas system and operating system involves a lot of little details that are just flat over-looked by most gun show grade parts kits suppliers. Think about how many people have jumped into the AR15 parts market, even dating back to the 1980's, who don't know a thing about the system other than it sells and they want to make money.
I've literally talked with scores of new AR15 manufacturers who had never heard about basically every aspect of the gun I asked them about, especially some of the critical components and assembly methods, materials selection, and dimensions. They basically purchase or machine one or two components of the guns, outsource the rest, slap them together, and throw a cool-sounding name on them that implies quality or precision, while most of the critical parts are not inspected and QC'd before going into their guns.
I've always been happy with Alexander Arms, Precision Firearms, BCM, Colt, Daniel Defense, GA Precision, Knight's, JP Enterprises, Noveske, Seekins Precision, and J&T for economical parts kits. I haven't purchased an AR15 off the shelf since 1997/98, if that tells you anything, and I've been on a steady panic-buy, controlled paranoia purchasing posture since before the Clinton AWB of 1994. I don't own any flat screen TV's, rims for my cars, or video game consoles.
Almost every bad AR15 company you've heard of, I've had experiences with over the years, although I have managed to avoid probably the worst offender of all: Hesse/Vulcan. I think I would own a Chinese copy of the M4 before I pulled the trigger on a Hesse.