I've had a bunch of different station boot over the years. I typically buy good boots; because my feet hate me if I don't.
Started with Rocky boot way back when. Didn't last too long and no zippers.
The Red Wing 4473's with the lace zippers; worked pretty well but the have an inside style sole and they're not good for snow and ice. I did buy 2 pairs of them and they lasted a long time; long enough to get resoled. They would last 2-3 years, each pair.
Next I tried the Danner Acadia's. The sole was a little thin for me. Good boots though; they got retired to work boots. Regular lace ups; no zip.
After those, I got a pair of Haix Air Powers. Fit well with a thicker sole. Can't polish the toe due to the rubber cap. Came with a decent lace zipper that worked well and didn't break. Lasted 2+ years.
Then I tried finding another pair of the Air Powers. At the time, I couldn't, so I bought a different style of Haix that I thought would be similar. Fit was different and never felt right.
Throgood's were next on the list; I can't remember the model/style. Still have the lace zippers. Good tread on the soles, solid construction. They're good boots, but a little too tall for me.
And currently wearing Keen slip ons. Very comfortable, decent soles. Very easy on and off.
A couple different options I've had over the years. I do like the zipper over the laces instead of along the side. If that zipper breaks; they can always be tied; if the side zipper breaks you might have to throw out the boots. Most of them were steel toe or composite toe.