I'm not a Harley guy, but I rented a V rod for a few days while on a business trip in Florida a couple years ago. I liked some aspects of it, and didn't like some others. I liked the engine, it had decent torque and didn't feel like I was straddling a woodstove like on most other Harleys I've ridden. The seat was pretty comfortable, too.
The list of things I didn't like is a little longer. The trans felt clunky. The one I rode had forward controls and the riding position is weird and I never really got comfortable on it. I can ride sport bikes, dirt bikes and standard motorcycles seamlessly but I don't understand how someone could enjoy their feet out ahead like that. The handlebars had a lot of vibration and the mirrors weren't very useful because of that.
I wouldn't buy one. It doesn't fit my riding style. The Ducati Diavel would be tempting, but I'd rather have a KTM 1290 if I wanted a v-twin naked bike. For something a little more subdued, I'd look at a Triumph Street Triple R. Maybe an Aprilia Tuono V4 R.