User Panel
[#1]
Upper barrel looks used. Cracking, no major fissures but chunks may be breaking off and skinning jackets, minor coppering, perhaps a little neglect (spotty rusting). If the order is muzzle at top to bottom it's time for a new barrel. What's the throat look like?
Second barrel looks good and broken-in (the edge of the leade is smoothed, still has tool marks from chatter in the depth of the grooves). |
|
|
[#2]
OST so I can read everyone else's oppinion.
|
|
|
[#3]
Originally Posted By Sinister:
Upper barrel looks used. Cracking, no major fissures but chunks may be breaking off and skinning jackets, minor coppering, perhaps a little neglect (spotty rusting). If the order is muzzle at top to bottom it's time for a new barrel. What's the throat look like? Second barrel looks good and broken-in (the edge of the leade is smoothed, still has tool marks from chatter in the depth of the grooves). View Quote Sorry, I should have identified the area of the barrel. These images are all from the first 3-4" of the barrel after the throat. The rest of the barrel to the muzzle looks quite similar to the bottom reference photos. The top barrel has 250 rounds through it and is less than 1 year old. |
|
https://www.nraila.org/donate/
|
[Last Edit: SOMT]
[#4]
Looks like you need to use a good brush? Patches alone aren't sufficient in most cases. Looks like fouling and possibly that the barrel got extremely hot cracking the chrome lining??
|
|
"Whip your dick out and start helicoptering it.
Bitches love that." - XCR |
[#5]
It's a stainless barrel, no chrome lining.
|
|
|
[#6]
I will brush it and take after pictures to see if there's any change. But jaq is correct, no chrome.
|
|
https://www.nraila.org/donate/
|
[#7]
Please explain to us what we're looking at -- is it different barrels; is it the same barrel but different places down the bore?
|
|
|
[#8]
Originally Posted By Sinister: Please explain to us what we're looking at -- is it different barrels; is it the same barrel but different places down the bore? View Quote The bottom set of photos is from a different barrel that shoots better OP was using for comparison. |
|
|
[Last Edit: Kuraki]
[#9]
Originally Posted By Sinister:
Please explain to us what we're looking at -- is it different barrels; is it the same barrel but different places down the bore? View Quote The first 7 photos are of the same barrel, taken in multiple points radially, from 1/4" to 4" from the breech. The second 2 photos are from a different barrel simply as an example of what I think a premium barrel should look like. I've been cleaning the trouble barrel now, again, on SOMT's advice. The cleaning cycle I've done is: Soak the brush in solvent, make 6 strokes through the bore, switch to a wet patch and jag, then dry patches until they come out clean. I've done this 3 times now and it still takes multiple patches to come clean after every brushing but I wasn't sure if the brush might be depositing more than it's breaking free, so after the third go around I got the borecam out and looked, and I don't see much difference compared to the pictures in the OP. I'm going to do another 3 passes at brush/patch cleaning then I will take more images and post them. ETA: Part of the reason for this post is I have issues with the first barrel I would like to resolve, the other part is to get input on what we're actually seeing in the borecam, as it's really quite hard to know. At this point I see it as a great comparison tool, but whether those dark spots are pits, or copper, or xxx, I don't know. I was hoping someone would. |
|
https://www.nraila.org/donate/
|
[#10]
What chemicals and type of jag do you use to clean?
Mark |
|
Meet GA folks in GA Hometown
|
[#11]
|
|
https://www.nraila.org/donate/
|
[#13]
Send member JohnBurns an IM asking if he has any thoughts. He has a lot of experience with building excellent shooters and I believe he has used a bore scopde quite a bit.
|
|
|
[#14]
I am hardly an expert but it looks like you're early into stainless barrel alligator skinning. I used to read my friends benchrest magazines and they had articles on barrel wear and such. Stainless barrel throats will erode like yours into what looks like cracked mud puddle and moly steel will just wear away smooth.
I am not an expert at all so I suggest you keep digging. Just tossing out my remote two cents. |
|
|
[#15]
It looks like a terrible barrel shitting the bed early. Lots of throat fire cracking and alligator scaling.
|
|
|
[Last Edit: HighpowerRifleBrony]
[#16]
|
|
|
[#17]
Originally Posted By Kuraki:
Shooters Choice and a jag like this sized so that pushing a wet patch takes some effort: http://deweyrods.com/wp-content/uploads/Male-Jag12-400x400.jpg View Quote View All Quotes View All Quotes Originally Posted By Kuraki:
Originally Posted By BookHound:
What chemicals and type of jag do you use to clean? Mark Shooters Choice and a jag like this sized so that pushing a wet patch takes some effort: http://deweyrods.com/wp-content/uploads/Male-Jag12-400x400.jpg Use a product like KG1 that will turn slightly bluish green when there is copper. Ditch that jag and use a Parker Hale style that allows cleaning both directions. In fact, throw away all those jags with pointy tips. They are garbage. For copper use KG12. It will attack the copper but contains no ammonia which can damage your bore. Regarding lapping.... We stock blanks from some of the top tier shops. We see barrels from every MFG though. The lapping all of them do is "good enough" in most cases but could be improved. If that barrel of yours is still giving you problems, you could have it lapped. Mark |
|
Meet GA folks in GA Hometown
|
[#18]
Shooters Choice turns blue, it's the reason I use it. But I've ordered some KG12 and Parker style jags, so I will give that a try. For what it's worth, I don't have any other premium barrels, many with much higher round counts, that look like this inside. Stainless or carbon.
Ultimately I don't believe that my cleaning methods are what's caused this barrel to have this appearance, and there are not a lot of (easily found) borescope images on the net that I can find that look similar, which is why I posted here hoping someone knew what we were looking at. This barrel has never shot up to my expectations, initially I believed it was because all of my precision shooting experience has been with bolt actions, and an AR is simply harder to shoot to the same level as a bolt gun given how easy it is to manipulate, it takes some practice to manage trigger and grip control through the trigger break to keep from influencing the gun. Then I thought I just had not found the right load, since it's shown streaks of precision in some 3 round groups. It will shoot 1.5" 5 shot groups, which isn't terrible, just not what I was hoping for. It's also been a copper fouling pig since day one. Every trip to the range resulted in many many blue patches, regardless of how many or few rounds I shot, which lead me to believe that it was simply not lapped as well as it should have been, which led me to buying the borecam, and here we are. I think this will turn into a barrel lapping thread shortly, because at this point I don't feel like I have anything to lose. I'm already unhappy with the barrel. Going back to the manufacturer after 10 months and 250 rounds isn't something I really want to do. I've already replaced it with another precision barrel that meets my expectations for accuracy and have reinstalled this one in another upper with an ACOG, so being a 1.5" gun isn't an issue, and probably better than a good number. The worst that will happen is I make it worse, which I'm more than willing to do if I learn something in the process. So I've already spent some time on the various benchrest forums reading up on bore lapping. I've got everything I need to do it, lead, pot, 1 pc steel rod, silicon carbide lapping compound in 180, 240, and 320 grit. I think I will cast some laps and give it a shot. Now that I have the borecam I can at least inspect what changes are made. I have a feeling however that even if I'm able to restore the surface finish and appearance of the bore, it's likely not going to shoot any better, and I'm not sure how to get any measurements on bore/land diameter other than where I can reach with a small hole gage. So I will likely cast a number of laps, some to use as laps, others to use as slugs, in an attempt to feel any diameter inconsistencies. And I'll post pics as I go. |
|
https://www.nraila.org/donate/
|
[#19]
I agree I don't think this is a cleaning issue, but making certain the barrel is properly cleaned is the first thing we'd do in our shop.
Lapping is a bit of an art form. If you decide you want some help on it, you can send us the barrel and we will lap it free of charge, just pay return shipping. Mark Kuczka Accurate Ordnance |
|
Meet GA folks in GA Hometown
|
[#20]
That's a very generous offer, I appreciate it. I'm compelled to learn how to do these things myself. If you were closer to me and I could participate I would accept immediately.
|
|
https://www.nraila.org/donate/
|
[#21]
I cast 5 laps tonight. First thing I noticed when slugging was that the last 2" of the barrel (muzzle end) is significantly tighter than the rest of the barrel. I don't know if it's truly tapered, or if there's just a small dimensional change. I'm not sure if I should try to work this out or not, the 22LR guys seem to want a tight muzzle, but I was under the impression in centerfire cartridges it was more desirable to be relatively straight.
I made an initial pass with 220 grit, paying more attention to the scaled area. When it began to loosen up, I applied a bit more compound and worked it again until it loosened up a second time. Each of these were 5-6 strokes. I think that lap is shot now and will move on to the next. I cleaned the bore with patches and lots of solvent, and I noticed an immediate difference when I got to running dry patches through. Prior to this bit of lapping, even wet patches would stick in the bore, dry ones were impossible to run through slow and steady, you had to force them and they would hitch, then get them going again. But now, patches glide with consistency through from breech to muzzle. Then I stuck the bore cam in. I can notice some improvement in the surface finish, mostly in the grooves at this point, but some on the lands. I'm going to do 1 more pass with a new lap, then I will take some screen shots and test fire before going any further. |
|
https://www.nraila.org/donate/
|
[#23]
Originally Posted By Kuraki:
This barrel was cleaned prior to scoping, Shooters Choice patches until they went in white and came out white. http://i65.tinypic.com/wmj7yt.jpg http://i67.tinypic.com/x42m86.jpg http://i63.tinypic.com/imnndc.jpg http://i68.tinypic.com/2vi308x.jpg http://i64.tinypic.com/2qteuww.jpg http://i66.tinypic.com/aob2g1.jpg http://i65.tinypic.com/fmtbup.jpg For comparisons sake, here is a representative picture of another barrel of mine: http://i67.tinypic.com/2wdac7s.jpg Lead area http://i68.tinypic.com/n2o36c.jpg I'm just looking for opinions based purely on the images before I describe the problems I'm having with the top barrel, because I'm curious if I'm seeing them the same way others do, since this is my first use of a borescope. View Quote |
|
Children are the most complex creations made by unskilled labor.
NRA member and I VOTE |
[#24]
Jim did you walk away mid post?
|
|
https://www.nraila.org/donate/
|
[#25]
Looks better, great thread
|
|
|
[#26]
Now that I'm thinking about it, what bore scope is that and ball pal price ?
|
|
|
[#27]
Lyman borecam, 200 to 250.
|
|
https://www.nraila.org/donate/
|
[#29]
Very interesting thread. In for results.
|
|
The nice part about being a pessimist is that you are constantly being either proven right or pleasantly surprised.
George Will Eagle Scout Vet NRA Life Member |
[#31]
The inconsistent NPoA with the 10/22 is bugging me.
How is the AR supported? Bipod or rest? How does the reticle behave when you dryfire? |
|
|
[#33]
Originally Posted By HighpowerRifleBrony:
The inconsistent NPoA with the 10/22 is bugging me. How is the AR supported? Bipod or rest? How does the reticle behave when you dryfire? View Quote Haha, I have to hold left because I must have a bit of cant in the front sight and run out of windage. Makes it tough to estimate the hold off on the varying sized targets. Anyway, supported by the bull bag in the first picture. I've tried a rest and rear bag, bipod and rear bag, and now this bull bag. I'm pretty certain that my problem is a consistent follow through. Any AR seems to recoil differently each shot. I'm never able to get any consistency. When I shoot a bolt gun, it's easy for me to support it in a way that it always recoils the same, shot to shot. That is, rises off target slightly as it pushes back into my shoulder. The ARs, sometimes jump up, sometimes straight back, sometimes pull left or right. I think that's why I seem to have my best results from a bipod - a solid bipod keeps the rifle from rotating and allows it to recoil freely in a more consistent manner than any other bag/rest setup I've tried. |
|
https://www.nraila.org/donate/
|
[#34]
To cap off this wonderful waste of an afternoon I left that 10/22 in that stupid rack at the range At least it was still there when I went back.
|
|
https://www.nraila.org/donate/
|
[#35]
Originally Posted By desertmoon: OP...do not worry about your bench shooting. You are not alone. I am fighting to learn how to incorporate all of my gear into some kind of synthesis. I mean....I can shoot bolt guns from the bench no problem.....but get me behind an AR-10 and....LORD it takes some work. You don't know how many rounds it has taken me to get this far at 100 yards...with a damn rifle rest. http://www.ar15.com/media/viewFile.html?i=88718 100 yards winds gusting from 5 to 25 mph 178 Grain Hornady AMAX 40 grains of IMR 4064 Mega recivers Geissele SSA-E Trigger JP 22 inch barrel w/ matched bolt. Leupold Mk IV 6 X 20, 30mm tube View Quote |
|
Prostitutes and Politicians are a lot alike, except when a hooker screws you and takes your money you feel good about it .
|
[#36]
I would like someone else to shoot but I don't have anyone in my circle of friends that I trust to shoot groups better than I do. I'm not saying that because I'm some super benchrester, I'm not, but I live in a world of "pie plate at 100 kills deer"
I've pretty much given up on the idea of a .5 MOA AR. I've spent too much time and money chasing it at this point and have moved on. I can buy a list of parts for a bolt gun, thread and chamber myself, true the action myself, and within 3-4 development loads be in that .5 MOA range every time I've done it, so that's what I'll keep doing. However, if you're offering, I'll send you one of these uppers to test if you'd be willing to try. |
|
https://www.nraila.org/donate/
Instagram @kuraki556, making knives and stuff |
[#37]
Originally Posted By Kuraki: I would like someone else to shoot but I don't have anyone in my circle of friends that I trust to shoot groups better than I do. I'm not saying that because I'm some super benchrester, I'm not, but I live in a world of "pie plate at 100 kills deer" I've pretty much given up on the idea of a .5 MOA AR. I've spent too much time and money chasing it at this point and have moved on. I can buy a list of parts for a bolt gun, thread and chamber myself, true the action myself, and within 3-4 development loads be in that .5 MOA range every time I've done it, so that's what I'll keep doing. However, if you're offering, I'll send you one of these uppers to test if you'd be willing to try. View Quote |
|
Prostitutes and Politicians are a lot alike, except when a hooker screws you and takes your money you feel good about it .
|
[#38]
Originally Posted By HighpowerRifleBrony: The inconsistent NPoA with the 10/22 is bugging me. How is the AR supported? Bipod or rest? How does the reticle behave when you dryfire? View Quote |
|
Prostitutes and Politicians are a lot alike, except when a hooker screws you and takes your money you feel good about it .
|
[#39]
I'm not a gunsmith or a machinist...but the pics posted look exactly like machining chatter to me. It makes sense that lapping would remove it.
Is this button cut rifling? Cause then my idea at least has merit. If it is hammer forged rifling then I'm just dumb! |
|
This post is the official opinion of ar15.com
|
[#40]
http://www.midwayusa.com/product/152946/tubb-final-finish-tms-throat-maintenance-system-224-caliber
shoot 2 -3 every 300 rounds...... |
|
|
Sign up for the ARFCOM weekly newsletter and be entered to win a free ARFCOM membership. One new winner* is announced every week!
You will receive an email every Friday morning featuring the latest chatter from the hottest topics, breaking news surrounding legislation, as well as exclusive deals only available to ARFCOM email subscribers.
AR15.COM is the world's largest firearm community and is a gathering place for firearm enthusiasts of all types.
From hunters and military members, to competition shooters and general firearm enthusiasts, we welcome anyone who values and respects the way of the firearm.
Subscribe to our monthly Newsletter to receive firearm news, product discounts from your favorite Industry Partners, and more.
Copyright © 1996-2024 AR15.COM LLC. All Rights Reserved.
Any use of this content without express written consent is prohibited.
AR15.Com reserves the right to overwrite or replace any affiliate, commercial, or monetizable links, posted by users, with our own.