I have been carrying around a magnesium fire starter block (with the spark generator grafted to the metal) for a while thinking it would be a good tool.
Last weekend, I finally got around to playing around with the metal shaving part of the process and have some things to work out.
In no particular order:
- the metal had oxidized somewhat and needed scraping before I could get actual shavings off
- the metal shavings were _VERY_ light and were being blown away as fast as I could make them even in light wind
- the knife (just some crappy 2 inch lockback) edge held OK, but it seemed like the force required to shave curls of magnesium was excessive
- the angle required for getting shaves off was very picky, too shallow and the knife just knotched the metal and stuck, to deep and it shaved dust or did nothing
I did get a small pile, after working at a table inside onto some newspaper. The resulting shavings did burn nicely.
Previously I had only used the spark making portion of this thing (using the back of the same knife blade) with other tinder (dryer lint, mouse nest, dry leaves).
To get the fire started, I used a different kit that consists of cotton balls smeared with petroleum jelly wrapped in used candy wrappers (wax paper). One strike and I had a good flame going and was able to light my tinder, even though it was left outside in heavy dew all night.
So, unless I am doing something really wrong, I am going to get a regular striker for sparks and forget about the magnesium part of it. True, the metal won't be harmed by water, but I couldn't start a fire with it anyway so it's just extra weight right now. A spark striker rod alone will also be waterproof and I wouldn't be tempted to make shavings to get blown away, or perhaps cut myself, or whatever.
Does anybody actually USE those magnesium starters? I have seen one or two on keychains that had obviously been shaved, but never had anyone say they used it often.