I have many all different types.

My advice is think small.  As area lights they really suck.  The big ones will end up in a box somewhere while the small ones, you'll use every trip.  A total approach of personal lights, is a lot more efficient.  A small LED, you can sit right on the table when eating at night, a couple  of them even.  It gives those in your group a lot more independence while increasing night activity instead of huddling around a lantern.  Somebody going to take a pee stops becoming a family affair.  

Try it, buy a couple headlamps and inexpensive small hand sized lanterns and leave the old tried and true Coleman at home.  

As for which ones, I'm not your guy.  I'm still using my old bulet proof Rock Rivers.  Seeing how often we camp and man I camp more than any three people I know, these damn things last forever.  A 1,000 hours a couple hours a night is a hell of a lot of nights.  What I can tell you is behind they do use batteries which weigh, the major concern in longevity is breakage.  Features like rubber guards, twist battery doors, and drop resistance are good things.  

Another thing in this decision is standardizing batteries across as many of your lights as possible.  

Tj