User Panel
Posted: 9/22/2023 9:18:46 PM EDT
Was zeroed for 75 grain TAP (of the Frontier variety) but re-zeroed for the couple of boxes of 62 grain TSX (5.56 pressure) I bought at the peak of Covid. We’ve got roughly 4 weeks before firearm season opens here. Typical shot will be around 50 yards, but a 125-150 yard shot is possible at some of the property I sometimes get invited to hunt. I’ve shot the 75 grain TAP at pigs before, but I didn’t know how the minimum fragmentation velocity would fair from a 10.3” barrel. I know the TSX is supposed to expand down to 1,800 FPS.
|
|
|
77 grain TMK seems to be the answer
https://rokslide.com/forums/threads/223-for-bear-deer-elk-and-moose.130488/ |
|
|
Why would an ethical hunter pick the weakest rounds to bring down game animals?
|
|
|
Originally Posted By Mike_Golf: Why would an ethical hunter pick the weakest rounds to bring down game animals? View Quote There are plenty of other threads where 5.56 (of various barrel lengths to include SBR’s) has been used with extreme success on whitetail. I’ve taken quite a few with the 64 grain Winchester Power Point and some of the 55 grain soft point offerings. But those were all 16”-20” barrels. |
|
|
The FFBI uses 64gr Federal out of their shorty .223 AR’s. Might look into that, but I think the TSX would be ok too. I don’t remember where I saw this, but it was a few months back.
ETA: https://www.midwayusa.com/product/1001660015/?pid=520900 |
|
|
Originally Posted By Mike_Golf: Why would an ethical hunter pick the weakest rounds to bring down game animals? View Quote 223 kills deer just fine. They don't wear plates. You don't need magnums to kill deer. My kids have shot 4 deer now with 223 and all have gone down quickly. All but 1 bullet has completely exited. The one that didn't was just under the skin on the off side after hitting the on side shoulder bone and destroying both lungs and heart. OP - I have the kids use the Federal Fusion 62gr bonded. They work great. |
|
|
My 2 thoughts.
The Barnes is 5.56 pressure. Velocity is a plus in an SBR with possible 100+ yard shots. The Barnes is designed for expansion, not fragmentation. Another plus. |
|
What is written is my opinion, and my opinion only.
|
Originally Posted By Mike_Golf: Why would an ethical hunter pick the weakest rounds to bring down game animals? View Quote Is a bow ethical? Attached File This one went the same distance with a 77gr TMK from a 10.5" barrel. Attached File Both "didn't go 20." Both ended very quickly. Define ethical for us, please |
|
|
Originally Posted By Mike_Golf: Why would an ethical hunter pick the weakest rounds to bring down game animals? View Quote Don't make the mistake thinking only your way of hunting is ethical. You don't get a monopoly on that regardless of what you think. They are not bullet proof. One does not need a 300 wiz bang magnum travelling Mach 4, turning 1/4 of the target into a fine red mist, dislocating ones shoulder, being heard 3 counties over to shoot your average whitetail at 50 yds. |
|
C co 2/325th AIR 91-96 11B1P
Father of 6 un-socialized homeschoolers and grandfather to 2 awesome little boys. |
Originally Posted By garyd: Don't make the mistake thinking only your way of hunting is ethical. You don't get a monopoly on that regardless of what you think. They are not bullet proof. One does not need a 300 wiz bang magnum travelling Mach 4, turning 1/4 of the target into a fine red mist, dislocating ones shoulder, being heard 3 counties over to shoot your average whitetail at 50 yds. View Quote View All Quotes View All Quotes Originally Posted By garyd: Originally Posted By Mike_Golf: Why would an ethical hunter pick the weakest rounds to bring down game animals? Don't make the mistake thinking only your way of hunting is ethical. You don't get a monopoly on that regardless of what you think. They are not bullet proof. One does not need a 300 wiz bang magnum travelling Mach 4, turning 1/4 of the target into a fine red mist, dislocating ones shoulder, being heard 3 counties over to shoot your average whitetail at 50 yds. Now if a griz is hunting that whitetail, maybe. But even then, that removes some of the thrill. |
|
What is written is my opinion, and my opinion only.
|
A buddy of mine just shot a bear today with a .243. Should I tell him it was unethical?!
|
|
|
My son killed his first deer last year with a 10.5” AR using 62gr Barnes TTSX at around 50-60yds. She went about ten yards and crashed
|
|
|
Originally Posted By 11B3XCIB: My son killed his first deer last year with a 10.5” AR using 62gr Barnes TTSX at around 50-60yds. She went about ten yards and crashed View Quote Did he take a double lung shot? Now that I’ve just about settled on the 62 grain TSX, I hear different opinions on a double lung vs. high shoulder/neck. |
|
|
Originally Posted By canthony123: Did he take a double lung shot? Now that I’ve just about settled on the 62 grain TSX, I hear different opinions on a double lung vs. high shoulder/neck. View Quote View All Quotes View All Quotes Originally Posted By canthony123: Originally Posted By 11B3XCIB: My son killed his first deer last year with a 10.5” AR using 62gr Barnes TTSX at around 50-60yds. She went about ten yards and crashed Did he take a double lung shot? Now that I’ve just about settled on the 62 grain TSX, I hear different opinions on a double lung vs. high shoulder/neck. I'm interested in hearing too. Here is my experience on those two shot selections from someone who has killed deer with 5.56 pistols, arrows, slugs, and muzzleloaders. -double lung is a huge margin of error and will result in a dead deer, period. They will almost always run a ways but it won't be far. Blood trail is dependent on the size of the holes you put in them. -high shoulder/neck: much smaller margin for error, may drop them or anchor them right on the spot or may result in a runner if not precise. If it does not drop immediately it might be a rough tracking job. There are spots you can hit a deer and drop them right now and spots you can hit them and have them take off like a freight train that are only a few inches apart. I've done both, had success with both, but will only recommend a double lung. It's the closest thing to foolproof, is friendly to meat, and will result in a quick and clean harvest if placed +/-4 inches off ideal POA with zero fuss and a short track, likely within eyesight. As I said previously, last year two deer went down almost immediately with two different weapons, both considered "low powered." Deer are not hard to kill if you put a hole in a good spot and that's all there is to it. To be honest I find coyotes much harder to kill due to wariness, speed and a small vital zone, plus they'll run for broke with their entire guts laid out. "Tough" deer do happen but it is almost always due to shot placement. Just my.02, worth exactly what you've paid for it. |
|
|
60gr NBT worked for me from a stubby barrel
|
|
|
62 gr speer gold dot and federal fusion work just fine on NC deer.
|
|
|
Originally Posted By 11B3XCIB: Yep he popped both lungs. In the video (and in person) I thought he shot under her, but it was the dust cloud from the round coming out the other side and hitting the ground. She jumped straight up, bounded once or twice and crashed into the vegetation right off the cut she was in when shot. He took the closer of the two: https://i.imgur.com/1fJFDc4.jpg Shot juuuust going off. I hunted with a .30-30 lever gun as a kid and mine is using a suppressed KAC SBR with an ACOG. https://i.imgur.com/Wkg5FRd.jpg Good blood not that we needed it https://i.imgur.com/p0Y7kt1.jpg Walking around some briars to get to the doe https://i.imgur.com/atfkSAV.jpg Thanking the deer for her sacrifice so that we may sustain ourselves https://i.imgur.com/jFBNpq3.jpg View Quote Love it. You're doing it right with that boy. |
|
|
Originally Posted By 11B3XCIB: Yep he popped both lungs. In the video (and in person) I thought he shot under her, but it was the dust cloud from the round coming out the other side and hitting the ground. She jumped straight up, bounded once or twice and crashed into the vegetation right off the cut she was in when shot. He took the closer of the two: https://i.imgur.com/1fJFDc4.jpg Shot juuuust going off. I hunted with a .30-30 lever gun as a kid and mine is using a suppressed KAC SBR with an ACOG. https://i.imgur.com/Wkg5FRd.jpg Good blood not that we needed it https://i.imgur.com/p0Y7kt1.jpg Walking around some briars to get to the doe https://i.imgur.com/atfkSAV.jpg Thanking the deer for her sacrifice so that we may sustain ourselves https://i.imgur.com/jFBNpq3.jpg View Quote This is exactly the info I was looking for double lung it is! You’re raising him the same way I’m going to try to raise my son. Mine just turned 2, so he’s got a couple more years though lol. |
|
|
Mine is 8 and wants to go this year. Was going to give him the 16" Larue, but good to know the 11.5 will work if he needs to.
|
|
|
I really like and have great success with soft points. Federal Fusion has worked well for me.
|
|
|
|
Thank you for the information and the awesome photos, 11B3XCIB.
|
|
|
Sign up for the ARFCOM weekly newsletter and be entered to win a free ARFCOM membership. One new winner* is announced every week!
You will receive an email every Friday morning featuring the latest chatter from the hottest topics, breaking news surrounding legislation, as well as exclusive deals only available to ARFCOM email subscribers.
AR15.COM is the world's largest firearm community and is a gathering place for firearm enthusiasts of all types.
From hunters and military members, to competition shooters and general firearm enthusiasts, we welcome anyone who values and respects the way of the firearm.
Subscribe to our monthly Newsletter to receive firearm news, product discounts from your favorite Industry Partners, and more.
Copyright © 1996-2024 AR15.COM LLC. All Rights Reserved.
Any use of this content without express written consent is prohibited.
AR15.Com reserves the right to overwrite or replace any affiliate, commercial, or monetizable links, posted by users, with our own.