User Panel
Posted: 5/2/2024 6:29:52 PM EDT
[Last Edit: 1975]
What is the best pump style water filter? I’d like to be able to pump water out of Scepter water cans that have been in long term storage.
Examples… Attached File Attached File Attached File Attached File |
|
|
I've been thinking I should get one recently so just in for the answers.
I was looking at this one: Katadyn Seems to get good reviews across the internet. |
|
|
Wife and I use the Katadyn hiker pro when out backpacking. Time to buy a new filter for it though. Wonderful piece of gear!
|
|
Life is like a box of chocolates, you never know what you're gonna get!
|
I know you said pump style but after 15 years of pumping and hating every minute of it, I found the Platypus gravity system and will never go back. Fast and effortless Gravity filter
|
|
Life's tough...it's even tougher when you're stupid
|
I've been using an MSR Miniworks for over twenty years.
|
|
"What is socialism? The most difficult and tortuous way to progress from capitalism to capitalism." -Stated at an intel conference, East Berlin, Oct. 1988
"Every election is a sort of advance auction sale of stolen goods." -H.L. Mencken |
It's such a tough call between MSR and Katadyn because you look at the reviews and you read the high trouble rates for both. For MSR, it seems to be difficulty keeping the filter clean and low or no water flow. For Katadyn, it's lots of broken plastic parts issues. I have no doubt many are trouble free, but it seems like there are three bad reviews for every ten out there.
|
|
|
The water should be clean when you fill the water cans and you should add an appropriate amount of bleach to the water to kill anything before storing it long term. Then replace the water every 6 to 12 months, or hit it up again with a little more bleach and shake.
Then there should not be any need to run it through a filter or purifier before using. Just open the cap to let air in, close the cap, and shake to aerate the water and get rid of the flat taste. If the 47 pounds of a full 20L Scepter can is too heavy to lift then just tip it over to pour water out instead of pumping through a filter. In a wilderness or SHFT scenario I would filter clean water into the water can and not put dirty water in them. For this a gravity filter is going to be the least work. Get a 4 or 6 liter dirty water bag, fill it from your water source (stream, lake, beaver pond, cattle trough, etc.) and let gravity do the work for you instead of spending time and energy pumping. Get an extra filter to go with it. If the water is silty then filter through a piece of cloth or coffee filters first. Even if there are tannins in the water and it looks like weak tea it is still safe to drink after filtering. Then add some bleach to kill any viruses. Pool shock and solid bleach tablets have a long shelf life unlike liquid bleach which is only good for about 6 months. Between the pumps you posted I would get the First Need if I was looking at using in a stationary or car based scenario. Just because it also filters viruses while the MSR and FS-TEC do not. Viruses are not typically a major concern in the U.S. backcountry but for SHTF situation I would want it in an urban or refugee situation because hygiene is going to be a problem and cause issues beyond cryptosporidium and giardia. For backpacking I use a Sawyer Squeeze if it is just myself and a Platypus Gravity if there is 2 or more people with. I'm also a bit paranoid about my water in the backcountry after an issue several years ago and will add a Micropur water purification tablet or use a Steripen on questionable water sources. |
|
|
I don't have one yet but the
lifesaver wayfarer purifier is what I'm planning on buying down the line. https://iconlifesaver.com/product/lifesaver-wayfarer/ the only real downside to it is the filter has a supposed 5 year shelf life, I'm hoping they'll make a vaccum packed version like some of there other filters. I'm interested in it because it filters out the smaller dimension viruses that other purifiers don't filter out (0.015 microns). the only purifier that has the same micron size is the dubious looking survivorfilter.com/ It looks like a generic Chinese filter, and they don't even call it a purifier. Gravity filters/purifiers freak me out from a cross contamination standpoint, you have to get the dirty water into the upper bag without spilling it onto your clean water container. |
|
|
I have about a dozen mechanical filters, only a couple are rated for viruses, and anything rated for heavy metal contamination usually relies on the short-term use of activated carbon (which works, just have it stored/sealed in bulk or extra activated carbon filters stored properly).
Push filters are great until they get clogged up. Leverage filters usually have more leverage for easier pumping. For stored water in 5-gallon cans? I would just treat them with a MIOX or similar solution as the only threat is likely biological and not viral. It's a lot cheaper and easier to treat in bulk with chemicals than a mechanical means. ROCK6 |
|
"The tree of liberty must be refreshed from time to time with the blood of patriots and tyrants" - Thomas Jefferson
|
Gravity is your friend.
|
|
|
Originally Posted By ROCK6: I have about a dozen mechanical filters, only a couple are rated for viruses, and anything rated for heavy metal contamination usually relies on the short-term use of activated carbon (which works, just have it stored/sealed in bulk or extra activated carbon filters stored properly). Push filters are great until they get clogged up. Leverage filters usually have more leverage for easier pumping. For stored water in 5-gallon cans? I would just treat them with a MIOX or similar solution as the only threat is likely biological and not viral. It's a lot cheaper and easier to treat in bulk with chemicals than a mechanical means. ROCK6 View Quote I had treated them. Just wanted another safety net and to have in general. Thanks. Attached File |
|
|
Used a Katadyn Pocket for many years in exotic lands.
Great in jungle, not so good in freezing lands. Rongorongo |
|
That's what I love about Neanderthal girls man. I evolve, and they stay the same age...
|
Originally Posted By 1975: I had treated them. Just wanted another safety net and to have in general. Thanks. https://www.ar15.com/media/mediaFiles/259519/IMG_4293_jpeg-3205683.JPG View Quote Understood. I would just get a good hollow fiber gravit filter afrer chemical treatment... ROCK6 |
|
"The tree of liberty must be refreshed from time to time with the blood of patriots and tyrants" - Thomas Jefferson
|
If pump, Katadyn Combi (plastic body/ceramic/charcoal) or Pocket filter (aluminum body, ceramic).
If gravity, Sawyer. |
|
|
The only pump I ever recommend is the Katadyn pocket. It’s outrageously expensive but it doesn’t have any working parts that are plastic and comes with a warranty-a lifetime warranty at that.
Years ago when I was looking for a water filter I went to the local REI where they had a fake river for you to play with all of the filters they had on display. Every single one of the plastic pump filters was broken, and that was inside a 70 degree store and not a northern Michigan winter. A water filter is one of the most important pieces of gear you have, it needs to be reliable. |
|
Never make another person a priority when they merely see you as an option...
"Some People Are Like Slinkies. They're Not Really Good For Anything, But They Bring a Smile To Your Face When Pushed Down The Stairs." |
Suggest considering the water filter's mfr's level of support for a particular water filter. Some can be almost completely re-built using easily available and relatively inexpensive kits-- but one has to have the kits in the first place. Same thing with filters.
Plenty of "used" high-end water filters on ebay, some stupid cheap. Re-build, and filter away. Get spare re-build kits and filters. |
|
|
Originally Posted By TheOtherDave: The only pump I ever recommend is the Katadyn pocket. It’s outrageously expensive but it doesn’t have any working parts that are plastic and comes with a warranty-a lifetime warranty at that. Years ago when I was looking for a water filter I went to the local REI where they had a fake river for you to play with all of the filters they had on display. Every single one of the plastic pump filters was broken, and that was inside a 70 degree store and not a northern Michigan winter. A water filter is one of the most important pieces of gear you have, it needs to be reliable. View Quote I second the Katadyn Pocket. I got a deal on one when I was planning my first outdoor camping trip. I met up with a group, and went hiking out several miles to a place I was unfamiliar with. Most every one else had a MSR . We stopped at a pond that looked rather scummy. I pulled out my Katadyn. I got a couple snide comments about being a big spender, and their MSR was "just as good." A few minutes later, those with their MSR had the plastic handle pivots snap off, and they were SOL. Me being nice, and wanting to be friendly, offered my Katadyn to them to filter their water. That Katadyn filtered enough water for 6 people for the weekend. Made a few friends that weekend, and it shows you get what you pay for. |
|
|
I built my own gravity filter out of a couple USGI bladders, an MSR prefilter, a Sawyer Mini and a Pur (Yes Pur, before it was Katadyn) charcoal filter. It’s worked great for a few trips now and was cheaper than a mass produced option.
Also own a Katadyn pump type and an MSR Miniworks. Those both stay at home in favor of my home brew gravity filter. |
|
Liberal: Give up your guns to prevent murder.
Gun Owner: Cut off your penis to prevent rape. Liberal: I'm not going to rape anyone!!! Gun Owner: Thanks for proving my point. |
Originally Posted By ROCK6: Forgot about this. Well holy shit, my wife is a damn genius (or at least great at finding stuff). She found this 5-gallong USB-charged water pump: https://m.media-amazon.com/images/I/61BmFI1tqCL._AC_SX679_.jpg https://www.mountainbuzz.com/attachments/image-jpg.68444/ Can be press-fitted to a Scepter water jug (smaller opening) and pumps water incredibly well. Now, that means the water inside the water can has been filtered/treated, but it's pretty damn handy in the camp kitchen! ROCK6 View Quote This? JOYHILL 5 Gallon Water Bottle Dispenser, USB Charging Water Bottle Pump, Portable Water Dispenser Pump for Camping(Black) Amazon. 13.99. Damn. Already in my cart LOL. |
|
|
Yep, it works like a freaking champ!
|
|
"The tree of liberty must be refreshed from time to time with the blood of patriots and tyrants" - Thomas Jefferson
|
I've been using the Katadyn Vario for the last 12 years. It's worked perfectly for me. I carry it along with a Nalgene bottle because I can thread the filter directly to it and fill it. In all the time I've been using it, I haven't had any issues at all.
|
|
FJB.
|
There's a little electric pump that's meant to pump water out of the Sceptre cans. If you're not in an end of world scenario and electronics still work I'd think that you'd be happier with the little powered pump
|
|
*post contains personal opinion only and should not be considered information released in an official capacity*
0110001101101100011010010110001101101011 |
Katadyn Pocket for pump. MSR Autoflow XL for gravity. Sawyer squeeze for squeeze. Personally, I would dump water into a gravity filter bag like the MSR Autoflow XL in that situation or some sort of bucket filter for 5gal.
|
|
|
I have a few of the MSR mini works. The oldest is over 20 years old and still works well. Several years back I got a couple rebuild kits, but the model still exists as do spare parts. I don't use them much anymore though. If I am in a position where I need to filter water, I am usually solo and end up bringing/ using a sawyer mini. Cheap, disposable, works well for what it is and if it's cold out it can easily ride on my person in a pocket and spend the night in my sleeping bag as well.
|
|
Originally Posted By ar-jedi:
SO MUCH WIN IN ONE POST IT COULD CRASH ARFCOM !!! |
Sign up for the ARFCOM weekly newsletter and be entered to win a free ARFCOM membership. One new winner* is announced every week!
You will receive an email every Friday morning featuring the latest chatter from the hottest topics, breaking news surrounding legislation, as well as exclusive deals only available to ARFCOM email subscribers.
AR15.COM is the world's largest firearm community and is a gathering place for firearm enthusiasts of all types.
From hunters and military members, to competition shooters and general firearm enthusiasts, we welcome anyone who values and respects the way of the firearm.
Subscribe to our monthly Newsletter to receive firearm news, product discounts from your favorite Industry Partners, and more.
Copyright © 1996-2024 AR15.COM LLC. All Rights Reserved.
Any use of this content without express written consent is prohibited.
AR15.Com reserves the right to overwrite or replace any affiliate, commercial, or monetizable links, posted by users, with our own.