MM,
I own 3 .40 S&W handguns and two of them have seen extensive use. (Pins, IDPA, IPSC) I've never had a problem with factory ammo. I've bought surplus Fiocchi, Federal, Win. White box and others by the case. (almost all 165gr)
Never a problem.
However, I have had problems with "surplus" 9mm and .45 ammo. Bad OAL, bad primers, no charge etc. .40 is a great caliber IMO. Highly useful in the civilian as well as LEO and Military applications.
Make your own conclusions, I say stick with good ammo and you'll be fine in any caliber, but if you want a good carry caliber, .40 is a great choice. BTW, my carry gun is a .40 and the ammo is Cor-Bon 135 gr.
PS. I brought Billie to the vet today. She's having skin problems. (hot spots, excessive shedding) they gave her 3 shots and three different meds. Plus a heart worm test. Total damage $140.00!
Ouch. I asked them if she could work it off...retrieving things for them...they didn't see the humor.
I also was having problems with her going in the road and not comeing when called. Today she was introduced to Mr. Electric collar. Needless to say, the road is now a very BAD thing.
She also is delighted to come when called. IMO, it is a very humane way of teaching her she has to do what she's told (for her own good.)