What pisses me off is when those who don't own, or even HANDLED the item(s) in question PARROT information they've "heard" about the item(s) they don't like, and try and pass that info off as fact.
I have the SIR-C and RAS. ANY system that doesn't require front sight removal is for me, since I have permanently mounted muzzle brakes on my AR's.
I like the SIR immediately over the RAS due to it free floating the barrel. The M4 profile barrel isn't a heavy profile, so when the firing gets hot and heavy, the free floating of the SIR can't be a bad thing.
I have the RAS on my A2 upper, as the SIR won't fit this. This AR is an HBAR, so I feel it's better suited for the RAS.
The RAS is good and fully into the Army system, but the SIR to me is out front and I've heard NOTHING bad about it.
The downside - with either system, just be prepared to have your wallet SMOKED.
Chris