Some barrels shoot great with slugs, others won't hit the side of a barn. Many times it's the right combination of a barrel and the right slug. Couple of guys use M1-90 Benelli's and they're right on at 100 yds. using the regular Brenneke's. One took a big doe last year at 100 yds. and the Brenneke broke both shoulders and exited the far side. Another laid a big buck flat at 85 yds. Several years ago one took a big doe at 175 yds. using a Federal Premium Sabot Hydroshock, with a scope and the smoothbore barrel which isn't supposed to be a good shooter with sabots. His sure shoots them though.
I started out with an 870 in 20 ga. years ago and 75 was about max for it and Fosters. Went to an 1100 in a 12 with smooth deer barrel and could do about the same so far as decent accuracy. Got 1 of the 1st Hastings barrels, b4 there were any with scope mounts on the barrel. So, put scope on the receiver, 2 or 3 layers of duck tape on back end of barrel that fits back in reciever to take the wiggles out, and it would lay 3 regular Brekkekes touching at 100 yds, 3 BRI sabots in 2 in. circle at 100.
Sabots were predictable to 150yds., the Brennekes started to keyhole at 125 out of the rifled barrel. Federal sabots did about the same when they came out.
The Hornady H2K slugs, 300 or 350 gr. xtp in a sabot, will shoot within a 3 in. circle at 200 yds. Used them for last 3 years and took deer at 100, 125, 150, 175, 200 yds. 30 yds was farthest distance any of them traveled, most just walked around in a circle and fell over.
If you get the right combination, you can reach out and touch them.