User Panel
Posted: 8/22/2017 1:14:19 PM EDT
Sarco has these Virgin (never assembled) Browning A5 receivers for $39.95.
Browning A5 receivers - old virgin receivers So If I have an A5 clunker laying around. I could theoretically remove those parts and upon the virgin receiver, assemble into a 26" "Firearm" out of it (minus stock) ? Seems like Browning recoil operated guns are some of the few that work cut down without much tweaking. Need some inspiration - What does a 26" cut down browning "wippet" "firearm" gun look like - It can't have a stock - needs a grip or brace config. |
|
The way I understand the law, that would be correct. It's never been a firearm of any other type.
But let's not start writing letters. |
|
Seems like it could be done. I don't know how short the stock has to be before you can say its not designed to be fired from the shoulder.
Eta it must be allowed to have some stock or else mares legs would be SBRs. |
|
Quoted:
Seems like it could be done. I don't know how short the stock has to be before you can say its not designed to be fired from the shoulder. Eta it must be allowed to have some stock or else mares legs would be SBRs. View Quote Never have seen a PGO shotty Browning or Remington M11 and wanted inspiration, but the Bonnie and CLyde Whippit looks about right. |
|
Quoted:
Yes - No letters - Asking for permission is sometimes tantamount to asking for a reason not to approve. I didn't think of the Mare's Leg stock, I have a Ranch hand too, and never thought the stubby stock just past the grips on that is not considered a stock, not sure at what point it isn't but likely the less is better. Never have seen a PGO shotty Browning or Remington M11 and wanted inspiration, but the Bonnie and CLyde Whippit looks about right. View Quote |
|
My only concern would be that they are described simply as "stripped". My paranoia would force me to get something saying that they are virgin. Just me though, YMMV
|
|
Quoted:
Nor will you ever see one. There is a action spring and tube that extends into the buttstock, the whippit pictured above is about as short on the stock as possible. View Quote View All Quotes View All Quotes Quoted:
Quoted:
Yes - No letters - Asking for permission is sometimes tantamount to asking for a reason not to approve. I didn't think of the Mare's Leg stock, I have a Ranch hand too, and never thought the stubby stock just past the grips on that is not considered a stock, not sure at what point it isn't but likely the less is better. Never have seen a PGO shotty Browning or Remington M11 and wanted inspiration, but the Bonnie and CLyde Whippit looks about right. Eta the only thing I can think is to shorten the rat tail that goes on the bolt. This would allow you to possibly shorten the spring tube. Sorry don't know the proper terminology but you get the idea. Reliability may be affected. |
|
|
Quoted: My only concern would be that they are described simply as "stripped". My paranoia would force me to get something saying that they are virgin. Just me though, YMMV View Quote |
|
Quoted:
You would be better off making one out of an AK style. Something like this, but without the stock. http://i15.tinypic.com/4ictrvd.jpg View Quote 1. Can you get a virgin receiver or pgo version? 2. How much length does the receiver give you? |
|
Quoted:
You would be better off making one out of an AK style. Something like this, but without the stock. http://i15.tinypic.com/4ictrvd.jpg View Quote Seems like an easy fix for a Mfr - however many of the Saiga clones are imported and not sure if they can import PGO format. |
|
Quoted:
Nor will you ever see one. There is a action spring and tube that extends into the buttstock, the whippit pictured above is about as short on the stock as possible. View Quote I suspect what you have to leave on the gun to get it to work constitutes a butt stock so no short barrel without a stamp. |
|
No, you buy a complete Saiga.
Demill it properly Buy a new US made AK receiver Rebuild as "firearm" Profit On a 12ga you would have to cut the front of the receiver to fit, but I think it could be done. |
|
Quoted:
This. You either build a 18" Whippit or not. I suspect what you have to leave on the gun to get it to work constitutes a butt stock so no short barrel without a stamp. View Quote View All Quotes View All Quotes Quoted:
Quoted:
Nor will you ever see one. There is a action spring and tube that extends into the buttstock, the whippit pictured above is about as short on the stock as possible. I suspect what you have to leave on the gun to get it to work constitutes a butt stock so no short barrel without a stamp. |
|
I think I have to fo.
Attached File Attached File Attached File The whippet stock can't be any |
|
Quoted:
I think I have to fo. https://www.AR15.Com/media/mediaFiles/155324/f17480467b641331f7f007e94347b74b-288269.JPG https://www.AR15.Com/media/mediaFiles/155324/henry_mares_leg_f-288271.JPG https://www.AR15.Com/media/mediaFiles/155324/9db34a4aadb0c044845220ffbc5ecacb--barbering-short-shotgun-288272.JPG The whippet stock can't be any View Quote |
|
Quoted:
* * * https://www.AR15.Com/media/mediaFiles/155324/9db34a4aadb0c044845220ffbc5ecacb--barbering-short-shotgun-288272.JPG The whippet stock can't be any View Quote I've got a doner A5 in 20ga I'd like to do something similar with ... Just curious, though, why can't you fashion a "bird's head" pistol grip on that A5? What, if anything, extends into that portion of the stock? |
|
View Quote |
|
|
I've been thinking about numbers all day since this got posted. Using decent barrels and wood, a build could run close to or over $1000. Starting with a beater A5 in the $300 range, adding a $200 tax and allowing $100 to have the barrel professionally shortened it would be much cheaper to build on a complete gun. Only benefits to the virgin receiver route(and these aren't trivial by any means) are these might be available for those in states that don't allow NFA,no ATF tax and no NFA WAIT.
Me, I'm just trying to justify a receiver to have a spare on hand in case of catastrophic damage. Then again, receiver damage usually carries injury too, so there's that. Would be interesting to contact Browning with one and see if there's a record of whether it was ever actually built into a shotgun. |
|
Quoted:
What, if anything, extends into that portion of the stock? View Quote |
|
|
|
|
Quoted:
Can't have a pistol grip. Pistol grip = AOW View Quote View All Quotes View All Quotes |
|
The Mare's leg and the shock wave are not stocks, but pistol grips. Semantics.
|
|
How difficult/expensive would it be to finish one of the out if you had no parts to begin with?
If it wouldn't be too bad I may pick one up. |
|
Quoted:
How difficult/expensive would it be to finish one of the out if you had no parts to begin with? If it wouldn't be too bad I may pick one up. View Quote |
|
Quoted:
Cheapest would be to get a receiver and a complete A5 and just assemble the gun on the virgin receiver. Don't know if you could use savage or Remington clones. If you could you can find those pretty cheap. If you're real lucky you might find one that wasn't setup correctly and has a cracked receiver. Its not that uncommon for people to wreck these guns running them with high power rounds with the recoil system setup for light loads. When I had one of mine worked on the smith said to keep the high power rounds limited even if it was setup properly. View Quote The fact that it's completely legit to remove all markings but the serial number on a title-1 firearm mean that those importers marks can go away too..... Do it....and engrave it "Wippet Mk 1, Cal .70""..... |
|
Couple of thoughts. I built a "hybrid" stocked/whippet. Once I got the stamp back, I sent the barrel to Steve Rose and had it cut to 2 inches past the mag tube cap. Added a Nordic +1 to even it up and add a QD cup. As others have mentioned, the action spring and assembly don't allow for a pistol grip or even normal sized birds head grip. I personally don't know of a semi-auto shotgun that would work for that. Maybe something elongated, but I didnt go that route. Instead I cut the stock down by about 3.5-4 inches and mounted a grind to fit pachmayr pad. I was wanting the idea of a short handy semi auto that could be shouldered vs shot from the hip. Keep in mind, the A5 and its cousins use the brass friction rings to adjust to different loads. Shooting from the hip/wrist can be brutal if there is a mismatch between friction ring orientation and the load.
I had enough parts left over (barrel, newer trigger group, bolt, etc) that I decided to try the OP's idea, and did buy a Sarco receiver to start a second build. I can't speak to whether it is "virgin" for the stated purpose (I'm thinking mock Rhodesian for this one) but it was a good buy. Had to clean up some rust with a wire brush but it is in great shape otherwise. Be prepared though, Sarco is a grumpy pain in the ass to deal with. But as others have noted, getting the rest of the parts from a supplier would nickel and dime the project to a costly death. I'm gonna table the idea until I can find a cheapy gunshow donor. |
|
Quoted:
One of those receivers, and a 375.00 gunshow special beat to shit A5 or Remington, and you'd be good to go....can't really put a price on your time/work..... The fact that it's completely legit to remove all markings but the serial number on a title-1 firearm mean that those importers marks can go away too..... Do it....and engrave it "Wippet Mk 1, Cal .70""..... View Quote View All Quotes View All Quotes Quoted:
Quoted:
Cheapest would be to get a receiver and a complete A5 and just assemble the gun on the virgin receiver. Don't know if you could use savage or Remington clones. If you could you can find those pretty cheap. If you're real lucky you might find one that wasn't setup correctly and has a cracked receiver. Its not that uncommon for people to wreck these guns running them with high power rounds with the recoil system setup for light loads. When I had one of mine worked on the smith said to keep the high power rounds limited even if it was setup properly. The fact that it's completely legit to remove all markings but the serial number on a title-1 firearm mean that those importers marks can go away too..... Do it....and engrave it "Wippet Mk 1, Cal .70""..... If anyone knows if savage parts will fit I may end up going this route. |
|
Sign up for the ARFCOM weekly newsletter and be entered to win a free ARFCOM membership. One new winner* is announced every week!
You will receive an email every Friday morning featuring the latest chatter from the hottest topics, breaking news surrounding legislation, as well as exclusive deals only available to ARFCOM email subscribers.
AR15.COM is the world's largest firearm community and is a gathering place for firearm enthusiasts of all types.
From hunters and military members, to competition shooters and general firearm enthusiasts, we welcome anyone who values and respects the way of the firearm.
Subscribe to our monthly Newsletter to receive firearm news, product discounts from your favorite Industry Partners, and more.
Copyright © 1996-2024 AR15.COM LLC. All Rights Reserved.
Any use of this content without express written consent is prohibited.
AR15.Com reserves the right to overwrite or replace any affiliate, commercial, or monetizable links, posted by users, with our own.