I was so stoked about these when they first came out. I got two matching highly finished BPS's when I was a kid, a 12 and a 20. I love both guns, probably the finest field pump ever. I always pined for a HD/LE version of the BPS but it wasn't feasable unless Browning made one. They made a few BPS's with 18.5 inch tubes, synthetic stocks and 5 round capacity for a few LE contracts, but those guns are impossible to find and suck compared to the Hicap.
If you like the BPS, the hicap is a great choice for a defensive pump. Its a very robust and dependible weapon. The elimination of the ejection port reduces the amount of crap that can enter the receiver. The gun is also good for lefties since the shells eject from the bottom. The price is also excellent, especially when you consider the quality.
I paid 269.00 NIB for mine...
While its a great gun, it isn't perfect. There is zero aftermarket support as of now. I would love to see a pistolgrip and side saddle, but neither exist AFAIK...atleast they didn't a few months ago. The Ithaca side saddle may fit the BPS as they are very similar, but I am not certain. Ithaca stocks mak work too, but again I am unsure. The guns are quite similar...The bottom feed also makes it difficult to varify the guns condition. You can get the hang of it, but its not as easy as checking an 870. Cleaning is also a huge pain in the ass. The manual forbids disassembly past removing the barrel. Should you decide to go past this, better bring your A game. There are lots of little parts and its nowhere near as easy as stripping an 870/500. Better know what you are doing or you will be going to your smith with a bag full of parts. Other shotguns don't reccomend full stripping, but a HD gun needs to be cleaned regularly. Pumps are more forgiving of crud than other weapons, but a dirty pump can and will fail. The BPS is a very reliable weapon ,as reliable as any other pump, but it should be disassembled and cleaned with some regularity. You will get the hang of it after a while or with some further instruction, but if this is outside your comfort level most smiths will clean your gun for like 20.00.
Overall, the BPS is a great pump action shotgun. It has some quirks, but its as reliable/durable as other pumps and would make an excellent HD weapon. The quality is typical Browing-excellent and the price is competive, or less expensive than other HD pumps. 325.00 seems to be the going rate around here... If you want a solid, bone stock HD gun, this would be an excellent choice. There won't ever be as many parts for it as the 870, but someone will probably start making stocks and such for it.
Unfortunatly, I sold my BPS Hicap, 1200/1300's, 870's and 500/590's. Instead of owning a gaggle of pumps, I went with a few Benellis. I have a Benelli M2 Tactical, M3 Tactical, Supernova Tactical and Supernova H20 instead of the gaggle I had before. I love my Benelli's, but I still miss my 1300 Defender and BPS Hicap. I see myself buying another BPS Hicap as a truck gun or something if I can find one used.
If you like them, buy one...great guns.