Some of it does look like crap but from what I can see, it shoots good, even the bad looking stuff. The nice looking stuff is better looking then the xm193.
You are also talking about 2 different types of ammo. the Adcom is 855spec with a 62 grain bullet with penetrator. The Guat is 193 spec ammo with a 55 grain bullet. Some people want some of the 55 grain ammo as it might get harder to find in the future. The 855 will remain in production for the forseeable future.
For some with a 1/12 upper, 62 just won't cut it. It just won't stabilize properly and will keyhole.
Don't discount the Guat, my last lot was absolutely perfect. Looked like it came off the line yeaterday. I've got some cruddy lookin stuff in another batch but the funny thing is, it's more a surface thing. It's not really corrosion how we tend to think of it, but more a surface reaction to SOMETHING.
I consider it an OK deal, not great, but not horrible either. AIM has been very very good about standing behind their products. I don't think you will find anyone who can say they were treated poorly by them. So far it has shot just fine, and reminds me of the SA5.56 that was around years ago. The SA was in better battle packs and such tho.