Problem is there is a GIGANTIC choice of options for railed handgaurds like these. A lot of them do the same things as the others, yet some do a little more. I think the general consensus is that there reallyisnt anything BAD about this system in and of itself, but so many others do more things or better things. So while there may not be an immediate and compelling reason not to get it, theres not really any compelling reasons to get it either. Especially considering all the many other options. If you can agree so far, you now why you are getting the replies you see here suggesting other options.