IMO your letter, as written, will not accomplish anything. You have included a lot of unneeded information. The person reading your letter will see phrases like "version of the M4 carbine currently being used by our forces in Iraq and Afghanistan" and instantly go into CYA mode and give you a lecture about making illegal machine guns etc. You will not get a useful response.
You are also, in effect, asking for an opinion from a "cop". Frankly, I don't care what "opinions" a cop has. I care about the law. That would be my question......what is the law?
Quick and dirty. This would be the crux of my letter..............
Dear Sir,
I presently own a legally purchased AR-15 type receiver manufactured by Bushmaster Firearms. I am aware of the requirement, found in 18 USC Sec. 922(k), that prohibits the manufacturer's serial number from being removed, obliterated, or altered.
Assuming that the serial number and manufacturer information as applied by the manufacturer reamains intact, is there any law that prohibits me from adding (engraving) additional text and/or removing text (other than the serial number) or artwork (company logo)?
Thank you for your time. I look forward to your prompt response.
Sincerely,
hardcorps1775
|
I would probably polish this up a bit but that would be my letter. Ask a question about the LAW. The ATF doesn't need to know about what I'm going to write or what kind of upper I'm going to pin on the receiver.
With all that said.......the answer to your question is there is no law prohibiting what you want to do. If I were to do what you described, I would do it without feeling the need to get the ATF's "permission". In fact, I have done things similar on receivers. Just leave the serial number alone and you are good to go.
You asked for opinions.........