First, send those four rifles to me so that they can be properly disposed of. No, just joking. Seriously, read on:
[b]So from what I have read above 3 of these rifles are going to blow up?[/b]
No, they are all safe.
[b]My bad, these are .223 gauges and all but one of these rifles are chambered in 5.56.
That might be the problem then.[/b]
No, that is not the problem, either.
[b]Here MIGHT be your problem. There are "223" gauges, and then there are "M16/AR15" gauges. This boils down to the fact most AR-15's are 5.56 mm spec chambers, which is slightly larger than a .223 chamber.[/b]
BINGO!!! We almost have a winner!!! The M16/AR15 has a larger chamber that enables better feeding and extraction with its self loading feature. You cannot check headspace on an M16/AR15 with .223 gauges. Well, you can, but you get erronious results.
It does not matter if it is a .223 chamber or 5.56 chamber, .223 gauges do not work. Both chambers in a M16/AR15 are larger than what is found in a .223 bolt gun, it is the leade, or freebore, that is different.
[b]Ok Guys I have remove the extractors and this is what I came up with. Using .223 headspace gauges Go/No Go/Field.
Colt-closed on all gauges
OLY-closed on Go and No Go
RRA-closed on all gauges
Bushy-closed on Go and No Go
So WTH are these guns going to blow up if we shoot them? All guns have less then 600 rounds through them.[/b]
All of these rifles are safe to shoot. The best indication of unsafe headspace is from examining the brass, look for shiny rings around the circumference just above the web of the case. That is where brass will stretch from excessive headspace.
Sell your .223 guages to someone, if you can find them, that shoots a .223 bolt action varmint or target rig. Your gauges are useless, no, worse, for checking AR15's.
Forget all this fiasco, and just go shooting.