User Panel
Posted: 2/21/2006 5:18:47 PM EDT
Mine is Full Metal Jacket...but I also like Saving Private Ryan
|
|
One of my favorite movies of all time, but does it really fit into the genre of War Movies? |
|
|
Too many.
Band of Brothers is possibly one of the most important things ever done however. |
|
|
I always feel torn when this topic comes up, since it's not really a movie. But it basically is the best thing ever put on film. |
|
|
WE WERE SOLDIERS
Good morning Sgt. Major " Don't tell me what kind of GD day it is. |
|
"Where eagles dare" Hell, I dunno, I love it. Try reading the book.....whew.....
|
|
Gunga Din,,,,no wait,,Lost Patrol,,I mean Sand Pebbles,,The Great Santini,,,oh hell
KELLY's HEROS,,just try counting the actors,,,, |
|
+1 Thats gotta be the best part of the whole movie. Gotta say Black Hawk Down is my fav. Saving Rrivate Ryan is a good one to |
|
|
Well - for some reason - We Were Soilders really effected me. I dont know why. But I really get all choked up in the end.
If you have the DVD, watch the deleted scenes. There is one where some of the troops are trap shooting and recounting a story about Sam Elliots Character, Sgt. Maj. Basil Plumley. Two words about this man. BAD ASS. Now - if I actually think back and think about it, I would have to say Full Metal Jacket - mainly for R. Lee Ermey. (He signed my DVD!!) From there I have to say Saving Pvt Ryan and Black Hawk Down. As for an artsy film - Apocalypse now. I also LOVE Band of Brothers. Its not a movie - its more of an odyssy. I still need it on DVD - but its truely great. |
|
Attack force Z
BHD We were soldiers Private Ryan Uncomon Valor Bat21 |
|
My top 5:
Saving Private Ryan Band of Brothers Patton Twelve O' Clock High A Bridge Too Far |
|
Damn.....why aren't there more GREAT war films? Some of my favorites.
Saving Private Ryan is my favorite. ========================= First war film that really left me in shock after seeing it....which is how it should be out of total respect to those who paid with their blood. Set the new standard for war films. Band Of Brothers ============ Best mini-series ever. Great combat and an incredible DVD set. I'll somewhat forgive them for fucking up Bastogne ....which is still a GREAT story that needs to be told on film in whole. Platoon ====== Vietnam was a cluster fuck. One of the few good films by Oliver Stone. Enemy At The Gates =============== It's a very good film....but not great. Nice to get a peek into the Russian theatre during WW2. Tae Guk GI ========= The "Saving Private Ryan" of the Korean War. Absolutely brutal combat that pulls no punches. Some scenes are far fetched...but still very impressive for a foreign flick. A MUST see. |
|
Dear America: Letter Home From Vietnam
The Andersoon Platoon No other war movie can compare to these two. The runners up, and in no particular order......... We Were Soldiers Porkchop Hill Air America(the secret war in SE Asia) Apocalypse Now: Redux Purple Hearts(cheesy love story, good action, and The Gunny) SVP The This Red Line(for nothing more than the cinematography) A Bright Shining Lie A Midnight Clear Catch 22 Platoon Born On The Forth of July Kelly's Heroes Behind Enemy Lines M*A*S*H Gods And Generals The Patriot Blackhawk Down Battle of The Bulge A Bridge Too Far Bataan Anzio Operation Burma(or is it Objective Burma?) Operation Dumbo Drop(the opening seen with the Army helo pilots fucking with Liotta is classic) and for god sakes, Dr Strangelove: Or How I learned To Stop Worrying, And Love The Bomb |
|
Anything directed by sam fuller, "The big red one", but also "the steel helmet" "fix bayonets" ect. He was a rifleman in WWII and fought with the big red one.
|
|
I would have to pick either Band of Brothers or We Were Soldiers.
Honorable mention in no particular order to: Patton Saving Private Ryan Full Metal Jacket The Winter War (Finns vs Soviets in 1939) Apocolypse Now Heartbreak Ridge Kellys Heros Gods and Generals Red Dawn Battle of the Bulge The Patriot -K |
|
and......" Any of you pussies calls me grandpa, and I'll kill ya" I liked this movie as well.........but "Ryan" is a great one also |
|
|
Band of Brothers
Black Hawk Down Saving Private Ryan We were Soldiers |
|
Some of those mentioned I haven't seen. This past Sunday night I watched Platoon again after a few years, and I recently bought a copy of The Great Escape, but haven't watched it yet. I don't remember the last time I saw it. I'd love to have Band of Brothers, and if it counts as a single movie for this thread, I'd say this is my favorite. I haven't seen it in a few years, and look forward to seeing it again. The book is good too. If you like the Boot Camp stuff in Full Metal Jacket, check out Jack Webb's 1957 film The DI. I plan to get a copy of Saving Private Ryan. I love WWII movies. As a grade school boy, WWII was the war I fought with friends, and I saw a lot of those movies as a kid. I plan to review all of them eventually. For Vietnam movies, I'm not a fan of Apocalypse Now, partly because I think it gets stupid at the end, and I hate Marlon Brando's performance in it. I much prefer Platoon. I have a lot of catching up to do on war movies, though.
GL |
|
Platoon
Saving Private Ryan Blackhawk Down Band of Brothers Siege at Firebase Gloria |
|
But that's in the Movie forum...nobody actually goes there. Arty8, have you seen the Reconstruction Version of The Big Red One? Very good. I agree with Wobblin-Goblin. BHD SPR BOB except that I would substitute We Were Soldiers for BOB Band of Brothers is in a class all it's own. |
|
|
Sign up for the ARFCOM weekly newsletter and be entered to win a free ARFCOM membership. One new winner* is announced every week!
You will receive an email every Friday morning featuring the latest chatter from the hottest topics, breaking news surrounding legislation, as well as exclusive deals only available to ARFCOM email subscribers.
AR15.COM is the world's largest firearm community and is a gathering place for firearm enthusiasts of all types.
From hunters and military members, to competition shooters and general firearm enthusiasts, we welcome anyone who values and respects the way of the firearm.
Subscribe to our monthly Newsletter to receive firearm news, product discounts from your favorite Industry Partners, and more.
Copyright © 1996-2024 AR15.COM LLC. All Rights Reserved.
Any use of this content without express written consent is prohibited.
AR15.Com reserves the right to overwrite or replace any affiliate, commercial, or monetizable links, posted by users, with our own.