Quoted: So for you roadies, how are those minimalist seats? They look cool, but uncomfortable. How do they compare on long rides? Certain butt shapes only? Padded shorts only? I have a Sella Italia, but it has real padding. Took me so long to find a seat that feels good that I am scared to try anything else. obviously lighter, but ?? Trade offs?
|
RE: So for you roadies, how are those minimalist seats?Super light, ergonomic and efficient
RE: They look cool, but uncomfortable.Well proper seat height and angle is critical in order to achieve optimal comfort, aerodynamic position, and power efficiency.
RE: How do they compare on long rides? This depends on how fast the long ride is. The more force being applied by the rider to the cranks the more comfy minimalist seats are. If you’re just a recreational rider minimalist seats are probably not for you.
RE: Padded shorts only?true
RE: I have a Sella Italia, but it has real padding.Yeah I have a selle Italia flight and san marco and have tried several other brands. I personally prefer the models with carbon suspension systems (as opposed to massive padding) and center hole pressure relief. This combination produces the best combination of optimal comfort and power efficiency.
RE: obviously lighter, but ?? Trade offs?Personally I think that the saddle is a bad place to shave grams of weight from your bike. I would sacrifice weight for ergonomics any day. I choose my saddles based on maximum power output and comfort achieved in the most aerodynamic position.