User Panel
Posted: 9/5/2005 6:52:06 PM EDT
Looking for a 2nd vehicle for 2 people hunting, camping, fishing, etc. We do get off road on these trips, but not as a 4WD sport. Often it's a 6-7 hour drive to the hunting destinations.
My son saw a 72 Scout, but the guy wants $3K and I want something with easy parts availability, both body & mechanical. A relative has a Wrangler with coil springs in front, but not long ago, I saw another with leaf (albeit flimsy-looking) springs. When did they change, and in which direction? Frankly the sway is a bit too much in the corners for me, I keep thinking rollover (unlike the Bronco I had with coils in front). And the zipper windows are a major PITA around the city, not to mention highway noise. What are the best Jeep models, years, engines, and transmissions since '90 or so? I'm interested in plenty of room in the back and so naturally a Cherokee or Wagoneer comes to mind, but I'm limiting myself to around $5K cash. A Liberty doesn't sound so good, and I'd prefer manual hubs, real doors & top, good gross weight, economy, and simplicity (not a bunch of electric crap to fail). Towing isn't a major interest, though it would be nice to pull my friend's bass boat over the Coast Range. Obviously I will have to compromise, but the confusing part is that for every "thumbs up", there's a "what a piece of crap I bought!" So far I haven't been able to categorize all these reports to know what to look for, but I've seen some that are definitely overpriced. |
|
IIRC, in 91, Jeep introduced the 4.0L 6 cylinder. I have been very happy with mine and have heard generally good things on the net about that engine. The manual 5 spd has been good as well. My Wrangler was a daily driver from 91-99 and for fun since then. I have about 105K on it. |
|
Scout parts will be hard to find. A 75'-86 Chevy blazer, parts are easy to find and solid front axle. I love my 85'.
|
|
Someone should've watched Trucks! this weekend. The subject was best bang for the buck 4x4, and they said it was the old-school full-size Jeeps. www.ifsja.org/index.shtml |
|
|
Look for a 95 or so cherokee. 4,0 6 and around 100K, excellent engines good for 200K if taken care of, cheap parts available everywhere. Decent milage for a 4by, have the tranny checked well and serviced. Change the diff fluids and transfer case fluids, put in synthetic. Jeep wrangler,c-j or TJ is just to darn small for towing and packing stuff. BTW the leafs came first then coils in or around 97 or 98.
|
|
There is only 1 part not available new anymore for 72-80 Scouts, and that is the oil pump. But there are lots of rebuild kits for them out there. Everything else is readily available, with most parts being available at most large chain parts stores. Some parts(mostly body stuff) has to be ordered from one of the MANY online Scout vendors. |
|
|
85 four runner with a solid front axle. would fit the bill nicely I would stay away from anything with IFS. I am a Jeep person but Toyota has some strong offerings and the later 80's models can be easily changed to solid front axle setups. FJ60 land cruisers are freaking awesome but hard to come by. Blazers and Broncos have been done to death. this is a good thing. Lots of spare parts. It just seems hard to find a reasonably priced base vehicle. My personal reccomendation is a early to mid 90's cherokee 4x4 with the 4.0 and a 5sp if you can find one. Upgrade the dana35 rear with better axle shafts and a locker, add a lift kit and 32x11.50's and you should come out under $5k. It might not be the prettiest thing on four wheels but it will get you there. There are a lot of aftermarket companys offering XJ parts nowadays, so anything that you could imagine is availble. |
|
|
Good stuff, keep it coming. The I-6 Bronco was a good one until some shot-up gang banger plowed into it out front; though the oil pressure was getting low at 180K it had plenty of power. 16-18 mpg doesn't sound so hot right now, but I'm probably gonna have to live with that until more $ come in.
|
|
The 4.0 was first available in the Cherokee in 87, and 87-91 had the RENIX ignition after that they went to the Mopar system. Get a Cherokee with the 4.0L I-6 and the AW4 automatic.... the combination is unbeatable. From 87-89 they had the Dana 44 optional with the towing package, and it is definitly worth the effort to find them if you plane for an serious off-road use. You get a strong engine that still gets decent mileage, a solid front and rear axle, easy upgrades, and parts that are in stock at every parts store nationwide. |
|
|
Jeep wranglers 97 and below will have leaf springs, 98 and up will have coil springs. There is no problem with the leaf springs, although you can get more flex out of coils. If it seems to sway to much someone most likely took off the sway bar, not good if your driving on road.
|
|
Actually YJ Wranglers from 87-95 are leaf sprung and there was no Wrangler in 1996. In 1997 the Wrangler introduced the Quadra-Coil Suspension and round headlights and was dubbed the TJ. CJ 73-86 Round headlights, available V8's, narrower axles and leaf spring suspension YJ 87-95 Square headlights, leaf spring suspension. 1987-1990 the 4.2L I-6 was the 6 cylinder offering from Jeep. Avoid the 87-88 Peugot 5 speed manual transmisson which came with the 4.2L I-6. TJ 1997 thru present. 4.0L I-6 with good 5 speed manual transmissions. 2001 and later TJ's with man-trans included the NV3550 tranny which is the best manual tranny offered by Jeep since the CJ's with a T5 manual transmisson. Four coil springs suspension allows much more flex and vastly improved road manners. HS1 |
|
|
I had a 90 cherokee with the 4.0. I bought it for about $2800 with 135k and sold it with 200k for about the same. The guy still uses it 6 years later as his winter car. If cared for, they will last with one of the best engines and drive trains around.
|
|
I had a 75 or 76 with one of those weird ass 4 cylinders. I swapped it out for a 304. It was one of the neatest 4wd I ever owened. Unfortunetly the body rotted away. However that didnt happen without a fight. I must have put 150lbs of welding rod alone in that thing. In the catagory of I couyld kick myself in the ass was a 1960 2 seat scout with removable top.The gear ratio was 5.38's or something insane like that. The only thing that gave me troble was the distibutor. Yoiu could drive it through a pond but a slow rain would condensate in the cap. The 4 and 8 used the same distributor, diffrent cap. The 4 was just half an 8. |
|
|
If you're going to be driving 6 hours to hunt, you're going to want truck that will let you go the speed limit without getting beat to death, that seals out wind, has A/C, and won't break weird - hard to find parts just because it's old. I'd look for a Bronco from 1987 (or the first year they went to fuel injection) to the last year of production. I had a 1989 model that I traded in on a car. They didn't give much and I wish I had kept it now. It's new enough to be reliable, but not so new that it's too expensive. There are plenty of aftermarket parts and you're likely to find them in salvage yards.
Just my two cents. R. ETA - I've got an older 4X4 (1975 FJ-40) and I have to tow it to the deer lease. The older vehicles are really better as dedicated off-road. |
|
Jeep still sold the YJ in 1996 and you can still find YJ's that have a 1996 build date. I would get an older solid axle Toy, or an XJ! TJ Owner here... |
|
|
You don't want a Scout then. Going downhill with a tailwind on the freeway I am lucky to get 12 mpg |
|
|
Correct. Mid 96 was the intro year for the 97 model year TJ....which is a full coil suspension with solid front and rear axel as normal. I just purchased a new Tj, myself and like it but nothing beats a good YJ ( post 92 for the full cage and the 4.0 litre fuel injection ) for stripping down and using for a hunting vehicle. The TJ has ZERO room for interior mods that are worth a shit...the YJ on the other hand is great for mods. Rip out the factroy center console and put a mini van center consol in and you can carry a 1911, mags, CDs, full size sodas, etc. The TJ interior, while nice and comfy, is TOTALLY GAY. I hate my TJ for that reason alone. I don't have anywhere to put anything and I can't change out the center console for anything that has any more storage room that my current one. Wranglers are one of the last vehicles you can work on and modify to your most extreme or modest desires. |
||
|
Yeah, I was guessin a bit as I am a FJ-40 fan myself. My sis has had 2 cherokees and even under her awful driving they lasted great. Everyone I know who has had one was pleased at the reliability. |
||
|
I've been driving a 95 Toyota 4Runner 4wd for the past four years. It had 130K when I got it. It is V6 and auto trans.
It has been trouble free. Period. (Well mechanically, the clear coat on the paint is dying.) In June, with 175K miles on it, we drove from SA to boston, got a big Uhaul, loaded up our daughters stuff. We drove to upstate new york, to Nebraska, to santa fe, to the Grand Canyon, and on to San Diego. Then the wife and I returned to San Antonio. The trip was 7K miles. What other vehicle, with 175K miles could I trust for such a trip? Better, it dirves really well and it is tight and rattle free...except for the aftermarket sunroof. I love my Runner. |
|
Land Cruiser. Look for a good late model FJ60 or maybe even a decent used FJ80.
I have an FJ40 (1981) and a 79 Jeep CJ5. The Cruiser is a MUCH better built, heavier class vehicle. The parts are a little more expensive but they last a lot longer. |
|
Nothing wrong with IFS in your case...
Outside of hard core off roaders, there is no legitimate reason to fear it. The main reason "truck" guys don't like them is that they are impossible to lift by the average joe, and expensive to lift by the pros. With a solid axle up front, any bubba can head for the stars until his U-Joints start to scream for mercy. The reality is that you shouldn't lift a vechile unless you absolutely require the extra tire/ground clearance and extra articulation possible from it. Engineers spent lots of modeling time squaring away the suspension geometry, gear rations, and brake strength so you shouldn't mess with it unless you are prepared to deal with possible problems you will create. Do not buy an old 4wd of any type unless you want to (and will enjoy) fixing up and constantly maintaing it... The best plan would be to find a good condition high mileage soccer mom SUV that the owner things is worthless because of the mileage. The only thing you have to look for here is that the thing was in 4wd occasionally to bathe the gears/chain in lube. The best choice would be a Gen III (perferably 99-03) 4Runner as in that case you will get 20+ on the highway too... Old jeeps have a huge cool factor, but may not be worth the hassle. After all, how many old jeep owners do you hear mention "Reliable as hell, don't really have to do anything to it..." |
|
I have a 1998 Izuzu Trooper...auto with th 3.5l.
We're almost at 170k miles, and besides 1 EGR valve, nothing has broken. We've done the usually stuff like batteries, tires, brakes, etc. Still get 17mpg on the hiway with the A/C on. Back seat folds down giving you a lot of room. Twice yearly trips to Durango or Florida. Driving it to Chicago later this month. Come down to Octoberblast in Oct. at Tiger Valley. I'll be there camping with my truck. Does use some oil, about a quart a month, but has done that since new. If they still made them, I'd buy a new one tomorrow. |
|
|
|
|
I'd get a Wrangler. You should be able to find a pretty good condition mid 90s model, or a high mileage 97 or 98...
|
|
I've got a '77 Suburban that will be for sale soon, set up for hunting/offroad.
Camo paint, 4x4, Warn hubs, custom fab front bumper w/hellas, roof rack, 4-inch lift, 33's, crate 350 [2 years old, runs great], has hitch+brake controller [used it to tow his 26 ft Airstream] ac, etc...I believe the drivetrain is new. The truck is street legal in TX, passes inspection etc. Belonged to my brother who passed away a few months ago, I'll be selling it as soon as his estate is settled since I don't need it...he put WAY more money into it than I could ever get back out, as he intended to keep it...but I'll probably be asking $3500 obo. I have all the receipts for the work done. Maybe too big for what your wanting, but I figured I'd throw it out anyway. |
|
Toyota
I drive a 4 door Tacoma now, ZERO problems in 80K Before this one I had an '86 4x4 pickup. I had 180K on that one when I gave it to my son. It had over 220K when he sold it before going into the Air Force. Very few stock 4x4s of any type will go where a stock Toyota 4x4 will go. |
|
Not to nit pick, but Blazers only up to 1987 had leaf springs all around, 1988 and up Blazers have IFS. Also I think Blazers before 1987 were carburated not FI. Over all Blazers are a pretty good choice. But I'm still partial to full size Jeeps. |
|
|
I dunno, mine (pictured) is a 1990 and has leafs all the way around. You can see the front leafs in the pic. No coils, just leafs and shocks. It is a 1990, for sure, and all stock.
ETA: Mine is also fuel injected. Better for steep inclines IMO, plus electronic fuel pumps can be very easily replaced as opposed to mechanical units on the cam lobe.
|
||
|
Are you sure your 1990 has front leaf springs? I don't think it does. It doesn't have coil springs either, it has tortion bars. 1987 was the last year for all leaf spring sold axle suspensions, 1988 and up have IFS in the front. Yours would definetely have F.I. and that is a good thing. Check out this list of leaf srpings for Chevy's, it only goes up to 1987. www.suspensionconnection.com/cgi-bin/suscon/scan/fi=products/st=db/co=1/sf=category/se=Leaf%20Springs/op=eq/nu=0/sf=veh_make/se=Chevy%20%3A%3A%20GMC/op=eq/nu=0/sf=model/se=Front/op=eq/nu=0/ml=25/tf=category/to=x/tf=veh_make/to=x/tf=model/to=x/tf=description/to=r.html |
|||
|
**Thread hijacked all to hell**
89Grand, Do torsion bars require leaf springs to function? I ask because I know that my Blazer has leafs in the front and rear. Although you may be right in that they work with torsion independently rather than a straight axle design. I'll take some pics tonight and post them. This is somewhat on topic so it'll probably fly. Suspension is an important consideration in selecting a 4x4.
|
||||
|
Sign up for the ARFCOM weekly newsletter and be entered to win a free ARFCOM membership. One new winner* is announced every week!
You will receive an email every Friday morning featuring the latest chatter from the hottest topics, breaking news surrounding legislation, as well as exclusive deals only available to ARFCOM email subscribers.
AR15.COM is the world's largest firearm community and is a gathering place for firearm enthusiasts of all types.
From hunters and military members, to competition shooters and general firearm enthusiasts, we welcome anyone who values and respects the way of the firearm.
Subscribe to our monthly Newsletter to receive firearm news, product discounts from your favorite Industry Partners, and more.
Copyright © 1996-2024 AR15.COM LLC. All Rights Reserved.
Any use of this content without express written consent is prohibited.
AR15.Com reserves the right to overwrite or replace any affiliate, commercial, or monetizable links, posted by users, with our own.