User Panel
Posted: 5/5/2002 5:48:48 PM EDT
Seeing as I have to report for jury duty tomorrow, I thought I would solicit everyones opinion on what jury duty means to them.
Is it a pain-in-the-ass? An duty we owe our country? A great way to get out of work? [smash] |
|
Quoted: Don't think people should be forced to sit for jury duty. View Quote Why? |
|
Duty and Responsibility. Think about how you could be fulfilling your duty instead - humping a rucksack that seems to outweigh you up a hill in an effort to reach an LZ on time, while watching out for ambushes.
Jury Duty sounds like a cakewalk, even though I haven't been there yet. I might volunteer if they don't hurry up and find me. [:)] |
|
I think it should be considered a privlege {sp} not a duty. People who are forced to do something have funny ways of showing resentment.
|
|
I think that it is a part of your duty as a citizen to serve in its military as well on a jury when you'r called to serve.
7th |
|
it is your responsibility. the thing that pisses me off atleast in my county is the way its set up. last time i went i had to sit there all day. there wasnt a big case load that day so they only needed a couple juries. i didnt get picked. i would have liked to since i was there anyways. after they had picked everyone they needed they still made us sit there till 3:30. even the people that got called up and didnt get picked for a jury had to stay. if they were not picked for whatever reason why the hell couldnt they go home? i have nothing against it i just dont think i should have to sit at the court house all day if im not on a jury. my .02. [:)]
|
|
Quoted: I think it should be considered a privlege {sp} not a duty. People who are forced to do something have funny ways of showing resentment. View Quote I think we are splitting hairs here. To some a "duty" is a priviledge. Forcing people to perform jury duty is the only way. Hell, last month we had a judge get so fed up with no shows for jury duty he issued warrants for everyone who didn't show. Then half of them didn't show up. |
|
Quoted: Duty and Responsibility. Think about how you could be fulfilling your duty instead - humping a rucksack that seems to outweigh you up a hill in an effort to reach an LZ on time, while watching out for ambushes. Jury Duty sounds like a cakewalk, even though I haven't been there yet. I might volunteer if they don't hurry up and find me. [:)] View Quote In NY I think there is a way you can volunteer, might be true in Texas, too-call the local commissioner of jurorors or whatever it's called there. |
|
Quoted: I think it should be considered a privlege {sp} not a duty. People who are forced to do something have funny ways of showing resentment. View Quote |
|
I am an attorney.
Jury duty as set up now is a joke. So many times the parties settle just before jury selection. That's why you sit there for hours in the room waiting. I say we need a change in the law to say if you don't settle the week before the jurors report then both parties must do the entire trial and take the verdict. That would stop all the games with citizens' time. |
|
Quoted: I am an attorney. Jury duty as set up now is a joke. So many times the parties settle just before jury selection. That's why you sit there for hours in the room waiting. I say we need a change in the law to say if you don't settle the week before the jurors report then both parties must do the entire trial and take the verdict. That would stop all the games with citizens' time. View Quote So am I. In criminal defense, it is rare to have a settlement on the day of trial. It would be silly to have a trial if the parties settle on the day of the trial. And there are *far* more criminal trials than there are civil trials. I used to respect the "intelligence of the combined 12" or eight or six, the conventional wisdom that you can fool some people, but not all of them. Now I realize that's B.S. Ya sure can! |
|
I would vote for "all of the above"!
I have severed several times and when I was an employee it was a better income for me. Now, as self employed, one man operation I just can't and I miss it. It is a PIA for sure to get up early, dress to the courts expectations, listen to a bunch of crap from lawyers, witnesses and cops. Trying to sift through all that is not easy but necessary. It will give you a different perspective on the court system. If you don't want to do it, consider this: If you were accused of a crime that you did not commit, who would you want on YOUR jury?? |
|
I recently pulled jury duty. One case all month(rural area,etc) and guess who fucking gets selected?
Anyway the case was over a disturbing the peace violation where the plaintiff was a guy who complained about the wife's ex-husband making too much noise on his bike while driving by at night. Wife happens to be employee of Sheriff's Dept...Anyway, prior to trial one of the Bailiffs, a middle age busy body from what I could tell, comes in and gathers up the female jurors, then proceeds to give a five minute talk on how she has been a bailiff in numerous towns. Worked the "Burning Bed" case. 'Guy deserved what he got, they should stop these guys before it comes to that, etc,etc,etc.' Guy was making a pest of himself, no doubt, but their case was shaky("I saw the back of his head as he went past.."). The whole thing was about using this case to screw the guy over in family court. I could see through that right from the start. I end up being the lone dissenting juror. One of the other guys was a total wuss and the other didn't care what happened as long as he could get it over with so he could have a cigarette. I ended up talking to the judge after the case. Lots of fun being the bearer of bad news to the only fucking judge in my county. He wasn't pleased to say the least and I couldn't really tell if he was pissed at me or the bailiffs. Shit like this follows me every fucking where I go. I shit you not. If there is an asshole within a mile he'll end up in front of me waiting to be told to fuck off. I'm like a magnet for this kind of shit. I'd do it again in a heartbeat, though. However, I'd think really hard about a jury trial after this little experience. Think I'd pack my shit, grab a few guns and head into the woods. Plenty of that up here and I'd pity the sorry SOB's they'd send after me-If anyone was dumb enough. |
|
Quoted: I am an attorney. Jury duty as set up now is a joke. So many times the parties settle just before jury selection. That's why you sit there for hours in the room waiting. I say we need a change in the law to say if you don't settle the week before the jurors report then both parties must do the entire trial and take the verdict. That would stop all the games with citizens' time. View Quote Good point- I worked as an attorney for insurance companies a few years ago and with one client we almost always had a jury called in and usually picked one and started the case, just to try and scare the plaintiff into settling the car accident case (or whatever) for less money. I often picked juries knowing that the insurance company would pay the current demand the plaintiff made to settle the case, but we were trying to bluff them into taking less & it usually worked. Unfortunately it seems like the more likely someone was to be really hurt the more likely they were to cave while the ones I thought were fakers and scammers were more likely to push the case to make as much as they could. Dr.Jarhead-I remember seeing that post and wondered how it all turned out, good job. I am sure the judge was pissed at the bailiffs not you. They tend to be politcial patronage jobs and they don't always end up being the sharpest knives in the drawer. Here in NY once you have served you are immune from being called again for a number of years. |
|
I see it as my duty and resposibility to serve when summoned. My wife got a jury summons in the mail about a month ago but she was still in school when she was supposed to go. Then they rescheduled her for this coming week. Then about 2 weeks ago he gets another one in the mail saying that her summons was cancelled. Then the next day, the news reported that all civil jury trails in Alabama were postponed until October.
|
|
I'm reporting for jury duty today as well, I'm wondering if they'll reject me from service for being a police officer even though I want to do it.
|
|
I got one jury duty summons when I was stationed in Okinawa. I didn't turn up for that one. [;)]
I got one when I lived in California and went to the courthouse. I sat in a room with about eighty other people and not one of us was called for a jury all day. Just a monumental waste of our time. Now I just got not a summons but a jury questionnaire for our county court. I guess I can expect a summons any day now. ***Edited to add: I consider it a duty and responsibility. [b]Aimless:[/b] Did it at all seem like a dirty trick to you to waste the time of the people called for jury duty just to get the other party to settle? |
|
Jury duty has lost me two houses I was moving into. First one my girl friend was not allowed visitors and was not able to return paper work for closing. the second one the same jury duty screwed up income to secure loan. I guess interuption of income due to doing your duty still counts againsts you for big cororations such as banks.
|
|
Quoted: Duty and Responsibility. Think about how you could be fulfilling your duty instead - humping a rucksack .... [:)] View Quote mmhhmmmmm.. should we be worried? humping a rucksack.. you need help my friend. |
|
Waverunner, cops are routinely released. Pre-emptive challenge by defense most of the time. As for civil trial I don't know - never sat on one. Guess it would depend on the nature of the case.
No doubt some cops would make excellent jurors. Trained to observe people and such. OTOH many are prejudiced against the accused due to what they are exposed to everyday and may not fairly evaluate the evidence as presented. Just as prosecuters often reject clergy or social workers. |
|
I served in Federal Court last year. I think my jury duty ran 2-3 months. This was in Alexandria, Virginia. Personally I felt the jury system there was very well run.
Kinda funny though, some jurors though it might be OK to not show up..ha ha ha. Surprise! The Marshalls come get you. Then you get to explain to the judge why its such a great idea for you to skip out. I ended up on 2 trials. The judges there keep things moving, not much bullshit allowed from either side. |
|
I always go to jury duty when I get a summons. Basically it is an easy way to get out of work.
Seriousl, it is the basic building part of our way of government. If you don't have juries, how are you going to judge the plaintiff/defendants? Are we going to have trial by fire? Many times, people(those in the news media whine the most) don't under stand why a jury rendered such and such a decision, that is because these folks have never served on a jury, and don't understand the trials and tribulations behind closed doors. In Los Angeles County, people that used to be routinely excused, such as doctors, lawyers, and even judges are required to served. |
|
Duty and responsibility and also a P.I.T.A. (this is PC speak so I don't get smitten). |
|
I'd love to serve on a jury but both times that I've been summoned it was for a jurisdiction in which I no longer resided.
From what I hear about jury duty, it's not surprising that many people try to avoid it. Consider: 1) Even though jurors are supposed to be performing an important function, they're herded through the system like cattle. 2) The pay stinks. 3) There's a great deal of uncertainty. Will you be selected for a jury? How long will the trial last? Will you be sequestered? At least draftees in the military knew when their enlistments were supposed to end. 4) Judges exercise a great deal of power with little oversight or accountability. When you're in their courtroom, you're effectively the subject of a dictatorship. 5) Jurors are expected to play a very passive role in a trial. They only get to hear a small portion of the truth and they have hardly any lattitude (as far as they're told, at least) in executing the judge's instructions. 6) Jurors get little protection from criminals with an interest in influencing the verdict. 7) Because both sides get to influence jury selection, and because screening potential jurors has been refined to a near science, many potential jurors have a reasonable fear that they'll be rejected in favor of someone more malleable. 8) There's a widely-held suspicion that the well-connected can get out of jury duty. |
|
As a practicing trial attorney (civil) I would have to come down hard on the side of jury service being a duty as a citizen. One of the fundamental rights provided by our judicial system is a trial by a jury of your peers. If we do not have responsible, sensible people who are contributing members of society serving on our juries, we will be denied trial by a jury of our peers and some of these ridiculous jury results which get an undue amount of press attention will only be perpetuated. As I have told many juries in closing argument, their service is as valuable to our country and our way of life as is military service. It may be an inconvenience, but it is your duty as a citizen and you should do it proudly!
|
|
It is a duty and a responsibility that is made a pain in the ass by the people working with the jury pool. I live in Atlanta and was called for jury duty. The apathy and bad attitude of the people working at the court house made me want to pull my hair out. It might not be as bad in other cities and states. Just because it sucked does not mean I will try to avoid jury duty in the future. I am not the sharpest knife in the drawer, but there should be at least one person on a jury with some brain cells and common sense.
ARH |
|
[b]Aimless:[/b] Did it at all seem like a dirty trick to you to waste the time of the people called for jury duty just to get the other party to settle? View Quote At the time I was still doing work for insurance companies I was a little younger and trying to make a name for myself, impress clients etc. so I don't think I gave it a lot of thought. I think it bothers me more now, people have to take time off from work, find babysitters, etc just to sit around in a room for two hours and then be told to go home. This happened to me a few years ago. (NY stopped letting lawyers automatically get out of jury duty sometime after I started practicing- prior to that I would fill out a form that said I was lawyer and I couldn't be called) I was called for jury duty on a medical malpractice case and I KNEW the plaintiff's attorney (whimp) was going to settle, he wouldn't try a case with a gun pointed at this head, but I still had to sit around cooling my heels until the inevitable settlement (brought the newspaper). Unfortunately I was just in court this morning and a whole pool of jurors got brought in and let go-however I had to handle the case that way and keeping my client out of jail comes first, but I can see why the folks who sat around from 9 until 10:30 then were told to go home didn't leave with a good impression of the system. I live in a small town and have had jurors that did sit on a case to verdict come up to me at gas stations, and so on, after the case was over months ago to talk about it. They often remember the case much more clearly than I and are very interested in finding out more about the case and seemed to have liked being on the jury and taken in pride in doing a good job. My impression from most of the jurors that I have spoken to, that actually decided a case, was that they thought it was a positive experience and took the responsibility seriously. For the most part it's a good system, despite the inconveniences. |
|
I'm 28, have been called several times and served once (felony batter against a police officer). I'd gladly do it again. It gave a lot of insight into how a jury is supposed to handle a case, such as the burden of proof, using only the facts from the case and not the defendant's background, etc.
Put me on another one with one of those unconstitutional firearms laws so I can put jury nullification to work. |
|
Actually serving on a petit jury was kinda fun.
But I didn't have to travel far or anything. I got picked for the first case and it turned out that was the best, because then I wasn't likely to be called the rest of the week and wasn't. I couldn't believe the amount of jerks trying to get out of it while they were picking for my case. Old people faking bad hearing, people playing dumb when asked questions by the defense and prosecution. Serving on a federal jury would be a bitch because all those federal courthouses seem to be in the big cities like Chicago that I like to avoid. Parking is a hassle. But if duty calls....I'll be there. |
|
Well, I reported as ordered today but I did not get to serve. The process was painless and I was in and out in 3 hours or so.
The funny part came during the questioning of the jurors by the prosecution. The panel was asked if anyone knew the arresting officer. Oops, dang if I didn't. The attorney asked how I knew him and I told him he was a personal friend. I was watching the defense attorney as I answered and he marked my name off his list faster than I could finish the rest of my answer. As I left the courtroom my buddy was sitting in the hall, he looked at me, grinned and asked what I was doing there. I just laughed and said you just got me out of the jury panel. Oh well, maybe next time. |
|
Never been called (that I'm aware of). The Florida legal system doesn't keep very good track of us military guys who are out of state.
But when I get out in June and move to VA, I hope I do get called. |
|
Sign up for the ARFCOM weekly newsletter and be entered to win a free ARFCOM membership. One new winner* is announced every week!
You will receive an email every Friday morning featuring the latest chatter from the hottest topics, breaking news surrounding legislation, as well as exclusive deals only available to ARFCOM email subscribers.
AR15.COM is the world's largest firearm community and is a gathering place for firearm enthusiasts of all types.
From hunters and military members, to competition shooters and general firearm enthusiasts, we welcome anyone who values and respects the way of the firearm.
Subscribe to our monthly Newsletter to receive firearm news, product discounts from your favorite Industry Partners, and more.
Copyright © 1996-2024 AR15.COM LLC. All Rights Reserved.
Any use of this content without express written consent is prohibited.
AR15.Com reserves the right to overwrite or replace any affiliate, commercial, or monetizable links, posted by users, with our own.