Quoted:
In addition to knowing how to fly big jets, knowing how to operate these increasingly complex airplanes, and all that technical stuff that is constantly being updated, these guys want ALL pilots to also become experts in the use of firearms and the application of deadly force?
Have you ever seen most of these pilots? They look alot like engineers, with pocket protectors and everything... (no offense to engineers). They're science/math geeks with good vision and better-than-average hand-eye coordination, right?
How many have the "warrior mentality" or physical skills required to take on this role of sky-cop?
View Quote
I'm an airline captain. I'll use myself as an example, because I'm not too out-of-the-ordinary: I've shot competitively, taken a number of defensive handgun courses, and hunted dangerous game in Alaska and Africa. During seven years in the Marines, I did an infantry tour, flew fighters off carriers, and graduated from Topgun. Yes, we have the "warrior mentality and physical skills required". And as Fingers pointed out, it would be a voluntary program contingent upon the completion of appropriate training.
Right now, we're being treated as part of the problem instead of as part of the solution.
There will never be enough Air Marshals to go around, but pilots are "required equipment" on an airliner. Arming them would be about as cost-effective as a security program can be.
The terrorism problem is a long way from over. Pilots and their passengers are likely to be combatants again - or, if we continue to make ourselves defensless, casualties. Once the wheels come up, an airline crew is on it's own. Should our last line of defense be the skill and cunning of the metal-detector operators? If we're willing to shoot down hijacked airliners, shouldn't we give them the means to avoid being hijacked? Our government holds pilots responsible for their aircraft and passengers, while simultaneously denying them the tools to carry out that responsibility.
If the pilots on September 11 had been armed and had known what we now know, could they have prevented those hijackings? Probably, and they certainly had nothing to lose by trying. More importantly, if the cockpits had been armed, would the hijackers have even tried? As Benjamin Franklin said, "If you make yourselves sheep, the wolves will eat you."