User Panel
Posted: 6/14/2012 3:03:29 PM EDT
While shooting my Hi-power today its two-piece barrel came apart at the seam. No pictures yet but it appears whatever bonded together the two pieces failed. There was no damage to the pistol.
Anyone had this happen to them? |
|
If it is genuine Browning call them, not email Call. If it's not browning, see if Sarco has a new barrel. This is a gunsmith install, they are not drop in.
|
|
Quoted:
If it is genuine Browning call them, not email Call. If it's not browning, see if Sarco has a new barrel. This is a gunsmith install, they are not drop in. |
|
Quoted:
If it is genuine Browning call them, not email Call. If it's not browning, see if Sarco has a new barrel. This is a gunsmith install, they are not drop in. Wouldn't a local gunsmith be able to reattach the two pieces? |
|
Quoted:
If it is genuine Browning call them, not email Call. If it's not browning, see if Sarco has a new barrel. This is a gunsmith install, they are not drop in. That's new to me. Care to explain? |
|
No. Get on the phone with Browning CS.
Posted Via AR15.Com Mobile |
|
Would love to see pics. Hope you get it straightened out. BTW- do you know the round count of the gun, much +P, etc? 4073 |
|
Quoted: Quoted: If it is genuine Browning call them, not email Call. If it's not browning, see if Sarco has a new barrel. This is a gunsmith install, they are not drop in. Wouldn't a local gunsmith be able to reattach the two pieces? probably not....they are finished dimensioned after being put together.... |
|
I do wanna see pics, too. Was it a true Browning or FN Hi Power????
|
|
Quoted:
Quoted:
If it is genuine Browning call them, not email Call. If it's not browning, see if Sarco has a new barrel. This is a gunsmith install, they are not drop in. That's new to me. Care to explain? Real pistols require fitting of the barrel to the slide. Some may drop in, but it's purely accidental if they do. |
|
I had a FEG with a barrel that separated. They covered it under the warranty but they're out of business now
|
|
Quoted:
I had a FEG with a barrel that separated. They covered it under the warranty but they're out of business now Ouch. When did they go out of business? Or am I hopelessly behind the times, and my procrastination has got me in trouble (not new––––called S&W for a part a couple days ago to finally fix a model 64 that has been 10-7 for a while and was told I was SOL, as the 64-4 was obsolete and they don't have any parts for them anymore.) |
|
Quoted:
Quoted:
If it is genuine Browning call them, not email Call. If it's not browning, see if Sarco has a new barrel. This is a gunsmith install, they are not drop in. Wouldn't a local gunsmith be able to reattach the two pieces? |
|
Quoted:
Quoted:
I had a FEG with a barrel that separated. They covered it under the warranty but they're out of business now Ouch. When did they go out of business? Or am I hopelessly behind the times, and my procrastination has got me in trouble (not new––––called S&W for a part a couple days ago to finally fix a model 64 that has been 10-7 for a while and was told I was SOL, as the 64-4 was obsolete and they don't have any parts for them anymore.) 2007. Numrich has their parts inventory and of course Browning parts interchange. |
|
|
Quoted:
It's a 1970s FEG Hi-power. It was an engagement gift. http://i23.photobucket.com/albums/b367/thunderw21/more%20stuff/pics/Hipower001-2.jpg The barrel: http://i23.photobucket.com/albums/b367/thunderw21/more%20stuff/pics/FEGbarrel001.jpg http://i23.photobucket.com/albums/b367/thunderw21/more%20stuff/pics/FEGbarrel002.jpg http://i23.photobucket.com/albums/b367/thunderw21/more%20stuff/pics/FEGbarrel003.jpg http://i23.photobucket.com/albums/b367/thunderw21/more%20stuff/pics/FEGbarrel004.jpg http://i23.photobucket.com/albums/b367/thunderw21/more%20stuff/pics/FEGbarrel005.jpg Also, why a two piece barrel? Seems overly complicated and prone to failure. Two=piece is cheaper to make, period. Neat pistol. I regret selling my FEG many years ago. |
|
Numrich has the FEG barrels for like $75 it will need to be fitted to your slide and frame.
|
|
Wow, should that have been hi temp silver-soldered?
My Oct 1944 Inglis Mk1* has a barrel made in one piece from a forging. |
|
Quoted:
why not mention its an FM in the first post? Partly 'cause it is a FEG, I guess. |
|
Quoted:
Wow, should that have been hi temp silver-soldered? My Oct 1944 Inglis Mk1* has a barrel made in one piece from a forging. Starting around 1962 all FN Hi Power barrels went from a single forging to two piece barrels. VERY rare to have one separate. |
|
Quoted:
Quoted:
Quoted:
I had a FEG with a barrel that separated. They covered it under the warranty but they're out of business now Ouch. When did they go out of business? Or am I hopelessly behind the times, and my procrastination has got me in trouble (not new––––called S&W for a part a couple days ago to finally fix a model 64 that has been 10-7 for a while and was told I was SOL, as the 64-4 was obsolete and they don't have any parts for them anymore.) 2007. Numrich has their parts inventory and of course Browning parts interchange. Dang. I am behind the times. In '05 I knew I needed the part, but just left it be 'till that mythical "later" that never seems to come around. Guess I will check Numrich tomorrow (on a side note, they ended up having the part I needed for the 64-4 as well, just at a higher price than S&W would have sold it for.) |
|
You could also check with Cylinder & Slide or Novak to see if they fix barrels... worth a try.
|
|
Quoted: You could also check with Cylinder & Slide or Novak to see if they fix barrels... worth a try. Have a good smith ( such as Cylinder and Slide ) fit a Bar Sto barrel to your HP....you won't be disappointed. |
|
Quoted:
Quoted:
You could also check with Cylinder & Slide or Novak to see if they fix barrels... worth a try. Have a good smith ( such as Cylinder and Slide ) fit a Bar Sto barrel to your HP....you won't be disappointed. Yeah, but this is a FEG..... My FEG has an outstanding trigger... but I hear many FEG triggers are not all that great... And even though my FEG has a great trigger it is still a FEG, so I personally would go for the least expensive fix... I think.... And I have never had a problem swapping out Browning Hi Power barrels between different pistols... including my FEG. I might try buying a decent used Browning barrel and drop that in. |
|
I have a Browning Hi-Power that I've owned since the 80's, its one forged piece. Can you show a picture of yours? (sorry posted before I saw the pictures) I guess I need to have a look at mine
|
|
You know, since they manufacture the barrel in two pieces.... and since it came apart with no damage.... getting that same barrel back together can't be too difficult or expensive, or so it would seem.
|
|
Quoted: You know, since they manufacture the barrel in two pieces.... and since it came apart with no damage.... getting that same barrel back together can't be too difficult or expensive, or so it would seem. Cheaper to buy a replacement barrel...I would think. Unless you are a gunsmith who could do the work yourself. I just took mine apart and it looks one piece. Its an older Hi-Power, did they change the manufacturing process at some point?
|
|
Quoted:
Wow, should that have been hi temp silver-soldered? My Oct 1944 Inglis Mk1* has a barrel made in one piece from a forging. I thought they put them together by heating the collar/lug peice to make it larger, then smacking it into the barrel, and when it cooled it would then be a seriously tight friction fit. IIRC, they do cylinder liners on some engine blocks like that. I should think you could easily silver solder it back together, perhaps have a gunsmith silver solder, then maybe see if a solid straight pin could be press fit into an undersized hole that transects the barrel through the locking lug block? |
|
If there is still some friction between the 2 parts I would clean thouroughly and use Loctite Bearing Retainer.
I've seen 1911 .45 2 piece barrels also. I don't think I would silver solder those pieces. |
|
Quoted:
Quoted:
why not mention its an FM in the first post? Partly 'cause it is a FEG, I guess. It's like telling everyone about your 'Vette and omitting the fact that it's a CHE-Vette... |
|
Quoted:
If there is still some friction between the 2 parts I would clean thouroughly and use Loctite Bearing Retainer. I've seen 1911 .45 2 piece barrels also. I don't think I would silver solder those pieces. Oh, Loctite, thats a good idea. You can blue the crap out of stuff with that. The only thing I can say is that I don't think I would trust that particular barrel with my life in the future, regardless of the fix. I'd probably shoot it again, but I don't think I'd use it as a carry weapon or a nightstand gun. |
|
Quoted: JB Weld it and get back to shooting. That is exactly what I was thinking... |
|
So about half the posters are telling me to buy a new barrel and have it fitted by a competent gunsmith while the other half say to JB Weld the old barrel. This isn't a carry gun or self defense handgun, just a shooter.
Any other opinions are appreciated. |
|
Quoted: So about half the posters are telling me to buy a new barrel and have it fitted by a competent gunsmith while the other half say to JB Weld the old barrel. This isn't a carry gun or self defense handgun, just a shooter. Any other opinions are appreciated. If you buy a new barrel its just a plug and play. |
|
I love the BHP and I never knew that the barrel was a two piece construction I learn something new everyday on this website
|
|
Quoted:
Quoted:
So about half the posters are telling me to buy a new barrel and have it fitted by a competent gunsmith while the other half say to JB Weld the old barrel. This isn't a carry gun or self defense handgun, just a shooter. Any other opinions are appreciated. If you buy a new barrel its just a plug and play. Will a new barrel drop in and run? Probably. Will it fit properly and wear slowly in the lug areas? Doubtful. |
|
I had a early '80's BHP barrel break on me but the lug just snapped off. I contacted Browning about it and sent it to the repair facility. They wouldn't touch it because the magazine disconnect had been removed.
I fitted a Bar-Sto barrel and still shoot it now and then. |
|
Quoted:
So about half the posters are telling me to buy a new barrel and have it fitted by a competent gunsmith while the other half say to JB Weld the old barrel. This isn't a carry gun or self defense handgun, just a shooter. Any other opinions are appreciated. Knurl it and press it on? |
|
Quoted:
So about half the posters are telling me to buy a new barrel and have it fitted by a competent gunsmith while the other half say to JB Weld the old barrel. This isn't a carry gun or self defense handgun, just a shooter. Any other opinions are appreciated. I installed a Bar-Sto in mine. It was easy. Complete instructions came with the barrel and with minor fitting, it locked up tight and shoots very accurately. |
|
Quoted:
Quoted:
Quoted:
So about half the posters are telling me to buy a new barrel and have it fitted by a competent gunsmith while the other half say to JB Weld the old barrel. This isn't a carry gun or self defense handgun, just a shooter. Any other opinions are appreciated. If you buy a new barrel its just a plug and play. Will a new barrel drop in and run? Probably. Will it fit properly and wear slowly in the lug areas? Doubtful. This, the fitting needed is minor. My local smith who is a browning and colt guy, charges about $30 to fit a barrel. |
|
DO NOT JB WELD IT , they are a bunch of idiots on here that think that kind of crap is funny . Get a new barrel and have a smith fit it or you could get injured or worse..
|
|
Quoted: DO NOT JB WELD IT , they are a bunch of idiots on here that think that kind of crap is funny . Get a new barrel and have a smith fit it or you could get injured or worse.. Agreed. I hope no one took the JB weld idea as serious. |
|
Quoted: DO NOT JB WELD IT , they are a bunch of idiots on here that think that kind of crap is funny . Get a new barrel and have a smith fit it or you could get injured or worse.. I don't disagree with your sentiment, but I suspect that if it comes apart in the gun, you'll get a horrible jam, not a Kaboom. |
|
Sign up for the ARFCOM weekly newsletter and be entered to win a free ARFCOM membership. One new winner* is announced every week!
You will receive an email every Friday morning featuring the latest chatter from the hottest topics, breaking news surrounding legislation, as well as exclusive deals only available to ARFCOM email subscribers.
AR15.COM is the world's largest firearm community and is a gathering place for firearm enthusiasts of all types.
From hunters and military members, to competition shooters and general firearm enthusiasts, we welcome anyone who values and respects the way of the firearm.
Subscribe to our monthly Newsletter to receive firearm news, product discounts from your favorite Industry Partners, and more.
Copyright © 1996-2024 AR15.COM LLC. All Rights Reserved.
Any use of this content without express written consent is prohibited.
AR15.Com reserves the right to overwrite or replace any affiliate, commercial, or monetizable links, posted by users, with our own.