User Panel
Killing FAMILIES?
Caprica is a smoking, radioactive ruin. The people on the ships are the only real hope. Her actions are unforgiveable.
No, just inhumane and genocidal. |
|||
|
Adama was put in the same situation and realized he didn't have enough of a force to take on the enemy. The fleet he took on had ships capable of resupplying the Galactica with critical material. Including fuel. Adama has a logistical tail to support his combat actions against the Cylons. Pegasus has only what she was able to take. Amateurs argue tactics, Professionals discuss logistics. The counterpoint to this is that maybe the ships Cain ran into lacked the capabilities Adamas have. And she made the best of the situation. One thing we don't know, is where did Cain leave the ships she stranded? If she left them in deep space with only sublight drive, she may as well have gunned them down. But, if she left them close to an inhabitable planet, there may have been a slim chance they could make it. But, I bet she didn't leave them any shuttles. |
|
|
D. V. R. Watch it the next day. |
|
|
tell AZ to get with the program and join the rest of us observing Daylight Savings Time |
|
|
Anyone up for a nitpicker's thread?
I just found one: When GALACTICA first makes an FTL jump, her landing bays are deployed when in the previous scene they had been retracted in preparation for the jump. Oops! ETA: Funny thing, but I read the book in 1985 or so. The bays were always supposed to retract, yet they didn't bother with that detail in the original series. To be honest, I think the whole idea is dumb, but there it is. |
|
It seems people think I'm a despot with a pechant for murdering families now.
Remember that Kain doesn't have Earth as a goal unlike Adama and the Pres. She can't fly into the dusk looking for refuge. With no place to which she can run, she's doing raids hoping to find a weakness in the Cylons to exploit to push them back far enough to reclaim depots, space docks, space stations, the colonies even. From there, she will be much better equiped to mount a stronger offensive. The long term goal is reclaiming the twelve colonies for humanity- even if it means fighting for radioactive balls of slag. The valuable resources, supplies, infrastructure, salvageables left behind can make clean up possible. Kain's priorities are fighting first, then rebuilding. To fight, Kain needs replacement parts and technical expertise among other things. Adama's goal is different. He wants to transplant humanity forsaking the original colonies. This is a shot in the dark with no telling if Earth is hospitable. They will be rebuilding from nothing- no existing ammuntion depots, space docks, shipyards, space stations, orbital communications, ect. Adama's priority is rebuilding on Earth, then to fight only when necessary. To rebuild, he needs to bring all his infrastructure with him: all the technicians, fuel refineries, botanists, greenhouse ships, fianancial brokers, and politicians. Kain and Adama see the world differently. This you cannot deny. The difference of vision paints different goals. This in turn yields divergent methods and priorities to reach those goals. I simply stated that Kain's actions are not without reason. Even despots and tyrants act with reason. My mentioning and understanding said reason doesn't endorse or scorn the act, which I think some of my critics fail to understand. |
|
Daylight savings time bad. Sat. TV good. |
||
|
|
Uhm, he made up the story about knowing where Earth is, and doesn't believe that it does exist, when he decides to lead the people away. His original thought is to fight, just like Cain. Now, by time he runs into Cain, things have changed, and he sees things differently. But when the Cylons first attacked, he could very easily have taken the same route Cain did. And as he, himself, pointed out, they did shoot down a civilian ship. They didn't know for certain whether there were humans on board or not. |
|
|
|
||
|
You're correct. However, despite the farce that is Earth (or not so farce now with as much plot revealed), Adama did grudgingly acquiesce that the prudent choice was to run saving as much as he could before he revealed Earth to the fleet. "They've got to start making babies" was the epiphany in the CIC referring to Dee and Billy. At that exact moment, you see the switch in his priorities promoting the survival of the immediate fleet over recapture of the twelve colonies. Kain has not had this epiphany. |
||
|
Tag, and dang I love this show. Bought season 2.0 Sat. My boys and I spend most of today watching it again.
|
|
Yeah, I picked up on that too. Gina's gonna get loose somehow (maybe with the help of phantom-6 or Baltar) and go after Cain. She'll be stopped and killed, and Starbuck won't have a chance to perform the assassination. When Gina dies she won't be ressurected... oops surprise! Then the Cylon reinforcements are going to jump in, looking for a little payback for the rez ship. They'll be expecting Pegasus to be lax after the battle (just like both Battlestar commanders were about each other!), but with the attempted assasination, Pegasus will be all kinds of hot and bothered, catch the would-be revengers with their chassis down after the jump, and start blasting them to bolts. Sometime in the show, there will be a confrontation where Cain and Adama accuse each other of being callous to civilians and reckless. They'll have a brief semi-reconciliation when they each grudgingly admit that the other was doing the best they could with what they could -- though their methods and attitudes differ. Pegasus will be so busy kicking ass that they'll separate from the fleet. Cain's last order to Adama will be to get the hell out of the area, while Pegasus holds off the retribution BaseStars. Galactica and the fleet will jump out, and the fate of Pegasus will be an unknown. Galactica will take aboard the Pegasus fighters, including some Cain loyalists and co-philosophers, which will be important later. One of them will be taking the thematic place of Sheba, instead of being a literal daughter will be a thorn in Adama's side.
Oh, I don't know... Just because Galactica TOS never got far enough to become Battlefleet Galactica, doesn't mean we can't supersede homage and take that direction! Remember how JMS changed Babylon 5 every season... If you take "Babylon 5 was our last, best hope for peace. It failed. In the year 2260 it became something greater. Our last, best hope... for victory." File off the B5 and write in BSG, and maybe you've got something... Oh, and I've heard Richard Hatch talk about Galactica. If he gets a word in edgewise, he'll be pushing his own vision of a Colonial reclamation expeditionary force, new battlestars, and all that good stuff. Honestly, I don't so much care where it goes, because I'm sure I'll enjoy the trip! |
||
|
I'm interested to see just what Galactica and Pegasus will use when they go after the Base Stars. Flak guns and harsh language? I don't see the BSG equivalent of 16" guns on either...
|
|
if they do make it to earth who says it has to be in todays time??????
why not farther in the future???? whit our own equivalant to battle stars???? i think that would be the way to go... BEST DAM SHOW ON TV !! |
|
Please tell me you are not right and did not spoil the show. I like surprise. |
||
|
The whole human race on the Fleet is less than 50,000 people.
Retaking the Colonies is a pipe dream, and they are a radioactive wasteland anyway. It's impossible for 50k people to wage a sustained war against the Cylons. It will take centuries of unmolested growth for humans to repopulate to sufficient numbers to sustain a war effort of that magnitude. Their best bet is to LEAVE. Find a corner of the galaxy and rebuild, arm & stay vigilant, and pray the Cylons don't find you. |
|
I don't think something like that is out of the question. Keep in mind, that the Cylons, Galacticans, Humans in general, and Pegasans have all had their turn being held up as both victim and villain. And each faction, from their perspective, has their own faults and their legitimate grievances with the others. I wouldn't be surprised if everybody involved in this story goes through a phase where they sin and do wrong, and then when the consequenses come, *then* they get a choice of right or wrong, to redeem or be doomed. |
||
|
But that's the insanity of her position. It would take very heavy industry to construct and maintain something as complex as a Battlestar and its Vipers. Suppose they do take back Caprica or one of the other Colonies, they would have to rebuild everything from scratch as it was all nuked in the opening days of the war. How many decades would it take to rebuild enough infrastructure to maintain even one Battlestar, much less a fleet strong enough to defend the Colonies? Remember we're talking from the ground up. You'd have to rebuild electronics factories and mining operations and munitions factories - the list goes on. Even if they could rebuild all of that, how large a fleet could a population of 50,000 sustain economically? 12 Planets populated with billions each supported a military of about 120 Battlestars IIRC. Rosalyn was right in the beginning. They have no choice but to run. Kain does not understand this, and is doing the only thing she know's how - fighting. Adama would have followed this same path if Rosalyn had not talked sense into him in the mini-series. Now, once the Colonials find Earth, then its a different story. Earth's population with Colonial technology, if given enough time away from the Cylons to integrate, would give humanity a fighting chance. I hope that after BSG has run its course, they'll do a sequal several decades after the fleet reaches earth in which the humans do seek to reclaim their birthright of Kobol and the other 12 Colonies of Man. |
|
|
But, given the choice and only the choice, wouldn't you kill a couple of families, instead of allowing all of those families, plus thousands of other people, to die? From what I can gather, Cain's judgement of her situation told her that Pegasus would not be able to function, in any reasonable role, dragging around a civilian fleet. Adama made a similar decision, but with opposite motivation. While Cain had to abandon civilians to regain her ability to wage war, Adama abandoned some civilians instead of staying to fight and losing all of them. (Not saying that it's right or wrong -- just that I'm glad I don't live in a morality play!) |
||
|
My thinking exactly. The Colonies are DEAD. RIP. |
|
|
No sir, pure speculation! |
||
|
According to various sources (SciFi.com / Ragnar etc.) the Galactica armament consists of: 506 point defense batteries (Vulcan equivalent) 24 heavy turrets (5in rapid fire equivalent) 4 forward firing heavy cannons called the Main Battery All are massdrivers / railguns with conventional solid / explosive bullets. The Peggy has more weapons which include directed energy guns and heavy missiles. Note the comment by Laura about Pegasus kicking the Galacticas rear in a firefight. Fritz |
|
|
I thought I heard Tigh ask Adama (early in the episode, when the fighter wings are playing chicken with each other) whether they should target the main batteries (or main guns) on Pegasus. That must have referred to more than their AA guns. |
|
|
I'm thinking there'll be a showdown between the cylons and humans at earth that'll resolve all this religious prophecy deal. |
||
|
Yeah, but will the earth they find be ready to do anything for them?
|
|
But what type of earth will they find? I hope it's nothing like that gay shit that was on in the 80's. Remember the flying bikes and the arm bands that made you invisable? This is just a though but I think they fin earth in a pre industrial form nad to fit in and to hide form the Cylons they shun thier own technology to fit in to what they find on earth. But then thats just my thoughts your mileage may very. |
|
|
Earth is the Cylon homeworld
Now that would be a plot twist. The history of Kobol had the thirteenth tribe leaving BEFORE the other twelve and they went to a different location, and thus contact was lost. 12 Planets banned the defeated Cylons (thirteenth tribe) after the first war. They left first. The Second War happens and the other twelve leave for a different location. What has happened before will happen again! Interesting parallels. |
|
Earth (assuming 2006 technology) would likely need decades, at least, in order to begin to produce a viable fleet. Quite a bit of infrastructure would need to be built but, presumably, there are enough Colonials with the relevant knowledge to build what needs to be built. |
|
|
Just watched this weeks show... WOW what a damn good show. It is by far the best damned show on TV.
~Dg84 |
|
Ya, but Tigh is looped on space-booze all the time, so who knows? At the Battlestar Wiki, they list the following:
Plus the three remaining nukes. It's just that we never really saw Galactica itself take the fight to the enemy; it seems more like a WW2-era British Armoured Deck Carrier, in that is a really tough aircraft carrier, but still, just an aircraft carrier. They hauled ass pretty quickly whenever they encountered Base Stars before, so I can't wait to see how this one is pulled off. |
|||
|
If they find earth, hopefully it's a hundred years plus into the future so we dont all poo poo the whole thing. Maybe the beginnings of interstellar travel, some space based assets for defense from asteroids or something that would at least be viable to ward off a base star or two. ....
|
|
I think finding Earth is the least of their worries right now, as a TV show.
I think finding Earth may well be their shark. |
|
Well the characters involved didn't think it was that simple. The point was the same one Adama made in the show. He hoped that the record of the action would be viewed in the right light. The essence of the discussion on this subject is that things aren't always black and white. |
||
|
I say that they find Earth abandoned. Examination of records left behind show that the resources had been used up and the two most powerful nations allied to terraform and colonize a new system of planets... |
|
|
i'm thinking there's more of a connection with them happening upon the "resurrection" ship. |
||
|
not after 10pm tomorrow it won't be!!! |
|
|
? whatisit |
||
|
The Shield! And even then, it'll be nearly impossible to call the better show. |
|||
|
That's NUTS. The Cylons don't want to wipe out the Colonies - they want to wipe out humans. Pre-industrial? Just makes it easier to kill us all |
|
|
That sounds... "Serene" |
||
|
Just for shits and giggles, I'd LOVE to know how much "Baltar's House" costs.
Vancouver, with a view like that, with a balcony and hot tub. Wow..... |
|
After next Sunday & Monday they'll both be neck & neck for 2nd, if past seasons are any indication... (Just my contentious way of saying "TAG" in this new thread. ) |
||||
|
I don't know about "longest thread," but I would bet "total pages/posts" would go to 24. |
|
|
If the Cylons followed the Galactica to Earth under the protection of Earthforce, surprise would be their new feeling and emotion.
Yes.. That is the scale of the Galatica to the Excaliber.. Yes.. She is a big ship.. Note the Enterprise in the Bottom left. Its as long as Galactics Launch bay and as wide. |
|
Damn! Someone has a little time on their hands. Looks pretty neat, though. |
|
|
Sign up for the ARFCOM weekly newsletter and be entered to win a free ARFCOM membership. One new winner* is announced every week!
You will receive an email every Friday morning featuring the latest chatter from the hottest topics, breaking news surrounding legislation, as well as exclusive deals only available to ARFCOM email subscribers.
AR15.COM is the world's largest firearm community and is a gathering place for firearm enthusiasts of all types.
From hunters and military members, to competition shooters and general firearm enthusiasts, we welcome anyone who values and respects the way of the firearm.
Subscribe to our monthly Newsletter to receive firearm news, product discounts from your favorite Industry Partners, and more.
Copyright © 1996-2024 AR15.COM LLC. All Rights Reserved.
Any use of this content without express written consent is prohibited.
AR15.Com reserves the right to overwrite or replace any affiliate, commercial, or monetizable links, posted by users, with our own.