Just double checking.

Yes.
I think it's wise to know the person though.

Now what about off something like Gunbroker. If I was to purchase an item from a fellow Hoosier (god I hate that word) would he then need to mail it to a FFL still?

No.  Person to person within state does not require FFL.

Quoted: Now what about off something like Gunbroker. If I was to purchase an item from a fellow Hoosier (god I hate that word) would he then need to mail it to a FFL still?

Quoted: Now what about off something like Gunbroker. If I was to purchase an item from a fellow Hoosier (god I hate that word) would he then need to mail it to a FFL still?

It wouldn't have to go through an FFL, but the seller may want the transaction to go through one.

For example, I currently have a lower on Gunbroker. I will sell it local to someone with an Indiana driver's license and carry permit. However, if they don't have a carry permit, then I want the transfer to be done through an FFL. That gives me some measure of protection against selling to a prohibited person.

Of course, I never would do that when dealing with established arfcom members.