As much as I hate to suggest it, with an LEO's salary I think Anthem might do you ok. They have both the cheaper, cookie-cutter houses and the higher-end custom homes. Not the best area, but growing, and it seems most that live there are middle-class (real) people. Being right off the 17 and only 10 minutes North of the Loop 101, Cave Creek and Scottsdale are only 20 and 30 minutes away, respectively, and Table Mesa road (for desert shooting) is only 15 minutes North.
Fountain Hills and Rio Verde are incredibly expensive, as is North Scottsdale. Paradise Valley has some beautiful homes in some very well maintained areas, but their prices are skyrocketing. If you don't mind North of the city proper, there are some nice places out about 99th Ave and Union Hills - again, right off the Loop 101 for easy access to downtown Phoenix. In Phoenix, look at an area called Moon Valley. I lived there on Greenway Parkway and 7th Avenue and there are some beautiful, affordable housing communities. More than a few cops live in those houses, which helps deter bad stuff in the area.
I work for some awsome realtors - honest and informed, if you shoot me an IM with your current information I can hook you up with several who can probably give you more details to meet your needs.
Welcome to AZ, bro!
Richard