I shot my first 100 rounds of Portugese through my M1-A last Friday with no problems, and have heard nothing but good about the stuff.
I would suspect the rifle. I usually test brands of ammo by loading 2 rounds, firing the first round, then manually eject the second and look at the primer to see if there's a ding in it. There should be no more than a pinpoint sized scratch. If there's more, and it happens with a couple brands of ammo, something is amiss. I'd suspect crud build up in the chamber or bolt face, but I'm no expert.
I shoot American Eagle, Winchester, and Portugese, and found the Winchester primers have the biggest dings, but still haven't had a slamfire. Though some people poo-poo American Eagle, the primers are harder than Winchester in my experiments, and it's plenty accurate.