I am looking to purchase a new Tactical pump shotgun
I have narrowed my choices to a Remington 870 or a Benelli Supernova Tactical. (Sorry Mossberg enthusiasts).
Both with pistol Grip.
Both are approximately $430 in my area.
I was able to compare the two side-by-side, but that did not make my choice any easier. Both felt nice. Both had slight advantages over the other.
Here is my summary:
870: Pros: Time-tested design (1951), made in USA, 7+1 rounds, slightly smoother action (v. BSN), slide release button has easier access (v. BSN), lots of accessories available.
870 Cons: Poor sights (v. BSN), Many posts stating their 870s are rust buckets, Found many posts that the 870's have had quality problems off-and-on over the past 10-15 years.
BSN: Pros: Better feel in hands, longer forearm, nicer butt stock, far nicer ghost ring sights (with aftermarket tritium available), virtually weatherproof/no rust (posted feedback), Cabela's currently has 12 month, 0% interest for 12 months - always nice to temporarily spend someone else's money); receiver already tapped.
BSN Cons: Fewer accessories available (but, all I want is an extended tube, shell holder, and tritium sights - all available); only 4+1 rounds, design only been around since 2005, harder access to slide release (due to beefier trigger guard).
All constructive feedback with be greatly appreciated.
I don't want this to become an argument.
Thanks