Quoted: I think so. Shoot it at night and you tell me! Typically your 9mm and .40 Smith are the best option when short barrel is required.
I can't beleive how short they make .45 ACPs. How much of the cartridge to you want to waste anyway? Even in a 5" barrel they only achieve about 850 fps. Anything slower than that and you could practically jump out of the way of the bullet!
|
markm hits the nail on the head.
The .357 is powerful enough that, even with a fair amount of lost velocity, it's still a good stopper.
The 9mm and even the .40S&W are naturals for short barreled pistols because the powder used in commercial loadings results in relatively high chamber pressures and fast burn times. Therefore, not much energy is lost with shorter barrels.
By contrast, 45 ACP barrel lengths less than Commander length experience a significant decrease in velocity. The very short barreled 45s have a nice looking big bore but the terminal ballistics of approximately a 38 special fired from a 4" barrel.