Quoted: which one should i buy?
the colt series 70 is satin nickle finish with 2 mags. hardly shot. $600.00
or
sig p200 with 2 xtra mags also in fine shape with night sights for 550.00
keep in mind i cant get both, which one should i get?
|
$600 seems fair for an original series 70 in satin nickle. If it's a refinish job, it's worth less than that though.
$550 seems high for a Sig P220. CDNN is selling trade ins for $389.00
Heres the deal. If you want to take the time to learn the nuances of the 1911, get the Colt.
If you want a gun that will grow in value, get the colt.
If you don't like your gun not having a manual safety, get the colt.
If you want something simpler to operate, get the sig.
If you want something that will feed more ammo types stock out of the box, get the sig.
Both guns should be accurate. The nickle finish on the Colt will hold up better. Sigs rust pretty easy.
I've had both guns. I actually traded the Sig away (paid $469.00 for it brand new in 1994) for a Colt 1911 US Property marked pistol made in 1918. It had been refinished, but IMO I got a bargain. In your case I'd get the Colt. I do plan on owning a Sig P220 and P226 again someday though.
Edited to add: I'd take what Hilton Yam said with a grain of salt. It sounds like the same kind of crap American Handgunner printed when they said the Colt Commercial (pre 70 series) pistols were all made from rejected USGI parts and were terrible guns.