Yeah, I posted in GD regarding this as well, and got several "Its sighted in at the factory" type remarks. Apparently it wasn't sighted in that well. If it was just my shooting it, and everyone else hit OK with it, that'd be one thing. But when several people I know to be reasonably good pistol shots group the same with it, what else is there?
I finally did get it to move, thanks to a little nudge from a hydraulic arbor press and some experimentation with spacers to keep the slide from rolling bottom-up under pressure.
FWIW, I can now drift it using a hammer and a brass drift punch. Maybe it was just seized up in one spot. I'm gonna shoot it in properly tommorow morning.
ETA- Try taking a piece of super-fine-grit sandpaper, a scotch-brite, or maybe a piece of steel wool to the side of the sight you boogered up. Maybe you can get the brass marks off. If that doesnt work, try one of those Birchwood-Casey touch-up pens. All you do is clean the surface with alcohol, let it evaporate, then apply the touch-up pen. It'll start to turn black gradually, and when you get it to the shade you want, just dab some water onto it to neutralize the solution. I've redone sights on a Glock and a couple Rugers like this, and they look good-as-new.