User Panel
Posted: 7/10/2004 10:02:46 PM EDT
I am looking for a rail hand guard for my carbine. I have looked at the Knights, and the SIR rails. I have the 14.5 barrel with a soldered flash hider so I cannot use most free float rails. I looked at a GG&G and I like that the top lines up with my A3 upper with no gap. I have not heard much about the GG&G rails, but I like the idea. I like that you can mount the rails where you need them and not where you don't. It seems unique and I like it, but I wondered if anybody has any experience with them.
|
|
A few folks around here have used them with good results, but they haven't been as popular as other offerings. Personally, I think they fill a niche, and I plan on buying one for my next project. They're more configurable than any other option, I think.
|
|
Too many damned screws for me. I like GG&G's products, their rail handguard's versatility comes at a price though.
|
|
|
|
Why? |
|
|
We've sold quite a few of the GGG mod rails and have had excellent results and feedback from them. We use them on our main demo rifle. Ours is getting pretty beat up and we have had no instances of the screws backing out.
Jeff |
|
I like the TROY because it has less screws and think the fit and finish is a little nicer (personal opinion).. C4 |
||
|
I personally feel the GG&G has a fit and feel that is every bit as nice as any other forearm. My advice is to actually handle and look at it before deciding. You'll be sold.
|
|
Unfortunately that never seems to happen. Finding a dealer that's local that has all that kind of stuff in stock is pretty rare. |
|
|
This is true. GG&G treats their dealers pretty badly (IMHO) that is one reason why you don't see more of us stocking their products... C4 |
||
|
Grant,
I have to agree. My one order with them was a nightmare. First I was told it had shipped, then I was told they could not find my order and it had never shipped! No real apology, just excuses that I'm a small time guy and they have larger customers they have to deal with. I would be very hesitant to ever deal with them again! GIFFMANN |
|
Until the Troy MRF came along, the GG&G rail was the only one of its kind. I have one, and I like it. It's well built and very solid. I can see where the screws might be an issue if you're constantly adding/removing panels and rails. But for me, once I decided where I wanted my sling mount, light and vertical foregrip, I've never had to move the rails. Just be sure to get some loctite for the screws.
Take a look at the Troy MRF. It may suit your needs as well. |
|
Anyone have any pics of the Troy rail installed?
Is it true it doesn't require removal of the front sight? |
|
|
Yes. |
|
|
Ditto. Nightmare all the way. |
|||
|
Gee, I used to think it was just me.... C4 |
|
|
Well the GG&G offers rails in all 12 clock positions. I just wish that someone else would offer something just as flexible. |
|
|
The GG&G forend can mount rails in 8 clock positions (octogonal). It should be noted, however, that you may not be able to use adjacent mounting positions. For example, you can't mount a vertical foregrip at 6:00, and light at 4:30 - there isn't enough room. There are ways around this though: use the provided offset rail; or mount the vertical grip on the rear half of the forend, and the light on the front half.
|
|
actually with the offsett mount, you can achieve all positions (octagonal plus 4 offset positions). It's true about the adjacent positions but the sheer flexibility of the forearm had me sold.
|
|
|
That's basically what I was thinking, that I can remove the rails I don't need. |
|
|
I'll post pics of mine soon. I hated the wait but what when I did recieve it, I was impressed. The versatility and ease of changing configurations is simply amazing. Glad to see that everyone enjoys their G&G forearm as much as I do.
|
|
So if the dealers all hate dealing with them, who DOES sell these things, and does anyone have them in stock?
|
|
Norman74, try these guys. If CMMG does not have them then maybe ADCO does. However, ADCO is closed for a week while they are at Camp Perry. Be sure to post pics when you get yours. |
|
|
I will agree that the customer service leaves something to be desired...they answer their phones great but the waiting times for a new product are often longer than they let on. Personally, I've gotten rather spoiled with the GG&G forearm and can't see going to anything else.
|
|
Jeff,
About the GG&G 1. Do Tango down covers work on it? Do Tangos work on all major brand rails? 2. All the pics I have seen have the round disk just behind the front sight, forgive my ignorance, is this called a "handguard receiver". All the other rail pics Troy, Larue, DD have this removed. Does this assembly get milled off or is it pinned? I think it looks cleaner missing. 3. This may sound stupid, but have any of you weight crazy guys done any scaling with this rail system, I don't think I have seen any. Any weights with bare minimum rails installed? Thanks |
|
I like mine and nothing has come loose on it. My only observation is that some folks may not want all that modularity, but like the way it attaches to the barrel.
That is why I also find the Troy handguard appealing. Will the Troy HG system be offered for a 20" barrel? I am in for one if that is available now or in the next year. Here are eight pics of my GG&G rail. photos.ar15.com/WS_Content/ImageGallery/ThumbnailView.asp?iGalleryUnq=1423 Here's all the pieces |
|
Nope, several times a year I say I'm taking them off the site and will be done. And everytime I say that I get a huge backorder from 8 months ago..... Not worth the hassle, which is too bad because I think GG&G stuff is better made than KAC, ARMS, and Troy. |
||
|
So... I'm in the market for a FF rail forend for my M4. What I'm wondering is with all of those screws... doesn't that just increase the chance of the rail shifting? I will be mounting an eotech 552 on this rail so I'm concerned about that. As of right now the front runner is the Troy MRF-C (standard M4 FF). I'm also considering holding on because the MRF is a new product and I'm wondering if an improvement will come out soon. I remember reading a thread on someone altering their SPR rail to tighten it up.
Also... recently just made my first order through Adco... you guys are VERY fast! Thank You! The package was on my doorstep before the USPS acknowlegded receiving it. Kind of defeats the purpose of a tracking number, but I was pleasently surprised. |
|
IM CURIOUS,DOES ANYBODY ON THIS THREAD KNOW THE DIAMETERS OF THE G,G AND G HANDGUARD VERSUS THE TROY,I LIKE BOTH BUT THE TROY LOOKS ALOT BIGGER THAN THE GG AND G. THANKS
|
|
I'll take some measurements and post them when I have a chance.
Update: OK, here's what I have on the GG&G Modular Forend: width with panels on each side: 2.587" width with rails on each side: 2.472" height with rails on top and bottom: 2.448" I don't have panels on the top of mine, so I don't have top to bottom measurements for that. The width measurements with panels include the ribs or ridges, the "tallest" parts of the panel. |
|
Yep, same thing happened here. My first order and probably my last; jerked me around. "back ordered.......end of the month, next week, in a few days, on its way, give a few more days, oops - didn't ship" BS. I finally spoke to a real nice lady in shipping that knew what the heck she was doing and got my part to me. |
|
|
Does the GG&G forearm have some type of retaining system to keep it from rotating around the barrel nut, like the Troy MRF does?
|
|
srschick,
The GG&G MTFFF does not have a retaining device. It utilizes good ole fashion torque to stay in place, once you spend the time to line it all up just right. We have had one on a Demo gun, then moved it to a Simunitions setup, and it finally jumped onto a customers gun recently b/c we've been waiting for our restocking order to arrive. It has served admirably in all three setups, through thousands of rounds, and many demonstrations and training cycles. Haven't had any screws back out to date (a little loctite goes a long way). We have our first MRFs arriving next week and while we've played around a bit with Steve Troy's demo MRF's, we look forward to field testing them and comparing the setups as we stock up on TI's MRFs as well. I can understand a lot of the dealers' frustrations regarding GG&G, but they do turn out a good product, and we are proud to offer what is an excellent option and a GREAT VALUE to our customers. When you consider the integral heatshields, offset light mount, and the ability to go "slick" if you dont need picatinny covering every inch of the forend, $225 buys you a lot of forend! We dealers will handle the frustrations with GG&G behind the scenes- you guys can focus on the qualities of the different systems that are out there on their physical merits. Right now, we're stuck with the lineup off accessory rails in stock, but should have some more complete systems soon... we hope!! Joe |
|
I agree with you SKD! $225 buys a lot ! I have had mine over a year and a half now. I still believe it is the best value going. GG&G does some really good work and it is like nothing else out there. The modularity sells this thing and the quality sells a few more.
Has anyone heard about a 12" or 9" version coming out? |
|
|
|
My next build is a mid length and I'm interested in this hand guard if GG&G decides to build it. I have this and the YHM carbine handguards. I prefer the GG7G hands down to the YHM, although the YHM works as advertised.
|
|
Sign up for the ARFCOM weekly newsletter and be entered to win a free ARFCOM membership. One new winner* is announced every week!
You will receive an email every Friday morning featuring the latest chatter from the hottest topics, breaking news surrounding legislation, as well as exclusive deals only available to ARFCOM email subscribers.
AR15.COM is the world's largest firearm community and is a gathering place for firearm enthusiasts of all types.
From hunters and military members, to competition shooters and general firearm enthusiasts, we welcome anyone who values and respects the way of the firearm.
Subscribe to our monthly Newsletter to receive firearm news, product discounts from your favorite Industry Partners, and more.
Copyright © 1996-2024 AR15.COM LLC. All Rights Reserved.
Any use of this content without express written consent is prohibited.
AR15.Com reserves the right to overwrite or replace any affiliate, commercial, or monetizable links, posted by users, with our own.