A very good friend of mine is looking to buy his first AR. He wants to start out with a quality gun. I had initially mentioned getting an upper from BCM and letting me help him put together a lower, but he is adamant about buying a complete rifle. He doesn't need a barrel longer than 16", wants a collapsing stock, and railed forearm. The purpose would be a general SHTF/home defense carbine.
I have used the DD lite rails on my last 2 builds. I have been extremely pleased with them. If I were buying the same gun for my self I would get a Daniel Defense middy, based on my experience with their products and their reputation here. He is a Marine and very proficient with iron sights. I am thinking he would appreciate the extra couple inches of sight radius from the mid-length. Also, he is 6'3", and could probably make use of a couple inches more forearm.
The DD comes with a fixed rear sight. How good are these? How would they compare to a flip up back up like MI? (What I have on mine) How would they compare to the A2 that he is used to?
He found a Sig 516 Patrol for sale locally for $200 less than the DD. These haven't been out long, and I haven't heard much about them. I did read that they use a proprietary bolt carrier that eliminated the carrier tilt problem experienced in earlier piston guns. He has not expressed any interest in suppressing it, but the Sig would have an advantage there. The Sig doesn't come with iron sights, but does come with a red dot. What do y'all think about the sig red dot?
Quick comparison:
Weight: Sig- 7lbs 4.8 oz DD- 6lbs 12.2 oz
Barrel: Sig- 1:7 chrome lined DD- 1:7 Chrome lined, cold hammer forged
Gas: Sig-Carbine Piston 3 position DD- Mid length
Bolt: Sig- ? DD- High pressure test
Chamber: Sig-556 DD- 556
Warranty: Sig- Life? DD- Life?
Price: Sig $1200 (local dealer) DD- $1429 AIM
Standard Accessories:
Sig: Aluminum GI mag, MagPul MOE stock, MOE grip, Sig red dot
DD: PMag, DD A1.5 rear sight, MOE stock, DD vertical grip.
Sig 556 Patrol
DD M4 V3
Please correct anything I said that was false. Feel free to add any info you think will be helpful to my friend. If you know of another AR in the same price range that would be better, speak up please. All technical comments welcome. I'm sending him a link to this thread.
Thank You