Ok, I ran out of ideas on this one, so I'm throwing this out there for ideas/advice.

I got like $1000 in merry money / santa dollars to spend at Kay Jewelers before June.

Now, The Wife says she doesn't want another diamond, so thats out.
I was thinkin of picking up an Omega watch, but those are not covered under the promotion.

What would be the best 'bang for the buck' to get from one of these places? I seem to recall that diamonds have a huge markup and watches have a small markup at these Mall stores.
I'd even get some gold coins if they carried them.

I know this is vague, but any ideas would be nice.  Just trying to maximize my value for these things before I give up and ebay them.
Oh, and they work at any of that chain, JBRobinson,  Shaws, Kays, etc.

If they carry Swarovski Crystal, get a few of those.  Neat for decorating the home.