User Panel
Posted: 1/29/2006 8:24:34 AM EDT
news.yahoo.com/s/nm/20060129/pl_nm/iraq_usa_stoploss_dc
can anyone in the know tell us if this really does have a terrible effect on morale, or is the media exaggerating things as usual? |
|
|
I would guess it would cause lower moral to some degree, it would seem natural.
I read that they are also consider "reduceing" the numbers in the army reserves within a few years, if that makes sense........ |
|
Stop loss has been in effect since 9-11. There were some guys challenging the stop loss policy but recently a judge threw the case out. I believe that is where that number came in .
|
|
When I came in 1998 my AFSC was in stop loss. Stayed that way for about 3 years on and off. Not only does it has a horrible affect on morale, it works a number on peoples work ethic as well.
|
|
It still is. I would've been disappointed if I was placed on stop loss but I wouldn't have an issue with it. I signed up & agreed to the possibility of serving more than the anticipated 4 years. It's the same with being called back up - I agreed to that possibility in the contract I voluntarily signed. So, it's still very much an all volunteer military. |
|
|
It's freaking amazing. I'd be glad to rejoin the AF either in the reserves or regular component, but due to a relatively minor screw-up in the way my DD214 was written, they won't take me.
Freakish. CJ |
|
That's interesting. What did they screw up on your 214 that would prevent you from serving? |
|
|
When i enlisted they explained stop-loss to me in my contract(read the fine print) Units and soldiers in them are routinely stop-lossed when the unit recieves MOB orders. You get released after your unit returns to CONUS. Some guys get pissed about, it didnt bother me though, if they leave the service because of it, good ridance, we dont need half-steppers.
|
|
Damn....that would really rub me wrong as a "volunteer". I wouldn't condemn any soldier who switched their status to "conscientious objector" after they fullfilled their initial term. Any individual who put their ass on the line and served is a hero in my book and don't owe anyone jackshit after that. So what is the purpose of the contract if the government doesn't have to honor it?
|
|
My friend got stop lossed. He's going back to Iraq in October. I'm sure it pissed him off, but when I talked to him he seemed okay with it.
|
|
The government does have to honor it, it is in effect for 8 years after you sign it. During the IRR part of your 8 year obligation, you can be 'un-I'RRed. They can also refuse to release you into the IRR and force you to stay on active duty untill you complete your intial 8 year enlistment. Your initial term is 8 years. They havn't served their intial term until 8 years have passed, regardless of whatever combination of active, reserve and IRR it includes. After 8 years, you don't owe jackshit anymore and they can't touch you. Before that, if you are reactivated and refuse, you are nothing but a sack of shit as you signed the contract. |
|
|
I almost got stop-lossed in 2001. My LT. kept forgetting to request replacement medics for those that were ETSing. I heard my plt. SSgt. hassle him about it. When I was due to ETS they said that I was going to have to stay on for a few more months, I was really pissed because I had already payed my first month of rent at a new apartment stateside, and this was all because of an ate up LT. I told the CO as much and he helped me out. I didn't end up staying, but my platoon eneded up being short and understrength for awhile. I felt sorry for 'em, but I was ready to go. I had been there for almost a year and a half already.
|
|
The re-enlistment code got goofed up on my 214. There was no valid reason for me to receive a code starting in a 2. If it had been typed as a 1 like it should have been, I'd have gone back in many years ago.
My requests that I made several times over the years for a review went NOWHERE....because the people I asked didn't know the right answer. Now I could get a review board to evaluate the situation, but am I really going to do that now when I'm 40 and my job is starting to get me somewhere, finally? Would I sign up for the reserves knowing that I'd probably be activated for active duty the day I got out of tech school? I just don't know if I'm really ready to do that. I can't go back to 1988. Would I if I could? CJ |
|
"The re-enlistment code got goofed up on my 214. There was no valid reason for me to receive a code starting in a 2. If it had been typed as a 1 like it should have been, I'd have gone back in many years ago."
The national guard will submit a waiver to the national guard bureau for even an re 4 from any branch "other than the army or national guard", depending on the narrative reason for it, and they approve a lot of them. Less than re 4, 3 or lower should be a lot easier with them. IF you still care to serve, talk to a national guard recruiter. I have been attempting to re enlist into the guard with a bad re code from the navy, medical, since june '04, I have a good discharge from the army, but I was in the navy last and that's what they go by. Anyhow, it's all about talking to a recruiter willing to assist with a waiver. I eventually talked to 1 that would with the va national guard and passed a meps physical thursday, and a waiver will be submitted 1st of the week for God willing approval or disaproval, that should be 3 weeks and I'll know. If approved I'll be re enlisting into the va. guard, infantry or medic. I'm 39 and will be 40 in feb., so i know how it is at this age but it's doable.. |
|
|
|
|
meps was crowded the other day when I was there, 1 guy was older than me, he was 41. But that said, it would be different for the people who have been serving and were preparing to be discharged.
|
|
|
|
|
I was just at MEPS on saturday. Had a real old looking guy there. Must have been near 40. Had a prior service navy guy and maybe 4 prior service army. One of the army guys was going marines. Some poor bastard had his paperwork misplaced so he sat in a waiting room for 5-6 hours and no one knew he was there. Someone walking past a few times noticed he had been there forever and did something.
|
|
|
Punisher BS, they are extending people I fulfilled my original 8 yr obligation, I got 12 years and I was legally out past my ETS, when i got extended. I'm not complaining after Iraq, I decided to stay in for my full 20. But they are extending people, I know guys that had their 20yr letter and submitted their paperwork to retire, that where extended and sent to Iraq.
|
|
We have a 43 year old SSgt in my shop..got out of the AF sometime in the 1980's came back in 2001 as SrA. He was probably the oldest SrA in the AF. Doubt they would let you back in nowadays...the AF is being rightsized... |
|
|
You came in after 9-11 then you should know that this might happion to you. The Marine corpe has not stared it yet. I know because I'v got untill March 31,2006 .
|
|
From part 9 c of the DD form 4, enlistment contract:
“In the event of war, my enlistment in the Armed Forces continues until six (6) months after the war ends, unless my enlistment is ended sooner by the president of the United States.” We are at war with the terrorist! I have been stop loss twice in 23 years. It’s part of the job. Get over it! |
|
From another forum:
Courtesy sneakerboots. _________________ |
||||
|
if the pussies don't want to go ....SEND ME!
I wish I could have enlisted when I was 18, Hearing issues. The goober next to me in MEPS had coke bottle bottom glasses and he GOT IN!! I may be 36 but I am in great shape, and can shoot pretty damned good too! Id rather see the enemy, cause you cant shoot what you cant see! |
|
Hell, it is no big deal. I got involuntary extended back in 1976 and there wasn’t a war going on. They simply didn’t have a replacement for me and it was deemed that my job was critical to the operation of the unit. The term they used on my extension orders was “Convenience of the Government” which means they can generally do just about what ever they wanted. When they extended me they didn’t even know how long it was going to be for. As it turned out I stayed an extra 23 days. Sure I was a little disappointed, but I still had a good time. Back then no one thought anything about you going to the club and drinking yourself silly every night. Everyone knew that I got extended and they all bought me drinks!
|
|
Then they were under their second or third contract. If you keep signing contracts, they can keep extending your ass. |
|
|
Big deal, we've got an upcoming rotation to Iraq coming this summer. People dont realize that no matter who or where you are, if your unit is slated to deploy, youre gonna deploy with it. Stop loss/move is over 3 months after you return from where you are going. Im glad we have the stoploss, most people end up re-enlisting overseas to get the tax free bonus instead of mopping around like an abused puppydog waiting to ETS when tey get home.
|
|
Its in the contract and your recruiter is required by law to ensure you understand how stop loss works before you sign. I have my contract in the drawer next to me, it has my initials right next to the stop loss agreement. It is all volunteer. |
|
|
That is not true, I am on my second enlistment, and kept my same obligated service date as the first enlistment. However, you are obligated 8 years, no matter what you sign up for. |
||
|
I've seen older SrA, but they were NCOs once. |
|
|
Boo fuckin hoo............It happens for a reason. They cant afford to let highly experienced people out without replacements during wartime. It happened to me. I had to say a significant amount of time in theater. No big deal. If its a problem you should have thought twice before you put your signature to paper. |
||
|
Duh, read the post just above yours. It IS part of the contract. |
|
|
Sign up for the ARFCOM weekly newsletter and be entered to win a free ARFCOM membership. One new winner* is announced every week!
You will receive an email every Friday morning featuring the latest chatter from the hottest topics, breaking news surrounding legislation, as well as exclusive deals only available to ARFCOM email subscribers.
AR15.COM is the world's largest firearm community and is a gathering place for firearm enthusiasts of all types.
From hunters and military members, to competition shooters and general firearm enthusiasts, we welcome anyone who values and respects the way of the firearm.
Subscribe to our monthly Newsletter to receive firearm news, product discounts from your favorite Industry Partners, and more.
Copyright © 1996-2024 AR15.COM LLC. All Rights Reserved.
Any use of this content without express written consent is prohibited.
AR15.Com reserves the right to overwrite or replace any affiliate, commercial, or monetizable links, posted by users, with our own.