User Panel
Posted: 9/2/2021 1:16:29 PM EDT
I just bought a brand new All-Clad D5 12.5 inch skillet and a D3 8 QT stock pot.
Both are cupped so that the middle is about 1/8" higher than the edges and all liquids pool around the perimeter. The skillet was also badly warped right out of the box so that it rocks on my glass stove top. I returned the skillet and the replacement was warped just as badly. I had thought that All-Clad was supposed to be tier 1 but I have cheap chinese crap that is perfectly flat.... What am I missing? Before everyone says just use cast iron, I have plenty of cast iron but also like to use a stainless pan for things that will damage the seasoning. |
|
Quoted: Before everyone says just use cast iron, I have plenty of cast iron but also like to use a stainless pan for things that will damage the seasoning. View Quote Use enameled cast iron (Le Creuset)? |
|
|
I have a number of All-Clad pots and pans and they are excellent. Mine are close to 20 years old. I have no idea about current quality.
You could contact them through their site and tell them what you have experienced: https://www.all-clad.com/ I think of mine as top tier build quality but not luxury style. |
|
In to learn stuff. Thinking about the very same.
(and in for the hilarity of Arf approved tier one cookware to match my Lamborghini, for you know, cooking up quick snacks on the yacht ) |
|
Covid AllClad.
I have the Emeril set which is the Chicom made AllClad, It's been fine. One large saucepan is a little domed on the bottom and I haven't got around to messing with fixing it yet as it doesn't get used much. |
|
Quoted: my glass stove top View Quote Complaining about All-Clad while using a glass induction stove... |
|
Another business destroyed by a union
|
|
Have had a set for about 15 years, they are nice but sometimes a pain to clean
|
|
Return it. Even the best stuff can have defective pieces slip through.
And consider Tramontina tri-ply clad (not tri-ply base). 90+% as good as All-Clad for a third of the price. Or at least it was when I bought mine. |
|
|
The answer you seek is Mauviel. Be prepared for sticker shock.
|
|
I bought one of their copper core pans to try out last year. They are expensive, but I noticed a dramatic difference. Food cooked better and more evenly. It can be a bitch to clean sometimes, but it's held up well so far, but at that price I'd expect it to.
|
|
|
There is nothing wrong with a good-quality glass-top stove. If you can't cook on one, it's not the stove's fault. I've had them in three different houses for 18 years. The current one is the best I've used. None were induction. I'm sure there are some crappy ones, of course, and that might be where a lot of the bad rep comes from. My first one was okay, but it took a little getting used to. Each time I've moved, they've gotten better. |
|
My wife has an entire All-Clad set. It's excellent quality stuff. Never noticed a problem like yours OP.
|
|
Quoted: Return it. Even the best stuff can have defective pieces slip through. And consider Tramontina tri-ply clad (not tri-ply base). 90+% as good as All-Clad for a third of the price. Or at least it was when I bought mine. View Quote I have a Tramontina stock pot that is really well made. |
|
Quoted: Another business destroyed by a union Is there any evidence for this? My all clad stuff is great, a few years old though |
|
Also, like most other companies, they have product tiers. The lower tier products are made overseas, the high end stuff like the copper core is actually made in the US, at made in the US prices.
|
|
My USA made D3s are 10 years old and still perfect. Contact all clad.
They do have factory seconds out in the wild. |
|
|
Mine are flat, and still work great after several years of use.
|
|
Quoted: There is nothing wrong with a good-quality glass-top stove. If you can't cook on one, it's not the stove's fault. I've had them in three different houses for 18 years. The current one is the best I've used. None were induction. I'm sure there are some crappy ones, of course, and that might be where a lot of the bad rep comes from. My first one was okay, but it took a little getting used to. Each time I've moved, they've gotten better. View Quote |
|
I have plenty of AC. I rarely use it these days, preferring to use cast iron. Some of my AC is warped - I think from high heat. Have you ever seen the steel skillets they use in restaurants? They generally warped all to hell.
|
|
Quoted: Aside from being super slow to adjust temperature and incompatible with cast iron, they are perfectly acceptable. View Quote How is a glass-top incompatible with cast iron? I have occasion to use a glass-top (non-induction) frequently with cast iron. More often, I use an induction glass-top with cast iron. Standard glass tops suck, but they do work. |
|
Glass tops can really screw up some cookware.
Think it has to do with localized heating causing the pan bottoms to warp at high temps. |
|
|
Quoted: Regular electric glass top stoves suck. Induction stoves generally work very well. View Quote View All Quotes View All Quotes Quoted: Quoted: Complaining about All-Clad while using a glass induction stove... Our last house we had a 5k thermador induction cooktop. No gas available and that was the best. I would call them or return it. The D5 series shouldn’t have a problem. Other than the nonstick pans our all clad has been excellent. |
|
All-Clad is tier one.
You bought someone’s returned merch after they warped them. |
|
Quoted: How is a glass-top incompatible with cast iron? I have occasion to use a glass-top (non-induction) frequently with cast iron. More often, I use an induction glass-top with cast iron. Standard glass tops suck, but they do work. View Quote View All Quotes View All Quotes Quoted: Quoted: Aside from being super slow to adjust temperature and incompatible with cast iron, they are perfectly acceptable. How is a glass-top incompatible with cast iron? I have occasion to use a glass-top (non-induction) frequently with cast iron. More often, I use an induction glass-top with cast iron. Standard glass tops suck, but they do work. It's not. I've used cast-iron on mine for years. My first one was slow to adjust, but my second and third have been much better. Even slow to adjust, you could easily compensate for it. |
|
|
Quoted: I have a number of All-Clad pots and pans and they are excellent. Mine are close to 20 years old. I have no idea about current quality. You could contact them through their site and tell them what you have experienced: https://www.all-clad.com/ I think of mine as top tier build quality but not luxury style. View Quote 25 years in on ours and they’ve been great. |
|
So you care enough to buy allclad and then complain it’s deficiencies... then cook on a glass top stove?
|
|
Overpriced. For the price of one all clad Pan you could buy a dozen non stick pans.
|
|
My D3 are fine, best pan and pots.
All Clad stand behind their products, keep contacting them, they will make it right. BTW, where did you bought your D5 from? I stay away from the All-Clad factory seconds thou. |
|
I bought a Viking set at Sams Club for our new induction top. Turns out our old Farberware works fine. Viking seems pretty good, but the price dropped and they cleared them out a month after we got ours....
|
|
Poor care can ruin anything. I got about 15 years out of my skillet-then somehow managed to warp it. That said 15years vs an semi annual non stick
|
|
Quoted: There is nothing wrong with a good-quality glass-top stove. If you can't cook on one, it's not the stove's fault. I've had them in three different houses for 18 years. The current one is the best I've used. None were induction. I'm sure there are some crappy ones, of course, and that might be where a lot of the bad rep comes from. My first one was okay, but it took a little getting used to. Each time I've moved, they've gotten better. View Quote View All Quotes View All Quotes Quoted: Quoted: Quoted: Complaining about All-Clad while using a glass induction stove... There is nothing wrong with a good-quality glass-top stove. If you can't cook on one, it's not the stove's fault. I've had them in three different houses for 18 years. The current one is the best I've used. None were induction. I'm sure there are some crappy ones, of course, and that might be where a lot of the bad rep comes from. My first one was okay, but it took a little getting used to. Each time I've moved, they've gotten better. There might not be anything wrong with a glass top electric stove, but cooking on one sucks horribly compared to gas. |
|
|
|
Quoted: Induction works quite well in my limited experience, the older glass top electric elements suck. View Quote View All Quotes View All Quotes |
|
Quoted: Honestly, vintage Revere Ware pots and pans are tits. View Quote I have a ~20 year old 10" Revere Ware stainless steel copper bottomed skillet (chinese) that I use all the time. It is perfectly flat and works great on the crappy glass top stove that came with my house. I just got off the phone with All-Clad. They are sending a shipping label to return it and try a third one (first return was with the retailer)... I am not holding my breath. |
|
My 20+ year old stuff has been great.
I also have 40+ hear old Farberware that has held up very well, the stainless with copper insert in the bottom. I think that I bought them at Caldor's in the 70's. |
|
AR15.COM is the world's largest firearm community and is a gathering place for firearm enthusiasts of all types.
From hunters and military members, to competition shooters and general firearm enthusiasts, we welcome anyone who values and respects the way of the firearm.
Subscribe to our monthly Newsletter to receive firearm news, product discounts from your favorite Industry Partners, and more.
Copyright © 1996-2024 AR15.COM LLC. All Rights Reserved.
Any use of this content without express written consent is prohibited.
AR15.Com reserves the right to overwrite or replace any affiliate, commercial, or monetizable links, posted by users, with our own.