I've also had very good results with Federal's 158 gr American Eagle load - as well as their 158 gr JSP "Champion" load which gives me the same results.
Federal 158 gr JSP = 1,807 fps average velocity in a 20" barrel and an SD of 13.
I got almost identical performance with a 158 gr XTP using 16 grains of Win 296, producing 1805 fps average velocity, but with a higher SD of 32.
My preferred hand load is the 125 gr XTP on top of 20 hrs of Win 296. I have loads of data on this, and the average has been extremely consistent with the 10 shot averages only varying between 2,168 fps and 2,172 fps with SDs varying from 14 to 17 fps.
The above velocities are in my 20" Rossi Model 92 rifle. I also have a 24" Rossi Model 92 rifle, and the increase in velocity from the extra 4" of barrel are on the order of 40 fps for both loads.
----
Trajectory wise:
Federal 158 gr JSP at 1,807 fps: 1178 ft pounds of energy at the muzzle, and 570 ft pounds at 170 yards.
With a 150 yard zero, it is 3" high at 50 yards, (max trajectory is 3.7" high at 90 yards), 3.5" high at 100 yards, 2.25" high at 125 yards, 0.0" at 150 yards, and 4.0" low at 170 yards.
Hornady 158 gr XTP at 2,210 fps: 1,378 ft pounds of energy at the muzzle, and 561 ft pounds at 170 yards.
With a 170 yard zero, it is 2.7" high at 50 yards, 3.7" high (maximum trajectory) at 100 yards, 3.2" high at 125 yards, 1.8" high at 150 yards, 0.0" low at 170 yards, and 4" low at 200 yards (where it has 464 ft pounds of energy.
-----
Someone commented on not being impressed with the energy of the 125 gr load, and I'm not in agreement, at least with the 125 gr XTP, as the loss is just 9 ft pounds at 170 yards, compared to the 158 gr Federal JSP bullet.
The lighter bullet does flatten the trajectory a bit, and allows an extra 20 yards in terms of point blank trajectory.
Accuracy with both loads runs 2.0" to 2.5" for five shot groups at 100 yards, using a Lyman 17AHB front sight and a Marbles Standard Tang sight with a Merit #3 or #4 adjustable aperture.