Warning

 

Close
Confirm Action

Are you sure you wish to do this?

Cancel Confirm
AR15.COM
Armory Sponsor
5/30/2011 10:04:53 AM EDT
Hey guys, I loaded up some .45 auto over the weekend and shot a few rounds a little bit ago and I noticed after shooting my arms had specks of gunpowder on them from the powder not burning completely. Is this normal? The load was 6.0 grains of Power Pistol with Fed large pistol primers and 230 gr lead projectiles. I had very good results as far as accuracy goes but why isn't the powder burning completely? Thanks!

 
5/30/2011 10:44:54 AM EDT
[#1]
Quoted:
Hey guys, I loaded up some .45 auto over the weekend and shot a few rounds a little bit ago and I noticed after shooting my arms had specks of gunpowder on them from the powder not burning completely. Is this normal? The load was 6.0 grains of Power Pistol with Fed large pistol primers and 230 gr lead projectiles. I had very good results as far as accuracy goes but why isn't the powder burning completely? Thanks!  


    I do not use that powder , but I see that with Unique , maybe Bullseye .  Yhis can be improved with those 2 powders by raising the powder charge / pressure , if you are below max .

    Do not know about your powder ?  Where are you , in the range between min and max ?  Are you getting any smoke / soot on the outside of the brass ?

God bless
Wyr
5/30/2011 10:46:56 AM EDT
[#2]
Power Pistol really performs with heavier loads. The lead bullets you're using have less friction than a jacketed bullet, of the same weight, so the full charge probably isn't getting a chance to burn completely.



With lead projectiles, I've had better results using charges of Red Dot or Unique.
5/30/2011 11:09:16 AM EDT
[#3]
You MIGHT need a heavier crimp.  Some powders don't do well in some calibers, so you might need to change powders.  I experimented with Blue Dot in 40 S&W, one day I was shooting behind a shooting table that was painted white, I was stunned by how much unburned powder was on the table when I finished, it really showed up on the white paint.
5/30/2011 11:27:25 AM EDT
[#4]
I'm using a pretty light crimp so that could be the issue. I have noticed alot of soot from this powder as well so I may just need to change powders. Thanks for your input guys it is much appreciated!
5/30/2011 11:40:34 AM EDT
[#5]
Incomplete ignition is because the pressure is low and it is pressure which assures 100% ignition.  Power Pistol is too slow for .45 ACP with lead.  Peak pressure happens before the bullet moves in most pistol rounds, if below about 15,000 PSI, you can have unburnt particles.



If you are shooting SWC bullets, a bit LONGER OAL can increase the pressure since the bullet doesn't get to "run up" before hitting the throat/leade.  This increases the bullet pull but it COULD cause reliability issues. Since most are sized 0.452, this is possible even with OALs less than maximum.  I go for 0.015" of the first driving band outside of the case, this assures crimping will form a ledge engraved into the driving band, preventing telescoping.
5/30/2011 11:50:06 AM EDT
[#6]
PP won't burn as well as some other powders.  I use QuickLoad and the burn rate for say HP38 is near 100% and PP is about 80% - if that.  Just the nature of that powder.

It will give you really good velocity, but burn rate - not so much.
6/1/2011 9:46:55 AM EDT
[#7]
I've got a question along the same lines.
Loading .45 cal Rainier plated 185gr truncated cone flat point over Titegroup 5.2 gr (max load for the 180gr LFP listed in Hodgdons data)
My issue is the same, lots of powder kernels left in the case and all over, and a velocity of only 800fps, Hodgdons data shows 950fps. I believe it is from excessive case volume, I'm seating them right back where the corner of the bullet meets the case. 1.220" OAL.

Can I raise the powder charge until I get the velocity up there? A little nervous about blowing up my GSR
6/1/2011 12:02:32 PM EDT
[#8]



Quoted:


I've got a question along the same lines.

Loading .45 cal Rainier plated 185gr truncated cone flat point over Titegroup 5.2 gr (max load for the 180gr LFP listed in Hodgdons data)

My issue is the same, lots of powder kernels left in the case and all over, and a velocity of only 800fps, Hodgdons data shows 950fps. I believe it is from excessive case volume, I'm seating them right back where the corner of the bullet meets the case. 1.220" OAL.



Can I raise the powder charge until I get the velocity up there? A little nervous about blowing up my GSR


5.5 grains is the max for 200 grain jacketed.  Remember, this fast powder needs a bit of pressure to function.  Plated bullets don't have high engraving force.  A truncated cone bullet behaves differently than a round nose but it being plated, this is nothing.  



 
6/1/2011 10:35:54 PM EDT
[#9]
I'm going to guess its because its too slow of a burning powder for your application... its even slower than universal which is considered "slow" for normal 45acp loads.

If you load it hotter and put more crimp on the round it will probably burn better... still I'd switch to a faster burning powder if the unburnt stuff bothers you.

MIke.
Armory Sponsor